Which KP combo would you take? (Part 2)

[Cynic]

Fremantle though I'd prefer Murphy over Tarrant.

 

[Squizza]

What about...

 

[AndyD]

Is he a Key Position player?

No.

Just because a player does not fit the mold of a big tall key position player does not mean they do not play in the key position.

 

[gandaal]

Just because a player does not fit the mold of a big tall key position player does not mean they do not play in the key position.

No doubt, but that doesn't apply to Johnson. He's a HFF/midfielder plain and simple. Resting at full forward occasionally doesn't make him a full forward.

 

[Mofra]

No doubt, but that doesn't apply to Johnson. He's a HFF/midfielder plain and simple. Resting at full forward occasionally doesn't make him a full forward.

Resting at Full Forward? Fair effort to come second in the Coleman Medal if he is only "resting".

By your logic, he could easily kick 200 goals a year as a full time forward.

 

[gandaal]

Resting at Full Forward? Fair effort to come second in the Coleman Medal if he is only "resting".

By your logic, he could easily kick 200 goals a year as a full time forward.

Didn't Milne kick 50+ goals in 2005?

I doubt you'd find many people claiming that he was the Saints full forward.

 

[borgy]

Didn't Milne kick 50+ goals in 2005?

I doubt you'd find many people claiming that he was the Saints full forward.

Milne play from the pocket, Johnson played from the square and that is a 'Key Position'.

 

[TigerGlory]

Is he a Key Position player?

No.

What about Brad Johnson, how do you rate him?

I would take him above alot of the taller forwards in the competition thank you very much.

 

[gandaal]

What about Brad Johnson, how do you rate him?

I would take him above alot of the taller forwards in the competition thank you very much.

As a player he's one of the top 10 players in the comp. Just don't tell me he's a key forward when he's clearly not.

 

[TigerGlory]

As a player he's one of the top 10 players in the comp. Just don't tell me he's a key forward when he's clearly not.

But he is, and he does a hell of a job than alot of the other tall forwards in the comp.

 

[gandaal]

But he is, and he does a hell of a job than alot of the other tall forwards in the comp.

Bulldogs supporters don't even believe that he's a full forward when they're being honest. In every Best 22 thread on there board for the last two years only 1 in 10 actually put Johnson at full forward.

Unless we're going to completely change the defintion to include every player who plays in the forward line or in defense he's not a key position player

 

[borgy]

Bulldogs supporters don't even believe that he's a full forward when they're being honest. In every Best 22 thread on there board for the last two years only 1 in 10 actually put Johnson at full forward.

Unless we're going to completely change the defintion to include every player who plays in the forward line or in defense he's not a key position player

The only reason we penciled in Johnno at FF was because Darcy has been out. When Darcy comes back he will be our FF.

 

[Mitchell Madness]

Hawks - Gilham/Campbell, DJ, Franklin, Willo

 

[gandaal]

The only reason we penciled in Johnno at FF was because Darcy has been out. When Darcy comes back he will be our FF.

So he isn't you're full forward, Darcy is.

BTW Darcy not being there doesn't explain why he wasn't listed at full forward this time last year when Darcy was clearly gone.

 

[borgy]

So he isn't you're full forward, Darcy is.

BTW Darcy not being there doesn't explain why he wasn't listed at full forward this time last year when Darcy was clearly gone.

If Darcy is our Full Forward then why did you have Robbins penciled in there?
And on Darcy its because he had a question mark over his knee and playing carrer. No one knew how he knee was going to turn up and so far so good.

 

[gandaal]

If Darcy is our Full Forward then why did you have Robbins penciled in there?
And on Darcy its because he had a question mark over his knee and playing carrer. No one knew how he knee was going to turn up and so far so good.

I'm not the one who claimed that Darcy was your full forward. But he fits the bill more than Johnson.