instead of trading him for the draft pick?
The answer is yes.
End of thread.
The answer is yes.
End of thread.
Do you wish you had kept Heath Scotland.....
- Thread starter JK Bundart
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
johnson_26
All Australian
Why start a thread answering your own question you self indulgent tripe....
No, he's a soft outside receiver, we don't need his softness, ala 2003 granny in our side...
now please, go home to ur.... match box?
No, he's a soft outside receiver, we don't need his softness, ala 2003 granny in our side...
now please, go home to ur.... match box?
- Thread starter
- #4
If Heath Scotland was in your team this season the premiership flag would be a guarantee.
You have a good squad that is in need of more depth IMO.
Heath would add this depth, did you not know he is the 3RD highest ranked Kelloggs nutri-grain afl dream team player this year.
That speaks for itself.
You have a good squad that is in need of more depth IMO.
Heath would add this depth, did you not know he is the 3RD highest ranked Kelloggs nutri-grain afl dream team player this year.
That speaks for itself.
not really, it just shows he get's a lot of stats, not ho1 effective he is.
JK Bundart said:
Kellogg's Nutri-grain dream team gives points for stats. Tell me where is he ranked in the Herald Sun dream team, where points are given on the effectiveness of possessions.
- Thread starter
- #7
Dazman said:
Heath Scotland is a very good looking man.
You homophobic or something.
Jeez, all decent threads have to go down that line.
- Thread starter
- #9
Warwick said:
Are you winding me up?
Heath for president!!
"When Heath Scotland gets the sherrin in his hands magical things are about to happen"
The Nutri Grain stats don't provide points for accountability.
Personally, I liked Scoots, but backed the trade at the time, as we lacked depth in quality talls and had a dearth of single paced, sub 6' mids with average skills. That we drafted an uber-dud in Hall is irrelevant to the principle.
As it stands though, Scotland is a poor man's Dane Swan. There would be no room for both of them and Swanny ****s on Scoots from a great height.
Personally, I liked Scoots, but backed the trade at the time, as we lacked depth in quality talls and had a dearth of single paced, sub 6' mids with average skills. That we drafted an uber-dud in Hall is irrelevant to the principle.
As it stands though, Scotland is a poor man's Dane Swan. There would be no room for both of them and Swanny ****s on Scoots from a great height.
JK Bundart said:
We didnt trade him - he left us. He wanted to leave and we honored his wish. If Port hadnt been so stupid we'd have Stevens now and they'd have Scotland and a draft pick.. Either Stevens or Scotland would be handy right now but neither are the difference between winning and losing a flag.
Nup, don't care much about Scotland
goalpie
Premiership Player
Somehow I think Walker and Hall would make Carltons team.
He used to get lots of the ball at Collingwood just wastes it half the time. Still does going by recent Carlton games.
He used to get lots of the ball at Collingwood just wastes it half the time. Still does going by recent Carlton games.
Pie 4 Life
Hall of Famer
No, No and No.
goalpie said:
I don't know how many Carlton games you watch, but he is easily in our top couple of players in terms of effectiveness of disposals. Has sensational disposal by foot and always manages to hit a target. He may have weaknesses but "wasting the ball" is certainly not one of them
goalpie
Premiership Player
Lajon said:I don't know how many Carlton games you watch, but he is easily in our top couple of players in terms of effectiveness of disposals. Has sensational disposal by foot and always manages to hit a target. He may have weaknesses but "wasting the ball" is certainly not one of them
Last game wasnt exactly a highlight. But then again others were worse. Much worse.
He has excellent foot skills.
Jabso
Brownlow Medallist
If Hall was at Carlton the fans would be salivating of having a team with both Silly Stupid Shambling Simple Celtic Setanta oHailpin and Big Bad Bogus Bumbling Brent Hall in the same team.
careyrips(I)
Debutant
Heath Scotland never hit his full potential at Collingwood so it was the right move for us to trade him. He never suited collingwood and it was probably best for both collingwood and himself to move to carlton where he has improved a little.
Yet has the highest number of effective kicks in the AFL, and his kicking efficiency is at 80.7%.goalpie said:
- Status
