Mega Thread Possible trades in 2015 for the Crows

[Kane Johnson]

Has anyone else noticed Sam Shaw's stellar effort at the 41 second mark in the Hampton video .

 

[Linekers Ears]

Straight swap for Sam Shaw?

Don't want to do that. SAM might come good.

 

[40porpoise]

Out of all the possible trades I really hope we get Menzel. I think he's an absolute star. Reminds me of wingard. If we manage to land him I think we'd have the best forward line in the whole comp BY FAR.

Eddie jenkins Charlie
Lynch tex Menzel.

That would definitely make for an exciting mix.

 

[latinoheat]

How many "live" selections do people think we will have in the national draft?
Would we only need 2 live picks? I'd imagine if we trade CEY, Grigg or Kerridge we would get a second or third round pick. Can't see us using picks in the fourth round.

Patrick Dangerfield (8yrs) : draft selection
Cameron Ellis-Yolmen : re-sign
Matthew Wright : delist draft selection
Mitchell Grigg : trade or keep
Sam Kerridge : trade or keep
James Podsiadly : ROB upgrade
Matt Crouch : will resign
Sam Siggins : Kelly upgrade
Rory Atkins : re-sign?
Sam Shaw : re-sign?
Brodie Martin: Hampton trade in

 

[WaynesWorld19]

15-20 would be my guess, probably your selection if he's available ( might go before that ).. He would be a nice fit at the Pies as the 3rd target behind Cloke and Moore, he would compliment those guys well.

IMO "late first .....20 - 25 seems right .....Bernie Vince was IIRC was #21

 

[King Elvis]

Kelly Osborne.

 

[Linekers Ears]

Has anyone else noticed Sam Shaw's stellar effort at the 41 second mark in the Hampton video .

Shush. We're trying to flip him to the Hawks who now need a key defender and like left footers

 

[Elite Crow]

Kelly Osborne.

Look on the previous page, Drugs should be in our group

 

[Pugsley]

Kelly Osbourne

1 - 0 Carl. Papa don't preach.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Out of all the possible trades I really hope we get Menzel. I think he's an absolute star. Reminds me of wingard. If we manage to land him I think we'd have the best forward line in the whole comp BY FAR.

Eddie jenkins Charlie
Lynch tex Menzel.

That would definitely make for an exciting mix.

This ......if he has the engine would be a great wingman

Surprisingly tall & still 21 YO

Troy Menzel
Forward
Height
187 cm
DOB
22-09-1994
Weight
83 kg

 

[tige19]

He started this years PS as a jet ......yet didn't make round 1 side

Think most had Jed in their Supercoach side ....so expectations were high ....what happened?

Missed some footy with his shoulder and other niggles, he barely trained during the season and had no tank ( hence playing perm forward )... He was in a coma last year from his illness and in all seriousness was lucky to be alive.

There has also been some whispers about him being a little uneasy, there's a lot of conjecture about whether he is signed or not and it's all quite worrying. Our board will meltdown if he goes, but I can't help to think that something just isn't 100%.

 

[Ron Hubbard]

Kelly Osborne.

you sure?

 

[Max Cottaletta]

I've never met a Kelly who wasn't pretty.

Kelly Slater?

 

[TheLeftFist8]

Yep, if there's any chance of landing Menzel then we must get him! Talent+++

If we need to get D Menzel from the Geelong trade to get the brothers together then so be it

 

[tige19]

IMO "late first .....20 - 25 seems right .....Bernie Vince was IIRC was #21

Yeah Burton could drop to that 25 mark, like I said most of us are having a stab as no one really knows. I wouldn't be surprised if Burton wasn't gone by 15/16 either.

 

[Draft Bored]

Why the Jeansch hate on here? Is it the drink driving incident?

Drink driving incident topped it off for me.

- I'm sick of his kick ins (bounce, run 10 metres, bomb to Jacobs on the right hand side of the field).
- Then his comments on twitter to a fan who was giving him a hard time. Returned serve with a joke about the guy having a 9-5 job... um yeah, cause that's a bad thing? So do 60k of your members.
- Thinks he can have any girl in Adelaide.
- Endangering peoples lives topped it off.

Yes he's improved and I was shattered when he did his knee but I've moved on.

 

[Linekers Ears]

Missed some footy with his shoulder and other niggles, he barely trained during the season and had no tank ( hence playing perm forward )... He was in a coma last year from his illness and in all seriousness was lucky to be alive.

There has also been some whispers about him being a little uneasy, there's a lot of conjecture about whether he is signed or not and it's all quite worrying. Our board will meltdown if he goes, but I can't help to think that something just isn't 100%.

Is he contracted for next year?

I looked and couldn't tell.

I'd like to have him at the Crows but i reckon you're over rating him.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Missed some footy with his shoulder and other niggles, he barely trained during the season and had no tank ( hence playing perm forward )... He was in a coma last year from his illness and in all seriousness was lucky to be alive.

There has also been some whispers about him being a little uneasy, there's a lot of conjecture about whether he is signed or not and it's all quite worrying. Our board will meltdown if he goes, but I can't help to think that something just isn't 100%.

Why did he hardly train ......he was flying PS?

What's he uneasy about ? .....is he contracted ?

 

[Mego Red]

You don't get a first round pick for a player who is outside your best 18.

Anderson would be great - but he's a 2nd round pick.

 

[dylan123]

Drink driving incident topped it off for me.

- I'm sick of his kick ins (bounce, run 10 metres, bomb to Jacobs on the right hand side of the field).
- Then his comments on twitter to a fan who was giving him a hard time. Returned serve with a joke about the guy having a 9-5 job... um yeah, cause that's a bad thing? So do 60k of your members.
- Thinks he can have any girl in Adelaide.
- Endangering peoples lives topped it off.

Yes he's improved and I was shattered when he did his knee but I've moved on.

So only one thing that's related to his on-field performances (not going to argue that he comes across as a knob) and that one problem is something that hasn't changed no matter who has taken the kick in. Perhaps the blame shouldn't be directed at the players

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Yep, if there's any chance of landing Menzel then we must get him! Talent+++

If we need to get D Menzel from the Geelong trade to get the brothers together then so be it

IMO Target #1

 

[tige19]

Why did he hardly train ......he was flying PS?

What's he uneasy about ? .....is he contracted ?

A few sessions he wasn't seen ( rumours are he may have ducked off home ), he also had shoulder issues.

Jed is a mystery for a lot on our board, there's posters who are brilliantly informed who says he's signed but absolutely nothing from the club.

 

[tige19]

Is he contracted for next year?

I looked and couldn't tell.

I'd like to have him at the Crows but i reckon you're over rating him.

Maybe/maybe not, you really never know with 20/21 year olds do you ( unless it's Patrick Cripps or Jesse Hogan)

 

[TheLeftFist8]

So only one thing that's related to his on-field performances (not going to argue that he comes across as a knob) and that one problem is something that hasn't changed no matter who has taken the kick in. Perhaps the blame shouldn't be directed at the players

I'd like to see Jaensch trialled as an outside mid…got to be way better than Mackay. Actually get him to use his kick as a weapon.

The stint in defence wasn't wasted as he became a very good one-on-one player which looked a laughable proposition early on. Get that harder edge up on the wing and I reckon he would do well lacing out Menzel or bombing them from 60

Would be like a new recruit in a position we are pathetic in at present, and there's no room in defence imo.

 

[PERRIE]

If you have lost track who owns which pick and which cub is linked to who:

http://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl...recruits-rookies/story-e6frf35c-1227558844054