VOTING THREAD: MFC 1990-2020 Re-draft | WINNER REVEALED

Which team would win (SEE POST #249 for line-ups)?

  • Proper Gander

    Votes: 10 52.6%
  • Dark Avenger

    Votes: 9 47.4%

  • Total voters
    19

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Crimson Azure

Moderator
Jul 16, 2007
19,274
13,852
Mariana Trench
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Lamb on the spit
TEAM DEMON 16
FB: Neville Jetta - Alistair Nicholson - Paul Hopgood
HB: Rohan Bail - Craig Nettelbeck - Daniel Bell
C: Marcus Seecamp - Colin Sylvia - Nathan Brown
HF: Scott Chisholm - Tom McDonald - Kevin Dyson
FF: Russell Robertson - Darren Cuthbertson - Paul Johnson
R: Jake Spencer - Nathan Jones - Guy Rigoni
IC: Rod Keogh - Robert Pyman - Brent Heaver - Shannon Motlop

TEAM SCHMUTTT
FB: Jay Lockhart - Anthony Ingerson - Dean Terlich
HB: Kyle Cheney - Oscar McDonald - Daniel Ward
C: Ed Langdon - Simon Godfrey - Chris Johnson
HF: Sam Blease - Jesse Hogan - Ricky Petterd
FF: Peter Vardy - Ben Holland - Jamie Bennell
R: Max Gawn - Clayton Oliver - Phil Read
IC: Steven Armstrong - Danny Hughes - Isaac Weetra - Simon Buckley
Would have little faith in either of these back lines. schmuttt dominates through the middle/ruck and the forward line is closer but clearly goes Demon 16

This is a hard one as peak Robbo and Tmac could kick 10 with limited opportunity but Schmutts midfield will maul them. In view of that I'm going Schmutt as his team is going to give the forwards plenty of looks.
 

Demon 16

Brownlow Medallist
Jun 25, 2009
10,773
6,727
Melbourne
AFL Club
Melbourne
I can't see peak Hogan being stopped by that backline and he should get plenty of service from the Gawn/Oliver/Langdon midfield. Robbo might cause some problems for schmuttt's mutts and the Spencil/PJ combo is a big one for Gawny to battle through, but with Vardy and Petterd chiming it I reckon that's enough.

Sorry Demon 16 - I think I just tied it up again. (and I'm over 35 so that can't help you)
Would have little faith in either of these back lines. schmuttt dominates through the middle/ruck and the forward line is closer but clearly goes Demon 16

This is a hard one as peak Robbo and Tmac could kick 10 with limited opportunity but Schmutts midfield will maul them. In view of that I'm going Schmutt as his team is going to give the forwards plenty of looks.
How you think Phil Read and Simon Godfrey take on Jones and Sylvia at their best has me stuffed!?

Look at my other runners I can add to my rotations - they’re everywhere (Rigoni, Dyson, Seecamp.. I’ve got Rod Keogh FFS!).

I’ve gone heavy on team oriented and courageous too (Hopgood, Nathan Brown, Jetta), so can shut down when needed.

At their height, Cuthbertson is only second to Allen Jakovich (and maybe Schwartz and Neitz) in this so my forward line is dominant god damn it!!!!!

Aaaaand my rucks and key defenders... are pretty sh*t actually.
 

Crimson Azure

Moderator
Jul 16, 2007
19,274
13,852
Mariana Trench
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Lamb on the spit
How you think Phil Read and Simon Godfrey take on Jones and Sylvia at their best has me stuffed!?

Look at my other runners I can add to my rotations - they’re everywhere (Rigoni, Dyson, Seecamp.. I’ve got Rod Keogh FFS!).

I’ve gone heavy on team oriented and courageous too (Hopgood, Nathan Brown, Jetta), so can shut down when needed.

At their height, Cuthbertson is only second to Allen Jakovich (and maybe Schwartz and Neitz) in this so my forward line is dominant god damn it!!!!!

Aaaaand my rucks and key defenders... are pretty sh*t actually.
Must admit I did miss Jones for some reason. :drunk: Did refresh myself on a few players from both teams so I could make a more educated descision but no idea how I missed Jones. Still, 1 point after the siren win to schmuttt.

Also, Gawn and Oliver. Perhaps some recent bias but Oliver is one of the best MFC mids I've seen.
 

pjfairbairn

Club Legend
Feb 21, 2011
2,354
2,880
Sydney
AFL Club
Melbourne
How you think Phil Read and Simon Godfrey take on Jones and Sylvia at their best has me stuffed!?

Look at my other runners I can add to my rotations - they’re everywhere (Rigoni, Dyson, Seecamp.. I’ve got Rod Keogh FFS!).

I’ve gone heavy on team oriented and courageous too (Hopgood, Nathan Brown, Jetta), so can shut down when needed.

At their height, Cuthbertson is only second to Allen Jakovich (and maybe Schwartz and Neitz) in this so my forward line is dominant god damn it!!!!!

Aaaaand my rucks and key defenders... are pretty sh*t actually.
FWIW, I think your team is far stronger. Just not strong enough to beat mine.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

dee_mac

Club Legend
Feb 28, 2013
2,012
3,392
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Philadelphia Eagles
How good a matchup is Alastair Nicholson on Dutchy Holland. Worth the price of admission alone. Peak Russell Robertson and Colin Sylvia are having an absolute field day in this match up. Demon 16 for me
 

Remove this Banner Ad