Create a 'Best 18' using one player from each club.

[Sir Priddis]

Only one Hawthorn player?

Pretty sure such a team would be comfortably beaten by Hawthorn.

 

[TwentyNine]

B: Steven Morris (RICH) Daniel Talia (ADE) Dale Morris (WB)
HB: Michael Hibberd (ESS) Tom McDonald (MEL) Shannon Hurn (WCE)
C: Scott Pendlebury (COL) Joel Selwood (GEE) Gary Ablett (GCS)
HF: Brent Harvey (NMFC) Nick Riewoldt (STK) Robbie Gray (PA)
F: Troy Menzel (CAR) Lance Franklin (SYD) Jarryd Roughead (HAW)
Fol: Shane Mumford (GWS) Tom Rockliff - C (BL) Nathan Fyfe (FRE)

 

[Capt_Blackadder]

You need to chose a player from University.

I would have Roy Park on the bench.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Players from another club

B: jaksch (Carl), mcfarlane (fre), Delaney (st k)
Hb: Houli (rich) , Davis (gws), Higgins (mm)
c: Vince (mel), greenwood (col) Goddard (ess)
Hf: gunston (haw), Franklin (syd), caddy (geel)
f: Betts (adl), Kennedy (wce), t boyd (wb)
r: Ryder (port), ablett (gc), beams (bris)

 

[Some Idiot]

FB: Yarran (CARL) - Rance (RICH) - Murphy (WB)
HB: Hanley (BL) - Talia (ADEL) - Burgoyne (HAW)
C: Sidebottom (COLL) - Jones (MELB) - Heppell (ESS)
HF: Johnson (GEEL) - Riewoldt (STK) - Harvey (NM)
FF: Wingard (PORT) - Franklin (SYD) - Smith (GWS)

R: Naitanui (WCE) - Ablett (GC) - Fyfe (FREM)

Can just imagine small forwards running havoc on that backline as their opponents don't go near them

 

[pazza]

B: Daniel Talia (Adel), Eric Mackenzie (WCE), Luke Hodge (Haw - Leadership Group)
HB: Pearce Hanley (Bris), Tom Lonergan (Geel), Bryce Gibbs (Carl)
C: Gary Ablett (GC - Captain), Jobe Watson (Ess - Leadership Group), Tom Liberatore (WB)
HF: Brent Harvey (North), Nick Riewoldt (St. K - Vice-Captain), Chad Wingard (Port)
F: Jack Riewoldt (Rich), Lance Franklin (Syd), Jeremy Cameron (GWS)
R: Aaron Sandilands (Frem), Nathan Jones (Melb - Leadership Group), Steele Sidebottom (Coll)

 

[Veddom]

All time:

B: B.Doull (Carl), J.Regan (Coll), I.Warne-Smith (Melb)
HB: A.McLeod (Adel), G.Jakovich (WC), E.J.Whitten (Foot)
C: D.Reynolds (Ess), M.Voss (BL), B.Skilton (South/Syd)
HF: L.Matthews (Haw), W.Carey (NM), H.Bunton (Fitz)
F: K.Bartlett (Rich), T.Lockett (St K), M.Pavlich (Frem)
Fol: G.Farmer (Geel), G.Ablett Jnr (GC), R.Ebert (PA)
Int: C.Ward (GWS)

Matthew Pavlich a better forward than John Coleman?
He can't even win a Coleman medal..

 

[eth-dog]

Matthew Pavlich a better forward than John Coleman?
He can't even win a Coleman medal..

Dick Reynolds was Essendon's greatest player, period. Pavlich is Fremantle's greatest player, period. I'm not a fan of Barry but you can't criticise him for those selections.

 

[12Chill]

Had a go at an all time list... First draft and I included Sydney and South Melb just richest in a few extra players

BACKLINE:
G. Wanganeen [PTA] - G. Jakovic [WCE] - S. Silvagni [CARL]
A. McLeod [ADEL] - M. Pavlich [FREM] - E.J Whitten [FOOT/WBD]

MIDFIELD:
J. Stynes [MELB] - G. Ablett jnr [GCS] - H. Bunton [FITZ]
D. Reynolds [ESS] - I. Stewart [STK] - B. Skilton [SOUTH]

FORWARDS:
L. Matthews [HAW] - W. Carey [NMK] - G. Ablett snr [GEEL]
K. Bartlett [RICH] - T. Lockett [SYD] - P. Daicos [COLL]

INTERCHANGE:
M. Voss [BRIS] - C. Ward [GWS] - R. Park [UNI]

 

[eth-dog]

Had a go at an all time list... First draft and I included Sydney and South Melb just richest in a few extra players

BACKLINE:
G. Wanganeen [PTA] - G. Jakovic [WCE] - S. Silvagni [CARL]
A. McLeod [ADEL] - M. Pavlich [FREM] - E.J Whitten [FOOT/WBD]

MIDFIELD:
J. Stynes [MELB] - G. Ablett jnr [GCS] - H. Bunton [FITZ]
D. Reynolds [ESS] - I. Stewart [STK] - B. Skilton [SOUTH]

FORWARDS:
L. Matthews [HAW] - W. Carey [NMK] - G. Ablett snr [GEEL]
K. Bartlett [RICH] - T. Lockett [SYD] - P. Daicos [COLL]

INTERCHANGE:
M. Voss [BRIS] - C. Ward [GWS] - R. Park [UNI]

Why not include West as the Dogs and keep Whitten for Footscray?

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

Matthew Pavlich a better forward than John Coleman?
He can't even win a Coleman medal..

You can only pick one player per club. So if I were to replace Pavlich with Coleman, I would need to drop Reynolds and replace him with another midfielder from Freo (Peter Bell?).

I like the Reynolds/Pavlich combo better than the Bell/Coleman combo.

 

[jackenny]

B: E. Wood, L. Dunn, E. McKenzie
HB: K. Simpson, C. Hooker, H. Shaw
C: P. Hanley, P. Dangerfield, I. Smith
HF: D. Martin, N. Riewoldt, L. Franklin
F: J. Elliott, T. Hawkins, R. Gray
R: T. Goldstein, G. Ablett, N. Fyfe

Adelaide: Patrick Dangerfield
Brisbane: Pearce Hanley
Carlton: Kade Simpson
Collingwood: Jamie Elliott
Essendon: Cale Hooker
Fremantle: Nat Fyfe
Geelong: Tom Hawkins
Gold Coast: Gary Ablett
GWS: Heath Shaw
Hawthorn: Isaac Smith
Melbourne: Lynden Dunn
North Melbourne: Todd Goldstein
Port Adelaide: Robbie Gray
Richmond: Dustin Martin
St. Kilda: Nick Riewoldt
Sydney: Lance Franklin
West Coast: Eric McKenzie
Western Bulldogs: Easton Wood

 

[Xenthor]

Bump
FB: Heath Shaw-Steven May-Jeremy McGovern
HB: Brodie Smith-Alex Rance-Kade Simpson
C: Nate Fyfe-Dayne Beams-Scott Pendlebury
HF: David Zaharakis-Jack Gunston-Jake Stringer
FF: Josh Bruce-Jesse Hogan-Chad Wingard
R: Todd Goldstein-Josh Kennedy-Patrick Dangerfield

 

[thetruth000001]

FB: Bartel(GEEL)Gibson(HAW)Wood(Dogs)
HB:Shaw(GWS)McGovern(WCE)Simpson(Carl)
C:Beams(BRIS)Abblet(GCS)Jones(MEL)
HFelideo(RICH)Rievwolt(STK)Goddard(ESS)
FF:Betts(ADEL)Franklin(SYD)Gray(Port)

R:Goldstein(NM)Fyfe(FRE)Pendlebury(COLL)

 

[eth-dog]

Smith (Syd) - Talia (Ade) - Gibson (Haw)
Shaw (GWS) - Reid (Col) - Simpson (Car)
Hanley (Bris) - Ablett (GC) - Goddard (Ess)
Gray (PA) - Riewoldt (StK) - Deledio (Ric)
Dahlhaus (WB) - Kennedy (WC) - Hogan (Mel)
Goldstein (NM) - Fyfe (Fre) - Dangerfield (Gee)

 

[Hoops]

Bump
FB: Heath Shaw-Steven May-Jeremy McGovern
HB: Brodie Smith-Alex Rance-Kade Simpson
C: Nate Fyfe-Dayne Beams-Scott Pendlebury
HF: David Zaharakis-Jack Gunston-Jake Stringer
FF: Josh Bruce-Jesse Hogan-Chad Wingard
R: Todd Goldstein-Josh Kennedy-Patrick Dangerfield

Selwood would get a game in the midfield before Dangerfield.

 

[Super Hans]

Smith - Rance - McGovern
Simpson - Hurley - Wood
Beams - Pendles - Dangerfield
Gray - Reiwoldt - Vince
Betts - Roughead - Cameron
Goldstein - Fyfe - Ablett

 

[ReaperX]

B: Josh Gibson (Haw), Alex Rance (Rich), Cale Hooker (Ess)
HB: Pearce Hanley (BL), Phil Davis (GWS), Heritier Lumumba (Melb)
C: Marc Murphy (Carl), Patrick Dangerfield (Geel), Scott Pendlebury (Coll)
HF: Brent Harvey (NM), Nick Riewoldt (St. K), Marcus Bontempelli (WB)
F: Eddie Betts (Adel), Lance Franklin (Syd), Robbie Gray (Port)

Foll: Nic Naitanui (WCE), Gary Ablett Jnr (GC), Nat Fyfe (Frem)

 

[TheAnt]

B: Shaw (GWS), Rance (RICH), McDonald (MELB)
HB: Murphy (WB) , Hurley (ESS), Simpson (CARL)
C: Beams (BRIS) , Pendlebury (COLL), Dangerfield (GEEL)
HF: Gray (PORT), Riewoldt (STK), Harvey (NM)
F: Betts (ADEL) , Franklin (SYD), Rioli (HAW)
R: Naitanui (WCE), Fyfe (FREM), Ablett (GC)

B: E. Wood, L. Dunn, E. McKenzie

Impressive call before Wood's big breakout season

 

[Xenthor]

B: Josh Gibson (Haw), Alex Rance (Rich), Cale Hooker (Ess)
HB: Pearce Hanley (BL), Phil Davis (GWS), Heritier Lumumba (Melb)
C: Marc Murphy (Carl), Patrick Dangerfield (Geel), Scott Pendlebury (Coll)
HF: Brent Harvey (NM), Nick Riewoldt (St. K), Marcus Bontempelli (WB)
F: Eddie Betts (Adel), Lance Franklin (Syd), Robbie Gray (Port)

Foll: Nic Naitanui (WCE), Gary Ablett Jnr (GC), Nat Fyfe (Frem)

I thought about putting hooker in my team but after the suspension and all...

 

[Xenthor]

B - S Thompson (NM), E McKenzie (WC), C Hooker (Ess)
HB - D Talia (Adel), Harry Taylor (Geel), C Yarran (Carl)
C - C Ward (GWS), D Beams (Bris), S Pendlebury (Coll)
HF - M Bontempelli (WB), L Franklin (Syd), J Gunston (Haw)
F - J Riewoldt (Rich), Nick Riewoldt (STK), H Ballantyne (Freo)
R - P Ryder (Port), Gary Ablett (GC), N Jones (Melb)

Thought about chemistry/combinations. Having both Riewoldts up forward would be insane. Also went through each team and essentially picked the best player apart from some back/forward choices. I feel like I've come up with a strong team here with a mixture of everything.

This must be the tallest team ever

 

[Wounded Lion]

S Michael. J Tippett. J Patfull.
S Docherty. L.Henderson. J Adcock.
J Aish. M.Rischitelli. J.Polec.
J.Crisp. B Longer. J Polkinghorne.
S Mayes. M.Clark. C.Wood.

M Leuenberger. J.Redden. E.Yeo

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

S Michael. J Tippett. J Patfull.
S Docherty. L.Henderson. J Adcock.
J Aish. M.Rischitelli. J.Polec.
J.Crisp. B Longer. J Polkinghorne.
S Mayes. M.Clark. C.Wood.

M Leuenberger. J.Redden. E.Yeo

the spud 18?

 

[pazza]

Had a go at an all time list... First draft and I included Sydney and South Melb just richest in a few extra players

BACKLINE:
G. Wanganeen [PTA] - G. Jakovic [WCE] - S. Silvagni [CARL]
A. McLeod [ADEL] - M. Pavlich [FREM] - E.J Whitten [FOOT/WBD]

MIDFIELD:
J. Stynes [MELB] - G. Ablett jnr [GCS] - H. Bunton [FITZ]
D. Reynolds [ESS] - I. Stewart [STK] - B. Skilton [SOUTH]

FORWARDS:
L. Matthews [HAW] - W. Carey [NMK] - G. Ablett snr [GEEL]
K. Bartlett [RICH] - T. Lockett [SYD] - P. Daicos [COLL]

INTERCHANGE:
M. Voss [BRIS] - C. Ward [GWS] - R. Park [UNI]

Not bad!

B: Wanganeen (P), Silvagni (C), Jakovich (WC)
HB: McLeod (A), Whitten senior (Fo), Fyfe (Fr)
C: Ablett junior (GC), Barassi (M), Stewart (St. K)
HF: Ablett senior (G), Carey (NM), Reynolds (E)
F: Matthews (H), Lockett (Sy), Bartlett (R)
R: S. Coventry (Coll), Bunton (Fi), Skilton (So)
Int: Park (U), West (WB), Voss (B), Ward (GWS)

 

[Synth]

I thought about putting hooker in my team but after the suspension and all...

Still a listed player.