Campbell Brown vs Beau Waters

[DrTomSwift]

Who will be the viewed as the better player at the end of their careers?

 

[Hangover]

Campbell Brown. Premiership player in 08, surrounded by an abundance of talent at GC who will quickly overtake WC on the charge to a flag. AA 07, voted most courage's in 02 and 05. Will hold down CHB at GC, will end with another Flag before Waters.

 

[Frothies Mcveigh]

Campbell Brown, although Waters is the better player imo.

 

[StillWaiting5689]

Went with Waters, have never really rated brown, always seen him as a tough player always on a mission to justify his standing as a tough player in the game.

 

[Winky]

Waters was a premiership player in 06 and unfortunately hasn't played much since then. If he continues as he had in the past year I think he would be seen as the better player but at the moment Brown would rate higher purely on games played. In my view it also seemed that Brown was on the wane a bit in his last year for the hawks..maybe he will get a bit back with the Suns.

 

[HyperAgressiveDonk]

People forget how good Brown was in 07. He played on guys 5 inches taller than him reguarly and towelled up the best forwards in the game. Hence the AA selection

 

[Winky]

People forget how good Brown was in 07. He played on guys 5 inches taller than him reguarly and towelled up the best forwards in the game. Hence the AA selection

I agree...he has been a great player for your club but he did seem a bit down on form last year?

 

[HyperAgressiveDonk]

I agree...he has been a great player for your club but he did seem a bit down on form last year?

Yeah he did. He was already gone though, as the GC and him struck a deal before the season had started from what I understand. I also think there was some internal bickering involving him. Sad end to a very good servant at the HFC

 

[Dan]

Who'd win in a fight?

 

[grizzlym]

People forget how good Brown was in 07. He played on guys 5 inches taller than him reguarly and towelled up the best forwards in the game. Hence the AA selection

I believe that the interpretation of the chopping the arms rule changed and affected Campbell's ability to play on the bigger forwards like he did in his AA year. He hasn't been nearly as effective since.

 

[willoblue]

Who'd win in a fight?

if Brown wasn't looking, waters would iron him out, but if it was face 2 face, Brown would slap him silly.

both reasonable players. Brown's AA playing tall was really well done.

 

[power09]

I voted Waters because he is a much better player, but i fear bown my be remember more for the same reason most people know about him now, he seems to be popular for some reason

 

[Byron_Clanger]

Beau Beau will get more respect if he doesn't dog us and go to Western Sydney next year

 

[Joshen]

Campbell Brown, although Waters is the better player imo.

Agree with this.

 

[Schulzenfest]

Who will be the viewed as the better player at the end of their careers?

Who will be viewed as the better player? Brown.

Who will actually be the better player? Waters.