List Mgmt. Trade & F.A. 2017 (if a scenario sounds wrong - read on before posting)

[ottoman]

....

Again with the trade De Goey talk?

Why do people thinking trading one of our handful of future A graders is a good idea?

We are hoping to land a few more Mayne type players.
If you want class you have to pay up.

 

[Stoods]

We are hoping to land a few more Mayne type players.
If you want class you have to pay up.

Just wait 1 more year for lynch and we get him as a FA

 

[left at home]

Might be 2 1st Rounders and De Goey and even Thomas

Way to much td, those type of deals never gets u a flag

 

[Apex36]

....

Again with the trade De Goey talk?

Why do people thinking trading one of our handful of future A graders is a good idea?

As far as I can see the the majority don't.

 

[left at home]

....

Again with the trade De Goey talk?

Why do people thinking trading one of our handful of future A graders is a good idea?

He is a keeper, to much talent to give away

 

[Scodog10]

....

Again with the trade De Goey talk?

Why do people thinking trading one of our handful of future A graders is a good idea?

Gotta give something to get something. I'm on the "trade Steele" bandwagon if some big chips are on the table, but I know you're a big fan so I think you'll need to cop this one especially considering he was on the table last year and his early season indiscretion.

 

[legendstatus]

....

Again with the trade De Goey talk?

Why do people thinking trading one of our handful of future A graders is a good idea?

He ain't Judd nor will he ever get close to AA, first & JDG is just enough!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Go Woods]

So we grab him for 2019? Another stop gap forward for next year? Oh dear.

No we go after him this coming trade period.

 

[Copeland]

So we grab him for 2019? Another stop gap forward for next year? Oh dear.

We arent the only one's who can grab him

 

[TradeDraft]

....

Again with the trade De Goey talk?

Why do people thinking trading one of our handful of future A graders is a good idea?

I would not Call De Goey a A Grader Yet. B-B+ Player

 

[doodles98]

I would not Call De Goey a A Grader Yet. B-B+ Player

he did say FUTURE A grader

I will be getting very grumpy if we trade DeGoey.

 

[TradeDraft]

he did say FUTURE A grader

I will be getting very grumpy if we trade DeGoey.

For the Right Player I would.

Would you Trade De Goey for Tom Lynch?

 

[unplugged]

Again, we wait until Lynch is a Free Agent next year and we're up against 16 other clubs chasing him at the same time. That and GCS can match unless we put forward such an unbelievable offer to him that it ruins our salary cap anyway.

Making him an offer this year wouldn't be the worst idea.

 

[Go Woods]

[

He ain't Judd nor will he ever get close to AA, first & JDG is just enough!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

That's a huge call regarding AA...his only 21 with massive upside. BTW Judd types come along once in a generation. JDG may well become a Dusty.

 

[ChubbyGallon]

Surprised that Jack Redpaths name hasnt been brought up.. Only 26 KPF and would be a cheap option both trade value and Salary.. If we could get Lever and him in this trade period it would be a massive bonus moving forward.

 

[TradeDraft]

Billings has Re-Signed

 

[unplugged]

Nooooooo!!!

 

[doodles98]

For the Right Player I would.

Would you Trade De Goey for Tom Lynch?

No. I'd find another way to get it done. Of all our younger players.. DeGoey and Moore are the ones I most want to keep.

 

[Kappa]

Nooooooo!!!

Surely you can see there are other players we need to spend salary cap on far more than another short midfielder with questionable disposal

 

[whiskeytown]

Having already been linked to Close from Brisbane which doesn't feel me with much excitement, nor did it appear to excite anyone else much either, another Brisbane KPF has said to be looking to leave the club. Jono Freeman is one who seems surplus to requirements at the Lions and I think has shown a fair bit more than Close. Has had quite a few injuries in the past but has kicked 16 goals from his 14 games and is only ~22/23. Would he deemed more worthy of throwing a late pick at rather than Close???

For me it's top grade forwards only.

Would rather we play Cox up front for 23 games than land the Close or Freeman's of this world.

 

[Boris the Contradiction]

I don't think the club would do it, but I'm in the trade Sidebottom camp. His perceived quality league wide is much higher than his actual quality. You just have to listen to the commentators waxing lyrical about him every game to know that.

Most neutrals I know consider Steele to be a top level footballer and although he is a good player, his actual impact on games is minimal. We would get more for him than his worth which is what you want in a trade option.

 

[Go Woods]

Billings has Re-Signed

We would of been right off the recruitment needs radar if we were thinking of chasing him. Don't need him.

 

[TradeDraft]

We would of been right off the recruitment needs radar if we were thinking of chasing him. Don't need him.

He is a Good Kick in what we don't have many at all

 

[Go Woods]

For the Right Player I would.

Would you Trade De Goey for Tom Lynch?

No I truly believe JDG will become our #1 midfielder within the next 2 years...there's other options to get Lynch.

 

[Go Woods]

He is a Good Kick in what we don't have many at all

Daicos and Kirby are good kicks and will play a similar role once they make our seniors. Maynard's a deadly kick and should be moved into the midfield mix in 2018.