I think a risk like Caddy is one worth punting on, his young and has upside.
Hmac was 28 and played something like 7 games in 3 years before this year. Was extremely risky to bring him in. And you could see that before he was recruited that it was a high chance of him not being a great move.
Good thoughts Alkanphel
I think as a Club we have been caught between rebuilding and contending with minor changes and I don't think we have done the latter at the level required ( performance in Finals since 2011 says that)
I think Caddy and Rivers has worked but I also believe we have carried too many players under injury clouds for too long.
Menzel , Simpson , Cowan , H Mac in particular and add in Vardy as well. We need to make calls on all at end 2015 else we continue to take List space with players who can't get on the park.
I hope Clark and Stanley repay our faith but Clark in particular is a higher than normal risk. Has worked for the Hawks with Lake so let's hope we can get a similar reward.
Testing times ahead for the Club.