which team would u rather?

[sum0005]

They are - The Victorians
1. P Everitt (vc)
2. R Murphy
3. C Judd
4. B Hall
5. S Mitchell
6. B Johnson
7. S West (c)
8. B Caracella
9. L Gilbee
10. F Gehrig
12. M Lappin
13. A Yze
14. L Ball
15. L Hodge
16. J Brown
17. T Johnstone
19. S Grant
21. M Maguire
23. J Leppitsch
24. N Stevens
26. N Dal Santo
29. G Ablett
30. M Scarlett
31. D Fletcher
32. C Bruce
33. A McPhee
34. J White
36. L Power
44. N Lappin
45. C Ling
-----------------------------------------------------------------------The Squad is - The South Australians
1. D Wakelin
2. T Harley
4. A Didak
5. S Thompson
6. B Ottens
7. S Welsh
8. N Bassett
9. T Edwards
11. A Cooney
13. R Biglands
14. S Wakelin
16. W Tredrea (vc)
17. S Dew
18. K Cornes
19. S Burns
20. D Brogan
21. M Wilson
22. K Kingsley
25. ND Brown
26. K McGregor
27. J Rivers
28. J Crouch
29. M Pavlich
30. B Rutten
32. M Ricciuto (c)
34. B Hart
35. C Cornes
36. S Goodwin
------------------------------------------------------------------------
these are the western australians
1. M Gardiner
2. D Gaspar
3. J Carr
4. P Haselby
5. T Lockyer
6. D Banfield
7. C Fletcher
8. J Clement
9. B Cousins (vc)
10. M Carr
11. J Corey
12. G Polak
16. K Bradley
18. L McPharlin
19. D Cox
20. S Black
21. Q Lynch
22. I Perrie
23. D Glass
24. M Coughlan
26. J Longmuir
27. J Ball
28. A Embley
32. P Bell (c)
34. P Medhurst
42. R Haddrill
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
these are the act, nsw, old, tas
1. J Hird (ACT) (vc)
2. A Hamill (ACT)
3. M Voss (QLD) (c)
4. B Mathews (NSW)
5. N Buckley (NT) (vc)
6. M Richardson (TAS)
7. L Hayes (NSW)
8. C Bizzel (QLD)
9. S Crawford (NSW)
10. P Williams (TAS)
11. J Bowden (NT)
12. J Akermanis (QLD)
13. B Voss (QLD)
14. B Rawlings (TAS)
15. M Michael (QLD)
16. B Miller (QLD)
17. D Solomon (NSW)
18. B Green (TAS)
20. C Mooney (NSW)
21. L Barry (NSW)
22. N Riewoldt (QLD)
23. J Kozhitske (NSW)
24. R Robertson (TAS)
26. J Laycock (TAS)
31. B Kirk (NSW)
33. B Hudson (QLD)
41. R Vandenberg (NSW)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------The Indigenous All-Stars -
2. C Johnson
4. G Wanganeen
5. S Burgoyne
6. M Williams
7. P Burgoyne
8. D Wells
9. A McGrath
10. T Cook
11. D Headland
12. C Bateman
15. B Pickett
16. R Clarke
17. A Corrie
18. G Johncock
19. M O'Loughlin
23. A McLeod (c)
27. A Krakouer
28. A Sampi
29. J Murphy
31. P Matera
32. J Farmer
33. D White (vc)
36. A Davey
37. A Goodes
38. M Johnson
41. A Lovett
43. R Hayden
44. D Wirrpunda
45. M Whelan

 

[jo172]

I like the look of the Allies,

Just wondering what has this got to do with the Adelaide Football Club?

 

[Hollow Knight]

The allies for sure.

 

[sum0005]

well the south australian side has alot of adelaide players in it and just wanted to see if everyone on this site chose the south austalian are the better side because they had the adelaide player in it

now if i did the same thing on the st.kilda website or something they will all probably say that the victorian is a better side cause they have st.kilda players in it

 

[babydoll]

there are a few hacks in every other team but just look vics - judd, ball, hodge, ablett, hall, brown etc...

vic team will thrash others by a mile and a half.

 

[*PAF]

NT Boys.

5. N Buckley (NT) (vc)
11. J Bowden (NT)
7. P Burgoyne
16. R Clarke
17. A Corrie
23. A McLeod (c)
36. A Davey
45. M Whelan


Plus pseudo NT

6. B Ottens
26. K McGregor

Not bad for a place of (almost) 200,000 people only hey?

 

[tribey]

The Victorian side hands down.

The Allies looks good at face value, but the likes of Voss, Hird, McLeod and Buckley are not as good as they were a few years ago.

 

[JeffDunne]

now if i did the same thing on the st.kilda website or something they will all probably say that the victorian is a better side cause they have st.kilda players in it

I'd say the Allies

And not because Lenny, Roo, Kosi, Hamill and Voss are in it.

(and you left our best defender out of that team too)

 

[Axl_Rose]

my team would e

G-Unit

tony yaya

lloyd christmas

uncle buck

fiddy cent

and the game if the disloyal prick pulled his head in

 

[Tas]

The Victorian side hands down.

The Allies looks good at face value, but the likes of Voss, Hird, McLeod and Buckley are not as good as they were a few years ago.

Not sure how Voss got into the Allies team given he is Victorian, from Traralgon in the Latrobe Valley. Unless they are allowed to field players not picked for the Victorian team.

All sides have a solid team, a lot would depend on injury status, if Gehrig, J Brown and Maquire had to play now he wouldn't be that good.

Victorian side also has a lot of hot or cold players... Bruce, Ablett, Yze, etc. A lot of talent in that side though. Where these squads do not adequately reflect the strength is that second or third Victorian side would still be pretty strong. Victoria has a lot of depth.

But, if those sides played off I think the SA side could do best because it is basically Adelaide strenghtened with the better Port players and a few of the standouts from other clubs. That team should click a lot better than the others and has a lot of talent all over the park.

Tredrea, Pavlich, Welsh and Ottens is a good forward line. The WA side still has a weak forwad line comparatively, when Lynch is named in the state side you know you have issues.

Allies side is also very good, strong in the middle and up forward but I struggle to see many top class defenders in that side and a fair few of their players are well past their prime. All sides are very good though.

 

[tribey]

Not sure how Voss got into the Allies team given he is Victorian, from Traralgon in the Latrobe Valley. Unless they are allowed to field players not picked for the Victorian team.

Voss previously represented the Allies did he not?