List Mgmt. 2016 Trade/Free Agency Part 2

[Morro]

Also Ellis is younger than Prestia and has played more games and nearly has the same amount of brownlow votes.
Ellis is getting pretty underrated here. With a proper game plan he is a very good player.

Agreed.

Edwards and BEllis alone is overs for Prestia - would do though but would like a 2nd rounder back our way which would be fair IMO.

 

[Groupie_]

Anderson going with edwards brandon and conca for prestia. I do know we are desperate to keep our first and thamt is one way to do it but will gcs take it?

pick 6 is haunted dont care if we lose it

theres never been a good pick 6 player

 

[Nostradumbass]

Would you rather give up pick 6 or those 3?

Can we throw Hardwick in aswell?

 

[Groupie_]

Also Ellis is younger than Prestia and has played more games and nearly has the same amount of brownlow votes.
Ellis is getting pretty underrated here. With a proper game plan he is a very good player.

hes a spud, cant hit a target, soft as butter, cant even handball

momentum killer

get rid of him for anything before we have to delist him. he cannot hit a simple 15 metre pass which most of us can do blindfolded

hes one that u dont want in your team

 

[tigs2010]

pick 6 is haunted dont care if we lose it

theres never been a good pick 6 player

Wingard would look alright in our side. Same with Macrae. I think we picked such a dud in 2010 it broke the curse.

 

[Groupie_]

Watches Ellis living on the gold coast imagine how the tan would develop up there and he gets to open his watches boutique on cavill ave

bloke would be in heaven

 

[M0557]

Butler plays with the ferocity of a flea Weightman.nowhere near the class and ball winning skills , but I like his attack on the ball .
He's a keeper. I'm sick of soft **** newted little Tom cats on our list.

It's about time we added some more grunt and big bodies to help Martin and Lids out..... I cringe every time we get knocked off the ball, or we cannot hold a tackle.... when we do actually tackle.
Can I ask RFC to pump up the gym sessions in the off-season?

 

[Sol23]

hes a spud, cant hit a target, soft as butter, cant even handball

momentum killer

get rid of him for anything before we have to delist him. he cannot hit a simple 15 metre pass which most of us can do blindfolded

hes one that u dont want in your team

He's good in those 3km time trials though.....

 

[tigs2010]

Anderson going with edwards brandon and conca for prestia. I do know we are desperate to keep our first and thamt is one way to do it but will gcs take it?

Who gets Mrs Conca's lasagna?

 

[TigerImposter]

If possible could we start a thread with just off season rumors from media outlets with links to reports

that will blow out to 400 pages

 

[Groupie_]

Cometti was right when he said we picked the worst possible time to bottom out. How do we fix this mess (**** u afl and gc gws)

 

[M0557]

Can we throw Hardwick in aswell?

We may have to then throw Pick 6 in in that case.....

 

[tigs2010]

Cometti was right when he said we picked the worst possible time to bottom out. How do we fix this mess (**** u afl and gc gws)

Lmfao yeah we just decided we would rebuild for fun

 

[M0557]

Cometti was right when he said we picked the worst possible time to bottom out. How do we fix this mess (**** u afl and gc gws)

And here we keep blaming everyone else but OUR recruiting failures for the position we are in.
Bad recruiting and poor or lack of due diligence has got us to the position we find ourselves in. And then an insipid style of coaching on top of all that.....
As mentioned on SEN, we are all too NICE at Punt Road, time to dig the heels in..... If it ain't working, fix it properly...... Look at Brisbane, their horror past 5 years from Crazy Vossy into Leppa and they won't mess about, quick vote and Leppa is gone today....... Where has the Ruthless Tiger gone?

 

[Groupie_]

Lmfao yeah we just decided we would rebuild for fun

should have topped up with old campaigners and kept terry as coach and most of terrys list finished 9th in 2010, 11, 12 and then bottom out

 

[M0557]

I struggle to think, how can so many of the 70,000+ members have little or no faith with Hardwick or his (non-existent) gameplan, yet within those 'Four Walls' it appears all rosy?
How can there be such a gap between our views, and the clubs views?
Perhaps we are obviously not in the know about what 100% goes on within the club, if all of us cannot tolerate it, then why do the RFC board?

 

[Caveman68]

And here we keep blaming everyone else but OUR recruiting failures for the position we are in.
Bad recruiting and poor or lack of due diligence has got us to the position we find ourselves in. And then an insipid style of coaching on top of all that.....
As mentioned on SEN, we are all too NICE at Punt Road, time to dig the heels in..... If it ain't working, fix it properly...... Look at Brisbane, their horror past 5 years from Crazy Vossy into Leppa and they won't mess about, quick vote and Leppa is gone today....... Where has the Ruthless Tiger gone?

We don't want to crack the facade of stability.

 

[SumTingWong]

I struggle to think, how can so many of the 70,000+ members have little or no faith with Hardwick or his (non-existent) gameplan, yet within those 'Four Walls' it appears all rosy?
How can there be such a gap between our views, and the clubs views?
Perhaps we are obviously not in the know about what 100% goes on within the club, if all of us cannot tolerate it, then why do the RFC board?

I don't know how you can come to that conclusion until after the review is done and also to see what we do in terms of player movement. Only then can you come to any conclusions as to what you think the club thinks of our current situation.

 

[poppa pump]

stay away from omeara,then this wont be us.

 

[M0557]

I don't know how you can come to that conclusion until after the review is done and also to see what we do in terms of player movement. Only then can you come to any conclusions as to what you think the club thinks of our current situation.

True..... I just feel completely ECO after the insipid year we have had, the performance on Saturday just left me looking for answers I guess......
And I am impatient.....

 

[duzzy]

I don't know how you can come to that conclusion until after the review is done and also to see what we do in terms of player movement. Only then can you come to any conclusions as to what you think the club thinks of our current situation.

is there a proper review---?
i have only heard/read the company line "we review every week- in football these days we are constantly reviewing"---?

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Anderson going with edwards brandon and conca for prestia. I do know we are desperate to keep our first and thamt is one way to do it but will gcs take it?

lol Edwards , pick 15 and pick 6 from 2010 who should be in the prime of their life . If that occurs how do they justify keeping Fine Eyes.
The campaigner is no good , he is a ex vfl scrubber who also happens to be a school teacher , no wonder our list is full of boring , shit skilled soft cocked hbf's.

 

[poppa pump]

kirby can we get him via OUR ACADEMY, IF WE CAN, THAT WOULD EXCIT ME BIG TIME.

 

[captain cotch 9]

kirby can we get him via OUR ACADEMY, IF WE CAN, THAT WOULD EXCIT ME BIG TIME.

Not this year.
Next year we can but he will be in this years draft

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

kirby can we get him via OUR ACADEMY, IF WE CAN, THAT WOULD EXCIT ME BIG TIME.

Acedemy selections arent available to RFC till 2017 and evidence must be provided of sufficient development .My understanding is that to this point only behind the scenes establishment has commenced and therefore it is likely to be 2020 before any academy selections are likely.