Trade hypotheticals (2015 version)

[Taylor]

Lol Yarran... No thanks

Shauny B's replacement.

You'll get him for way unders and he will look like a star.

 

[Oddhawk]

Shauny B's replacement.

You'll get him for way unders and he will look like a star.

Shows what you think of Burgoyne....

Anderson is well on his way in that role.

 

[Taylor]

Shows what you think of Burgoyne....

Anderson is well on his way in that role.

That he is getting old and your game plan is built on speed and clean ball use.

It's cool that you disagree though, that's why some get paid the big bucks to list manage and others argue over the internet

 

[Oddhawk]

That he is getting old and your game plan is built on speed and clean ball use.

It's cool that you disagree though, that's why some get paid the big bucks to list manage and others argue over the internet

Not writing it off entirely, don't get me wrong. But we all know how easy it is to deal with Carlton. Would need to be SERIOUSLY unders. In which case you'd think Carlton could do better.

 

[Taylor]

Not writing it off entirely, don't get me wrong. But we all know how easy it is to deal with Carlton. Would need to be SERIOUSLY unders. In which case you'd think Carlton could do better.

It's penciled in for end of 2016

 

[doona]

That he is getting old and your game plan is built on speed and clean ball use.

It's cool that you disagree though, that's why some get paid the big bucks to list manage and others argue over the internet

And the ones that get paid the big bucks won't trade a first rounder for Yarran.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

It's penciled in for end of 2016

That is the trump card we have with Yaran, if nothing decent comes in we hold onto him and get free agency pick next year.

 

[Oddhawk]

That is the trump card we have with Yaran, if nothing decent comes in we hold onto him and get free agency pick next year.

Rather than doing the right thing by the player? No wonder Carlton doesn't get much done during Trade.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Rather than doing the right thing by the player? No wonder Carlton doesn't get much done during Trade.

He is contracted, we will pay his salary... what more are we supposed to do.

 

[Oddhawk]

He is contracted, we will pay his salary... what more are we supposed to do.

If he wants to be there... nothing.

If he doesn't then you should probably do what's best for the player. That may mean taking marginally less than he's "worth". Being a trade friendly club far out weighs the benefits of being a PIA club to trade with.

 

[Jeremias]

Rather than doing the right thing by the player? No wonder Carlton doesn't get much done during Trade.

Don't know what rock you've been living under, but Carlton has been fairly active on the trade table for the past couple of years.

Might want to head to Bay 13 if all you're going to do is troll poorly.

 

[Oddhawk]

Don't know what rock you've been living under, but Carlton has been fairly active on the trade table for the past couple of years.

Might want to head to Bay 13 if all you're going to do is troll poorly.

LLLLOOOOOLLLL Carlton and Essendon are notorious for being extremely difficult to work with during trade week. The only teams that dont get that are Essendon and Carlton. Last year excluded in which the Jacksh trade was semi reasonable.

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

Hansen > Richmond for 1st Round Pick.
Ontraded to Hawthorn for Hartung

Black > Fremantle for Weller

Thomas > Adelaide for Lever

Bastinac > GWS for Plowman

Swallow > Gold Coast for O'Meara

 

[Red Bull]

Hansen > Richmond for 1st Round Pick.
Ontraded to Hawthorn for Hartung

Black > Fremantle for Weller

Thomas > Adelaide for Lever

Bastinac > GWS for Plowman

Swallow > Gold Coast for O'Meara

Nahas > Gold Coast for Ablett

Daw > GWS for Cameron

 

[Oddhawk]

Hansen > Richmond for 1st Round Pick.
Ontraded to Hawthorn for Hartung

Black > Fremantle for Weller

Thomas > Adelaide for Lever

Bastinac > GWS for Plowman

Swallow > Gold Coast for O'Meara

I don't think the Hawks are going to want to be trading Hartung. Not saying it won't happen.

Thomas for Lever I think is very unlikely!

Who becomes captain if you sell Swallow!

 

[Oddhawk]

Nahas > Gold Coast for Ablett

Daw > GWS for Cameron

GWS are screaming for a ruck forward!!

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

Nahas > Gold Coast for Ablett

Daw > GWS for Cameron

Nahas and Daw walk up starts for Carlton this week.

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

I don't think the Hawks are going to want to be trading Hartung. Not saying it won't happen.

Thomas for Lever I think is very unlikely!

Who becomes captain if you sell Swallow!

I agree, but he hadnt signed, he might think he can get a game and better money somewhere else.
Ziebell becomes captain, fairly obvious i thought.

 

[Oddhawk]

Nahas and Daw walk up starts for Carlton this week.

Nahas maybe. Daw couldn't get a run for the Heyfield 2nds

 

[Oddhawk]

I agree, but he hadnt signed, he might think he can get a game and better money somewhere else.
Ziebell becomes captain, fairly obvious i thought.

I think Hartung will sign.

but actively offering your captain.... wow

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

GWS are screaming for a ruck forward!!

They did take O'halpin

 

[Jeremias]

LLLLOOOOOLLLL Carlton and Essendon are notorious for being extremely difficult to work with during trade week. The only teams that dont get that are Essendon and Carlton. Last year excluded in which the Jacksh trade was semi reasonable.

Yawn.

Come back to me when you're prepared to enter into a rational and reasonable discussion.

Until then, feel free to troll to your heart's content over on Bay 13. Looks like you'd fit right in there.

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

I think Hartung will sign.

but actively offering your captain.... wow

Western Bulldogs seem to be going okay...

 

[Oddhawk]

Western Bulldogs seem to be going okay...

They didn't actively shop Griffen around. He wanted to leave so they did what was best for the player. Carlton could take note Jeremias
Granted they ended up doing ok out of it as I'm sure North would. Does Swallow want to leave though?

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

They didn't actively shop Griffen around. He wanted to leave so they did what was best for the player. Carlton could take note Jeremias
Granted they ended up doing ok out of it as I'm sure North would. Does Swallow want to leave though?

Might be his best chance to play along side his brother.