Out of 23:
Gollant
Murphy
Hinge
Schoenberg
Into 23:
Fogarty
McAdam
Pedlar
Berry
Sholl sub.
Gollant
Murphy
Hinge
Schoenberg
Into 23:
Fogarty
McAdam
Pedlar
Berry
Sholl sub.
Last edited:
Preview Changes: R5 vs Carlton, Thursday April 13, 7.10pm ACST @ Adelaide Oval
- Thread starter Thylacinus
- Start date
- Tagged users None
nummy217
Team Captain
- Oct 2, 2017
- 315
- 600
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Yeah this is pretty good. You win lol
This. And it’s nothing to do with those guys playing badly
Reckon Gollant comes back in for Tex in R6, I reckon we’ll rest him for the Tassie trip
- Jul 22, 2012
- 4,069
- 8,695
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Philadelphia 76ers
Out: Walker (5 day break), Gollant (omitted), McHenry (omitted), Schoenberg (omitted)
In: Fogarty, McAdam, Pedlar
Sub: Berry
Edit: I’m certainly not against Hinge being dropped or Sloane being rested on the 5 day break either. Murphy survives IMO.
In: Fogarty, McAdam, Pedlar
Sub: Berry
Edit: I’m certainly not against Hinge being dropped or Sloane being rested on the 5 day break either. Murphy survives IMO.
Butts will likely go out too given he was subbed. Keane you would think comes in.
MsTopG
Premiership Player
- Mar 21, 2023
- 4,959
- 4,243
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
In:
Fog Keane Pedlar McAdam Worrell Parnell Berry
Out:
Walker inj/rested Butts inj McHenry Murphy. Milera Schoenberg Keays
I don't subscribe to you don't change a winning team. You pick your best team to win. 5 day break means we need fresh legs and players who are better to come in. Carlton are much better than Freo. If we play like we did today we won't win.
Pedlar is better than Ned
McAdam is better than Murphy.
Berry (if fit ) is better than Harry
Worrell (if fit) is better than Milera
Parnell needed as Carlton have some dangerous smalls.
If Tex and Butts are injured Fog and Keane are better options.
Gollant played well and deserves to keep his spot imo.
Fog Keane Pedlar McAdam Worrell Parnell Berry
Out:
Walker inj/rested Butts inj McHenry Murphy. Milera Schoenberg Keays
I don't subscribe to you don't change a winning team. You pick your best team to win. 5 day break means we need fresh legs and players who are better to come in. Carlton are much better than Freo. If we play like we did today we won't win.
Pedlar is better than Ned
McAdam is better than Murphy.
Berry (if fit ) is better than Harry
Worrell (if fit) is better than Milera
Parnell needed as Carlton have some dangerous smalls.
If Tex and Butts are injured Fog and Keane are better options.
Gollant played well and deserves to keep his spot imo.
Last edited:
- Mar 3, 2022
- 4,966
- 6,482
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Bye Hinge, Gollant, McHenry,
Hello Fog, McAdam, Pedlar
Berry or Schoenberg for sub
If Parnell is fit he can replace Sholl
Hello Fog, McAdam, Pedlar
Berry or Schoenberg for sub
If Parnell is fit he can replace Sholl
Last edited:
Did I watch another game? Hinge isn’t going out, he’s firmly best 22.
- Jun 21, 2014
- 8,595
- 9,375
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Good sort of selection problems this week!
Was it a tactical or injury sub? Don’t think it was ever stated which it was, unless I missed it
Wtf
He had a stinker but he’s got enough runs on the board to stay in
Fog and McAdam will be available
This is my changes too, Ned played pretty well but we need to get Pedlar back in.
Drugs Are Bad Mackay?
Moderator
- May 24, 2006
- 77,386
- 152,111
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Redbacks, Sturt, Liverpool, Arizona
- Moderator
- #17
Pretty straightforward selections
Fogarty in for Gollant
Pedlar for McHenry
McAdam for Murphy
Butts injured replaced by Keane
Very easy week for the selectors but I fear we'll needlessly complicate things
Fogarty in for Gollant
Pedlar for McHenry
McAdam for Murphy
Butts injured replaced by Keane
Very easy week for the selectors but I fear we'll needlessly complicate things
- Oct 13, 2017
- 20,294
- 33,574
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, Glenelg, tigers
Hinge had a bit of a dirty day..
but he’s got way too many runs on the board this year to not survive 1 poor game.
You must of, Hinge was terrible, never seen a player have so many brain fades.
That said, I don’t think we will drop him as much as that performance warranted it.
Will be lucky to be 3 changes after a 7 goal win, let alone 7! Fog for Gollant seems a certainty. Pedlar for Murphy. McAdam for McHenry, but don’t mind either way if McAdam plays SANFL. Keane or Borlase to replace Butts. Berry replaces Schoenberg as the sub. 3 or 4 changes to best 22, change to the sub.
- Oct 13, 2017
- 20,294
- 33,574
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, Glenelg, tigers
This is what I’d go with..
They aren’t easy selections when McHenry did play well today and Murphy had been good last 2 weeks. Might seem easy for us, but you’re dropping two guys who are very stiff and only missing because more talented guys are returning.
Fogarty and McAdam have to come in.
Played a pretty typical Hinge game. Couple of howlers by foot, great defensive plays, involved in some scoring chains.
When a player has runs on the board you don't just throw them out after 1 bad game. It was like millera called going being dropped last week.
Sometimes I think this board is overly reactionary.
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll
