Who will win the Doig

[BB gun]

My tip
1 Haselby
2 Bell
3 Hadrill

This years count should be close. Haselby dominated the first half of the season. Bell and hadrill were consitent throughout the season. J Lo came will come home strongly.
Murphy or Dunn, who will be best first year player?
Best Clubman?
Schammer most improved?

 

[voodoo_86]

Connolly predicted Bell to be the highest polling docker for the brownlow, anything in that maybe?

You'd expect Hase, Bell, Haddrill and J.Lo to be up there.
Murphy best first year.
Schammer or Thornton most improved (maybe J.Lo?).
Clubman.. Hard to say really.

 

[Ripper]

Don't know. Last year the top 10 were mostly a complete surprise to most of us as the coaching panel give players jobs to do and rate the accordingly (generally differently to us supporters).

Belly & Hase & Sir Robert would be most likely to be top 3 as they are probably the only ones who were consistant all season.

Others to poll well IMO would be Pav (may be top 3) , Action Man , J.LO , Macpharlap until he was injured and I reckon D.J. & The Wiz will be up there in the top 10.

 

[Scham]

My top 10;

Bell
Hase
JLO
Robbie
Pavlich
Walker
McPharlane
McManus
Farmer
Cook

Wasn't it criminal that JLo didn't receive one Brownlow vote?

 

[Kapow!!!]

Haselby or Jlo. My tip Haselby because he has been there abouts. A roughy would be Schammer, don't rule him out yet!

 

[bluey17]

LOL, best first year player?

Did anyone actually debut for you that did anything good? Any rising star nominations? Oh, but you're so young.

 

[voodoo_86]

What does first year players have to do with being so young?
Idiot.

I'm sure WAFL form will be considered when selecting the 'best first year player'

The stats:
Bell - 28
Browne - 20
Campbell - 19
Carr - 26
Cook - 28
Cunningham - 23
Dunn - 19
Edgecumb - 20
Farmer - 26
Gilmore - 21
Grover - 24
Haddrill - 23
Haines - 23
Haselby - 23
Hayden - 24
Headland - 23
Johnson - 20
Longmuir - 23
Longmuir - 25
McManus - 28
McPharlin - 23
Medhurst - 23
Mundy - 19
Murphy - 19
Parker - 31
Pavlich - 23
Peake - 21
Polak - 20
Sandilands - 22
Schammer - 19
Seigert - 22
Simmonds - 26
Thornton - 22
Walker - 25
Webster - 22
Woods - 22

Average age = 22.92
Average age of best 25 = 23.68
Players 26 or over = 7
# Players yet to debut = 5

Eagles:
Adkins - 23
Banfield - 30
Beeck - 22
Braun - 26
Butler - 18
Carroll - 26
Chambers - 25
Chick - 28
Cousins - 26
Cox - 23
Embley - 23
Fletcher - 25
Gardiner - 25
Gasper - 23
Glass - 23
Grayham - 21
Hansen - 21
Humm - 21
Hunter - 23
Johnson - 20
Jones - 22
Jones - 25
Judd - 21
Kerr - 21
Lynch - 21
Matera - 29
McConnell - 18
McDougall - 21
Morrison - 26
Nicoski - 21
Sampi - 20
Seaby - 20
Selwood - 20
Staker - 20
Waters - 18
Wirrpunda - 25
Wooden - 26

Average age = 23.5
Average age of best 25 = 23.36
Players 26 or over = 7
# Players yet to debut = 4


So who cares how many players you debuted this year. The stats are remarkably similar.

 

[wooshta_9]

Top 10
Haselby
Longmuir
Haddrill
Bell
McPharlin
Pavlich
Walker
Schammer
McManus
Farmer (his forward pressure will see him poll better than expected)


Beacon: Byron Schammer if he eligible if not Daniel Gilmore, remember the beacon award is not best first year player its best young player.

Best Club Man: T'Lo again maybe????

 

[Borry]

J Longmuir

 

[Bockchoy67]

Being a Crows supporter, from what I've seen:

1. Hasleby
2. Haddrill
3. Longmuir
4. Bell
5. Pavlich
6. McPharlin
7. Walker
8. Schammer (Could go higher)
9. McManus
10. Farmer

Most Improved Player: Justin Longmuir (or perhaps Walker/Schammer)
Best Young Player: Schammer (if eligible)
Best Clubman: Robert Hadrill (depends what it is based on)