Who would win...

[Longy413]

TEAM A -

B. Atkinson Lee Pears
HB. Dempsey Fletcher Myers
C. Winderlich McVeigh Reimers
HF. Davey Lucas Daniher
F. Neagle Johns Houli
R. Gumbleton Johnson Hislop
INT. Dick Hocking

TEAM B -
B. Nash Ryder Slattery
HB. Lovett-Murray Michael Peverill
C. Dyson Watson Lovett
HF. McPhee Lloyd Rama
F. Jetta Laycock Monfries
R. Hille Stanton Welsh
INT. Lonergan Bellchambers Hooker Williams Magin Chartres

 

[eth-dog]

Team B by a lot

 

[Longy413]

Team B by a lot

You're right, but that would take the fun out of the thread wouldn't it

 

[kelvin_sheedy]

Team B would win by 300 because Team A would have 12 fit men in the second half.

 

[the_other]

Shouldn't Hille be playing for Team A?

 

[dodgey]

Shouldn't Hille be playing for Team A?

Yep.... that should bring the margin down somewhat ( hille V laycock)

 

[Bombs Away]

The real team A would win. Forgot to put in Hille, Slattery, Laycock, Lonergan, Lovett and Watson who all played injured on the weekend.

 

[Bombs Away]

TEAM A -

B. Atkinson Lee Pears
HB. Dempsey Fletcher Myers
C. Winderlich McVeigh Reimers
HF. Davey Lucas Daniher
F. Neagle Johns Houli
R. Gumbleton Johnson Hislop
INT. Dick Hocking

TEAM B -
B. Nash Ryder Slattery
HB. Lovett-Murray Michael Peverill
C. Dyson Watson Lovett
HF. McPhee Lloyd Rama
F. Jetta Laycock Monfries
R. Hille Stanton Welsh
INT. Lonergan Bellchambers Hooker Williams Magin Chartres

Should be on the injured team in bold, all were either injured on the weekend or carrying injuries which restricted their game effectiveness

 

[Longy413]

Shouldn't Hille be playing for Team A?

I based it on the team that played on Saturday.
Put Fletcher and Dempsey in the injured team because of how early in the game they were off the ground.

 

[Jono B]

TEAM A -

B. Atkinson Lee Pears
HB. Dempsey Fletcher Myers
C. Winderlich McVeigh Reimers
HF. Davey Lucas Daniher
F. Neagle Johns Houli
R. Gumbleton Johnson Hislop
INT. Dick Hocking

TEAM B -
B. Nash Ryder Slattery
HB. Lovett-Murray Michael Peverill
C. Dyson Watson Lovett
HF. McPhee Lloyd Rama
F. Jetta Laycock Monfries
R. Hille Stanton Welsh
INT. Lonergan Bellchambers Hooker Williams Magin Chartres

Team B would win but Team A has a better forward line structure and great pace.

 

[Bombs Away]

I based it on the team that played on Saturday.
Put Fletcher and Dempsey in the injured team because of how early in the game they were off the ground.

Fair enough Longy, It you took it at game end 1 of the teams wouldnt have enough players

 

[Lance Uppercut]

TEAM A -

B. Atkinson Lee Pears
HB. Dempsey Fletcher Myers
C. Winderlich McVeigh Reimers
HF. Davey Lucas Daniher
F. Neagle Johns Houli
R. Gumbleton Johnson Hislop
INT. Dick Hocking

TEAM B -
B. Nash Ryder Slattery
HB. Lovett-Murray Michael Peverill
C. Dyson Watson Lovett
HF. McPhee Lloyd Rama
F. Jetta Laycock Monfries
R. Hille Stanton Welsh
INT. Lonergan Bellchambers Hooker Williams Magin Chartres

 

[stander]

You're right, but that would take the fun out of the thread wouldn't it

The thread about I was right and wrong was much better than this.

 

[Rack Watts]

The thread about I was right and wrong was much better than this.

B: Dick Ryder

 

[Bombs Away]

b: Dick Ryder

lol

 

[Rack Watts]

INT. Dick Hocking Hooker

Edited for lolz.

 

[gavdog08]

TEAM B by >20 goals because they have Hille, Lloyd, Watson, Welsh, Stanton, Jetta, Ryder, Peverill, Lovett, McPhee, Lonergan, Monfries and a 6-man bench.

 

[Bombs Away]

Thought I would update the sides now that the season is over

Team A
Nash NLM Slattery
Hocking Ryder Peverill
Lonergan Watson Dyson
Monfries Lloyd McVeigh
Rama Michael Jetta
Bellchambers Stanton Johnson
INT Williams Hooker Magin Lovett


Team B
Atkinson Daniher Houli
Pears Fletcher Myers
Winderlich Hislop Reimers
McPhee Lucas Gumbleton
Davey Neagle Laycock
Hille Dempsey Welsh
INT Johns Lee Chartres

That is every player on all lists used Except Dick who has gone crying to Dad cause hehas got the boot.

I personally think that team B has better forwards, backs, rucks and if we are serious and add the other playing injured players as Watson, McVeigh, Lonergan better midfield aswell.

Your thoughts on which side you think would win and margin thanks.

 

[WN123]

This concept has changed dramatically this week. The injured team would win easliy now. Far better KPP, quicker and the big one is Hille in the ruck.