Traded Jake Carlisle [traded w/ #23 and #44 for #5, #24 and Craig Bird]

[YEMOC NAYR]

If the deal doesn't get done, tell me what will happen. I'll give you a hint, he won't be going back to Essendon. StKilda CAN walk away from negotiations.
Ameet Bains will be running the show i guess.

But you won't walk away... you've both now commited to each other..... it may sound good for you but you won't be walking away lol

 

[eth-dog]

LOL, and you have Bellchambers

Bellchambers played poorly when the club ****ed up his injury management on his ankle. He kicked 28 goals from 18 games in 2013, whilst averaging 22 hitouts as well. To put it in perspective, Dean Cox never averaged 20+ hitouts and 1.5 goals/game in his career.

 

[Paul_Barnard]

pick 5 for carlisle and essendons second rounder which is ontraded to collingwood for freeman. how is this not perfect for all?


He's not worth 5. But 5 is worth Freeman and Carlisle. Collingwood would take our second for freeman. (or if saints really wanted, they could trade their second and keep ours which is 1 selection ahead)

Collingwood win, essendon get an early selection for carlisle and our second (which I'd rate at around pick 6 or so) and saints give up pick 5 for 2 talents. Win win win

Agreed Pick 5 for Carlisle and Freeman is great value

 

[DaniFletch]

LOL, and you have Bellchambers

Bellchambers, who has proven he can be a top 5 ruck/fwd in the competition, with 28.11 in 2013 while averaging over 20 hitouts.

You can always tell those who have never watched somebody outside of their own club play.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Bellchambers played poorly when the club stuffed up his injury management on his ankle. He kicked 28 goals from 18 games in 2013, whilst averaging 22 hitouts as well. To put it in perspective, Dean Cox never averaged 20+ hitouts and 1.5 goals/game in his career.

Great you should be able to trade him for 3 first round draft picks.

 

[Bunk Moreland]

If the deal doesn't get done, tell me what will happen. I'll give you a hint, he won't be going back to Essendon. StKilda CAN walk away from negotiations.
Ameet Bains will be running the show i guess.

The deal will get done. Why the hell wouldn't it?

You sound like the Carlton fappers from a couple of weeks ago.

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

The deal will get done. Why the hell wouldn't it?

You sound like the Carlton fappers from a couple of weeks ago.

cos saints hold all the cards mate, because if they dont get what they want they will walk away LOL

No chance. They will be taking carlisle

 

[eth-dog]

Great you should be able to trade him for 3 first round draft picks.

Haha, get proven wrong so childishly insult the other person. Nice.

 

[jwint43]

Ive seen what jake can do so im excited to see if he gets motivated. Rather not give up pick 5 though.

 

[blueboy25]

Bellchambers, who has proven he can be a top 5 ruck/fwd in the competition, with 28.11 in 2013 while averaging over 20 hitouts.

You can always tell those who have never watched somebody outside of their own club play.

I wonder if anything happened over the summer of 2012/2013 that helped him have a career best season?

 

[Milenko]

As a neutral I can confidently say that Bellchambers is a horrible ruckman.

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

I wonder if anything happened over the summer of 2012/2013 that helped him have a career best season?

His form declined when he broke up with Mrs.Universe Australia....... I don't blame him.. everything in his life is now second rate

 

[DaniFletch]

I wonder if anything happened over the summer of 2012/2013 that helped him have a career best season?

Kicked 15 of his 28 goals in last 9 rounds after the vitamins had stopped. Move on.

 

[DaniFletch]

As a neutral I can confidently say that Bellchambers is a horrible ruckman.

He's not a ruckman. He's a forward/ruck.

 

[blueboy25]

His form declined when he broke up with Mrs.Universe Australia....... I don't blame him

I saw her doing the weather report on channel 9 in Perth last night.

My form would decline if I broke up with her as well.

 

[Oraaaaazio]

As a neutral I can confidently say that Bellchambers is a horrible ruckman.

There we have it everyone, someone who probably hasn't seen much of him knows he is a horrible ruckman. Clearly he is an authority on the subject and no need to argue your points anymore.

He is a NEUTRAL. Surely couldn't be wrong.

 

[Gavin Excell]

Essendon get deals done. We will again here.

I'm wondering if St Kilda can, because they have a history of not doing so.

Again - who runs this stuff for the Saints?

Just on this about essendon gets deals done - have read and heard comments that suggest Dons are notoriously difficult to deal with. Is this real?

 

[Foxx]

Pick

 

[eth-dog]

Just on this about essendon gets deals done - have read and heard comments that suggest Dons are notoriously difficult to deal with. Is this real?

Ryder got to Port. Crameri got to WB. Edwards and Aylett got to Essendon. Gumbleton got to Freo.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Taking extreme outcomes from the trade negotiations.
1. Essendon refuse to accept a reasonable offer, they want pick 1 and Billings. Saints walk away. Possible outcomes: Carlisle can choose to stay at Essendon or choose to go in the draft with the terms of his employment specified.

2. StKilda refuse to make a reasonable offer, they only offer a straight swap with Shenton. Possible outcomes : Carlisle can choose to stay at Essendon or choose to go in the draft with the terms of his employment specified.

have i missed any possible outcomes here?

 

[SaintsSeptember]

As a neutral I can confidently say that Bellchambers is a horrible ruckman.

Aren't you paying attention, he's better than Dean Cox.

 

[eth-dog]

Taking extreme outcomes from the trade negotiations.
1. Essendon refuse to accept a reasonable offer, they want pick 1 and Billings. Saints walk away. Possible outcomes: Carlisle can choose to stay at Essendon or choose to go in the draft with the terms of his employment specified.

2. StKilda refuse to make a reasonable offer, they only offer a straight swap with Shenton. Possible outcomes : Carlisle can choose to stay at Essendon or choose to go in the draft with the terms of his employment specified.

have i missed any possible outcomes here?

Yes, the one that is likely to happen:

St. Kilda and Essendon agree on a deal close to Carlisle's worth. Pick 5

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Ryder got to Port. Crameri got to WB. Edwards and Aylett got to Essendon. Gumbleton got to Freo.

These are all players who wanted to leave.
Have you actually had any decent trades going the other way?

 

[Foxx]

Taking extreme outcomes from the trade negotiations.
1. Essendon refuse to accept a reasonable offer, they want pick 1 and Billings. Saints walk away. Possible outcomes: Carlisle can choose to stay at Essendon or choose to go in the draft with the terms of his employment specified.

2. StKilda refuse to make a reasonable offer, they only offer a straight swap with Shenton. Possible outcomes : Carlisle can choose to stay at Essendon or choose to go in the draft with the terms of his employment specified.

have i missed any possible outcomes here?

That's Carlisle in your avator pic.

 

[marky53]

Ryder got to Port. Crameri got to WB. Edwards and Aylett got to Essendon. Gumbleton got to Freo.

You forgot Monfries who we traded to Port when he could have gone there as a FA but Port didn't want to reduce their compo. Yep we are hard to deal with