Your ideal team Changes

[Dr Ralph Dagg]

I've thought about this very carefully and I think the following:

Ins: Dane Swan, Simon Black, Brent Harvey
Out: Matt Carr, Ryan Crowley, Byron Schammer.

 

[Shaymuhz]

if we are rewarding players on form as is mark harvey's supposed philosophy then i think the changes should look something like this:

Ins: Duffield, Drum, Warnock

Outs: Peake, M.Carr, Schammer

apologies to Luke Webster but couldn't find a role for him despite excellent form - whats he like off a half back flank?

m. johnson to the backline where he belongs with dodd (tagger) and gilmore being run through the middle.

i think campbell and tarrant really need to justfiy their selection this week.

 

[Nodgey]

Duffield has to prove his form over at least or 4 weeks IMHO. With all due respect to East Fremantle, I want to see him performing consistently well, and against the better teams like Subi & Claremont.

Ins: Warnock, Drum, Black/Johnson
Outs: Peake, Ibbo, MCarr

Feel sorry for Ibbo, but he got caught HTB several times, and a derby aint gonna be any easier. MCarr usually plays well in derbies, so I'd be prepared to give him another week if Black or Mark Johnson aren't fit.

 

[bigkev bleeds purple]

In: Waterhouse, Parker, Christ

Out: Ibbotson, M Carr, Peake

 

[afreofan]

In : Warnock, Duffield, Drum, Black

Out : Peake, M. Carr, Campbell, Schammer

B : Black Grover Mundy
HB : Dodd Johnson Drum
C : Palmer J. Carr Headland
HF : Mayne Pavlich Duffield
F : Farmer McPharlin Tarrant
R : Sandilands Gilmore Bell
Int : Warnock Hayden Ibbotson Crowley