which one do you chose

[barmyarmy]

greg williams

 

[GILLOTINE]

Harvery for me.

20 years of quality footy and at his best was untouchable with the footy, could run all day, couldn't be tagged and racked up the possies when they actually meant something.

 

[Dan]

Tough choice...but I'm going with Judd out of that group

 

[Godzilla!]

Judd. People are forgetting how truly brilliant he was at West Coast. There were people saying that by the time he was finished, he might go down as the greatest player of all time. It was for a reason.

 

[Dazb86]

Simon Black or Robert Harvey. Club loyalty etc.

 

[Claude Balls]

Judd at West Coast was the best of this lot.

Ablett Jr and Williams a shade behind.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

By the end of his career, it will be Gary Ablett Jr.

 

[wavefall21]

At their peak, I'd take Judd, his years in 04-06 are the best I've seen from a midfielder, he was unstoppable in full flight

 

[INSANE]

At their peak, I'd take Judd, his years in 04-06 are the best I've seen from a midfielder, he was unstoppable in full flight

Yeah Judd 04- early 07 was as dominant and talented as any mid.....probably ever.

 

[invinciBlues]

Diesel.

Probably the hardest at the contest of that list and I've never seen better hands or vision under pressure.

 

[Jesse Custer]

I may be proved wrong here but i don't think that Ablett jnr will be as good at the Coast.

Give me Williams, only when Denham is not playing on him though.

 

[barmyarmy]

I may be proved wrong here but i don't think that Ablett jnr will be as good at the Coast.

Give me Williams, only when Denham is not playing on him though.

how diesel has only 3 votes is beyond me clearly the greatest

 

[the distributer]

Strange group.

judd at westcoast for mine, he hasnt been a shadow of that player since he joined carlton though, williams for career.

 

[barmyarmy]

Strange group.

judd at westcoast for mine, he hasnt been a shadow of that player since he joined carlton though, williams for career.

really i dont know what juddy has to do 3 years at carlton 3 b+f 1 brownlow ,2nd in brownlow, and 6th in brownlow ... i think people just expect to much from the great man

 

[the distributer]

really i dont know what juddy has to do 3 years at carlton 3 b+f 1 brownlow ,2nd in brownlow, and 6th in brownlow ... i think people just expect to much from the great man

he was a much better player at westcoast, 2 GFs, brownlow, BaFs, media awards, MVP im guessing, shouldve had another brownlow from those days to IMO, he's been great for you guys too but not as good IMO.

 

[Byron_Clanger]

he was a much better player at westcoast, 2 GFs, brownlow, BaFs, media awards, MVP im guessing, shouldve had another brownlow from those days to IMO, he's been great for you guys too but not as good IMO.

Plus it's easy to look good playing with a bunch of young guys at Carlton, he was dominating at West Coast with the whole midfield in their prime and another Brownlow Medalist

 

[Donakebab]

Plus it's easy to look good playing with a bunch of young guys at Carlton, he was dominating at West Coast with the whole midfield in their prime and another Brownlow Medalist

At the same time, being surrounded by quality players makes the job easier, gives more opportunity to look flash

 

[the distributer]

At the same time, being surrounded by quality players makes the job easier, gives more opportunity to look flash

i dont really think that applys to judd, he's always won his own ball, some of the shit he used to do at WC was just freaking ridiculous.

 

[barmyarmy]

Plus it's easy to look good playing with a bunch of young guys at Carlton, he was dominating at West Coast with the whole midfield in their prime and another Brownlow Medalist

he will be that chris judd like he was at the eagles this year more an outside player but he is now the best inside mid in the comp as well ...so i reckon it has added another beau to the collection

 

[Frothies Mcveigh]

At their peak, Judd. Over their career, Harvey.