Official Trade Period Discussion 2012 Thread (#3)

[markm106]

Hmm, you sure you are a Melbourne supporter? Seems you might be working under an alias looking at this post...

Maybe I should proof read. But u get what I mean.

 

[longdaveyjetta]

Someone put in on Carlton board this morning.
C4[2]Yo'Door

You can't expect us to know that, aren't all neutrals perma banned from the carlton board..

 

[Beer n Skittles]

You can't expect us to know that, aren't all neutrals perma banned from the carlton board..

just passing on where the rumour started. don't worry, I'll keep my expectations of what you know low so as not to be disappointed

 

[Snowplough]

Above Melbourne

Yawn.

You think you're original? See post #156.

 

[Seb78]

A shame they don't have Caddy to offer Hirdy then....

We'll take Gaff instead

 

[mediumsizered]

You can't expect us to know that, aren't all neutrals perma banned from the carlton board..

They should be, but if you know of anyone we've missed, please let us know.

 

[tigs2010]

Yawn.

You think you're original? See post #156.

In fairness it was still true the second time it was posted.

 

[astrodee]

You did watch this season didn't you?Dawes was pathetic to say the least... Right now Melbourne clearly look the fools with their revolving Dawes policy...

Whoever tried to make a ruckman out of him is the fool. He was a very effective KPF before he was stuffed around. Now he feels he's got something to prove.

Excellent motivation.

 

[saintsrfreak]

Whoever tried to make a ruckman out of him is the fool. He was a very effective KPF before he was stuffed around. Now he feels he's got something to prove.

Excellent motivation.

I wouldn't say 27 and 30 goals in a season is "very effective"

 

[Demonheart]

You did watch this season didn't you?Dawes was pathetic to say the least... Right now Melbourne clearly look the fools with their revolving Dawes policy...

Did you watch the season? Even Collingwood have admitted that they tried to play him in a role that he was unable to do. Apparently you didn't.

 

[Theo X]

I wouldn't say 27 and 30 goals in a season is "very effective"

It's not a bad return for a CHF though.

 

[RossFC]

Hey guys I've got some news on 2 players (My dad does tax for both the players fathers).
1. 2 months ago Panos's dad told my dad, Bulldogs are trying to turn Panos into a backman (He is currently a forward).
2. On Friday Polec's dad told my dad, Polec from Brisbane is thinking of coming home to South Australia after the 2013 season.
Obviously the sources are the players fathers.

 

[Igloo]

Hey guys I've got some news on 2 players (My dad does tax for both the players fathers).
1. 2 months ago Panos's dad told my dad, Bulldogs are trying to turn Panos into a backman (He is currently a forward).
2. On Friday Polec's dad told my dad, Polec from Brisbane is thinking of coming home to South Australia after the 2013 season.
Obviously the sources are the players fathers.

Panos played in defence a lot in the VFL this year, and did it pretty well. Played both forward and back though, and even some stints in the ruck, for some crazy unknown reason.

Quick question though, why is that trade news?

 

[saintsrfreak]

Saw that Iles from GC was delisted, his numbers look decent, what's he like?

 

[RossFC]

Quick question though, why is that trade news?

Its not But I thought i'd share it with everyone.

 

[scottwade]

Hey guys I've got some news on 2 players (My dad does tax for both the players fathers).
1. 2 months ago Panos's dad told my dad, Bulldogs are trying to turn Panos into a backman (He is currently a forward).
2. On Friday Polec's dad told my dad, Polec from Brisbane is thinking of coming home to South Australia after the 2013 season.
Obviously the sources are the players fathers.

I'd suggest that, assuming this is true, you aren't quite so specific regarding your source.
Not sure your dad would appreciate losing clients due to you posting on BF.

 

[saintsrfreak]

I'd suggest that, assuming this is true, you aren't quite so specific regarding your source.
Not sure your dad would appreciate losing clients due to you posting on BF.

I'm sure Jared Polec reads bigfooty

 

[dlanod]

I'm sure Jared Polec reads bigfooty

Guys who talk to Polec do (not implying that that's myself).

 

[Dugg]

Both Paul Bower (Carlton) and Sam Iles (Gold Coast) have been delisted...would be good pickups for clubs needing defenders.

 

[UpTheGuts]

Polec was going to be part of the Tippett trade had Kurt decided to go to the Lions.

Brisbane would want him to have a good year in 2013 or they might not get much for him

 

[RossFC]

I'd suggest that, assuming this is true, you aren't quite so specific regarding your source.
Not sure your dad would appreciate losing clients due to you posting on BF.

Im sure Polec's dad wouldn't have said it if he didn't want the news to become public.

 

[pauldrc]

Polec was going to be part of the Tippett trade had Kurt decided to go to the Lions.

Really???

According to whom?

 

[Red Bull]

Okay here's a four way deal that i think works for all parties involved :

Deal 1. Carl > 11 to Syd for Parker and 22
Deal 2. Syd > 11 to Adel for Tippett
Deal3. Carl > Warnock and 22 to St.K for 13
Deal4. St.K > 22 to West Coast for Mitch Brown

So final washup :

Carl : In Parker and 13 Out : Warnock and 11

Syd : In Tippett Out : Parker and 22

St.K : In Warnock and Mitch Brown Out : 13

WC : In 22 Out : Mitch Brown

Adel : In 11 Out : Tippett

 

[Igloo]

Carlton get too much. Warnock's value is nowhere near high enough for that to go through.
Effectively Warnock for Parker and a downgrade of 2 spots on their first pick. Not very even.

 

[livnixon9]

I doubt Carlton will get involved in trade week. Mick is more concerned about flogging books than flogging ruckman.