Worst top 10 draft selections

[SYDNEY_EAGLE]

What do you reckon?

Collingwood picking up Danny Roach with No. 7 in 1999 is the one for me.

 

[marcuz]

What do you reckon?

Collingwood picking up Danny Roach with No. 8 is the stand-out for me. Not sure which year - 1998?

Daniel McAlister

thread over.

 

[Portia]

Laurence Angwin

 

[m.diddy]

Clive Waterhouse



oh wait did you say worst or ugliest?

 

[SYDNEY_EAGLE]

Daniel McAlister

thread over.

Who picked him?
What year?
What number?

 

[SYDNEY_EAGLE]

WC picked up Brendan Fewster with pick 3 in 1995.

Although Freo were dumb enough to give pick 3 to us in return for David Hynes.

 

[marcuz]

Who picked him?
What year?
What number?

essendon
1996
pick 5

 

[SYDNEY_EAGLE]

WC picked up Brendan Fewster with pick 3 in 1995.

Although Freo were dumb enough to give pick 3 to us in return for David Hynes.

And then we traded Fewster to Freo for pick 16 in 1999.

Those Dockers. How many WC duds did they accept in those early years?

 

[nonchalance]

Who picked him?
What year?
What number?

Essendon.
1996.
Pick 5.

He played 6 games (2 in 1997, 1 in 2001 and 3 in 2002) for 44 possessions.

 

[ThatThis]

At least Roach played 1 game.

WCE Brandon Hill, 0 games
Pick 10, 1997 i think

 

[SYDNEY_EAGLE]

Yeah that was a bad one.

 

[tayls]

Geelong picked up Leigh Brockman at number 7 i think. i may be wrong. He was a dud.

 

[RoganSaint]

surely Richmond supporters would rate Fiora at (3)... (taken ahead of pavlich) as a poor pick..

I on the other hand hope he lives up to his pick rating... hasn't shown alot yet, now's his chance to shine

 

[rick James]

melbourne - Luke Molan - Pick 9. Looking for a key backman. Then Maguire went at number 13 or so I beleive. Well done dees. go number thirty four.

 

[Ripper]

surely Richmond supporters would rate Fiora at (3)... (taken ahead of pavlich) as a poor pick..

I on the other hand hope he lives up to his pick rating... hasn't shown alot yet, now's his chance to shine

From what I have seen Fiora is not a bad player. He is just unfortunately weighed down with the baggage of being a number 3 Pick.

 

[jonny f muleus]

Luke Molan, Melb, Pick 9, 2001...0 games...I think he is now delisted???
Nick dal santo, Brent Rielly, James Kelly, Sam Mitchell all picked with later picks in the draft

 

[rick James]

Luke Molan, Melb, Pick 9, 2001...0 games...I think he is now delisted???
Nick dal santo, Brent Rielly, James Kelly, Sam Mitchell all picked with later picks in the draft

and worst of all maguire went after him as well, and molan was meant to be a key backman.

admittedly he was injured non stop for two years. he actually could play when we drafted him.

 

[- PC -]

surely Richmond supporters would rate Fiora at (3)... (taken ahead of pavlich) as a poor pick..

I on the other hand hope he lives up to his pick rating... hasn't shown alot yet, now's his chance to shine

Richmond supporters are still asking who Richard Lounder is. He was a number 1 draft choice. What still dont recall him? He must have played all of ummm 4 games for Richmond.

Oh and this is a repeated thread.

 

[turtle27]

Another Richmond classic, Anthony Bannick (sp), though to be fair, his back didn't help him.

 

[Eggzoi]

Ugh, Angwin.

 

[dA Crow]

Ugh, Angwin.

He was our key to stealing a premiership, but he prefered lose change.

 

[Stiffy_18]

He was our key to stealing a premiership, but he prefered lose change.

 

[Hawka Deano]

The Hawks traded pick 4 for Brett O'Farrell I think?

 

[mjhen3]

at least melbourne cut their losses with molan after 2 years sheedy persisted with mcalister for 5 i think

 

[jimmy35]

The Hawks traded pick 4 for Brett O'Farrell I think?

What happened to Brett O'Farrell? I thought he was going to be some sort of player at Sydney but he didnt develop at all.