Bluemour Discussion Thread X

[Salt Lake Cities]

Gaff too now. Don't get my hopes up. Going to be too shattered when we only land McGovern.

Time to sell the dream SOS.

Convince gaff that Shiel is coming. Convince Shiel that Gaff is coming.

Sell the story, paint the picture.

"With your addition next year Carlton will have the strongest starting midfield in the comp. Cripps, Shiel, Gaff and Kruezer. Supported by some of the best young talent in the country... Dow, Walsh, SPS, Settlefield, O'Brien and Fisher.

And guess who you get to kick it to. The best young forward in the comp, Curnow. With McKay and McGoven as your other options."

Open that war chest sos and sell the story.

Any danger of you taking your own advice??

I’m jacked now, feels like the 90’s....

Sell that story, SOS!!

 

[Bluey24]

The Gaff discussion is just ridiculous

Any Victorian club would beg for his services, yet he chooses Carlton?

 

[SkyhorseTamer]

Read and article about three or four days ago with him being directly quoted that it has always been his intention to stay in Sydney and re-sign.

Typical public stance of all players before their season is over. They are advised to say that by their clubs and managers. I only passed on what a swans staffer told me.

 

[Blue and Silver]

What would it take to get Shiel?

I am guessing

2019 1st pick + at least a 2nd rounder

 

[cocoscout]

I don't beleive Teague is any reason for MM to be choosing Carlton, Teague was never held in high regard at the Cows - Carlton never poached him, he wasn't offered an extension on his contract at Adelaide, Carlton picked him up when he was out of a job, exactly rhe same as Matty Bode who wanted to stay at the Cows but they didn't want him

 

[tencentpiece]

Few pieces:

Setterfield and shiel carlton bound if they chose carlton (e.g GWS preference is to deal with us for a trade put forward). Not sure about Setterfield but Shiel won't look at offers until after the season. We might take salary dumps if required
Lloyd likely to re sign with Sydney. Again no decision until after the season. Club still working overtime to get him in

 

[zeeCFC]

Few pieces:

Setterfield and shiel carlton bound if they chose carlton (e.g GWS preference is to deal with us for a trade put forward). Not sure about Setterfield but Shiel won't look at offers until after the season. We might take salary dumps if required
Lloyd likely to re sign with Sydney. Again no decision until after the season. Club still working overtime to get him in

Thanks TCP, anything on Brodie/Scrimshaw?

 

[Blue and Silver]

Few pieces:

Setterfield and shiel carlton bound if they chose carlton (e.g GWS preference is to deal with us for a trade put forward). Not sure about Setterfield but Shiel won't look at offers until after the season. We might take salary dumps if required
Lloyd likely to re sign with Sydney. Again no decision until after the season. Club still working overtime to get him in

Just a quick clarification.

Do you mean if they choose to leave?

Or if they choose Carlton we can get the deals done?

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

 

[tencentpiece]

Chose Carlton, I doubt either will be at GWS next year. Salary cap pressure and GWS concede they are as good as gone and would prefer that cap relief happens now.

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Few pieces:

Setterfield and shiel carlton bound if they chose carlton (e.g GWS preference is to deal with us for a trade put forward). Not sure about Setterfield but Shiel won't look at offers until after the season. We might take salary dumps if required
Lloyd likely to re sign with Sydney. Again no decision until after the season. Club still working overtime to get him in

Love your posts. But this one seems a little confusing

 

[DangerousD]

I saw Pickets name pop up a few time the last few pages, where has this come from?

On a seperate issue, where has the Neale to the lions come from? If he wanted out, why would he go to QLD?

Also, could we be interested in Duryea?

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Typical public stance of all players before their season is over. They are advised to say that by their clubs and managers. I only passed on what a swans staffer told me.

TBF, Shiel basically said the same thing and many here argued it meant he wasn't coming. Granted they were the one's who didn't want him until next year, if at all, so it suited their argument. Who knows, I will be surprised if he leaves Sydney though. That said, I don't think Sydney fans would be too upset if he did leave judging on what their supporters say about him on their pages. They seem to think he is a bit over rated and a stats padder.

 

[Arr0w]

I don't beleive Teague is any reason for MM to be choosing Carlton, Teague was never held in high regard at the Cows - Carlton never poached him, he wasn't offered an extension on his contract at Adelaide, Carlton picked him up when he was out of a job, exactly rhe same as Matty Bode who wanted to stay at the Cows but they didn't want him

Ask any Crows supporter, they wanted Teague to stay

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Few pieces:

Setterfield and shiel carlton bound if they chose carlton (e.g GWS preference is to deal with us for a trade put forward). Not sure about Setterfield but Shiel won't look at offers until after the season. We might take salary dumps if required
Lloyd likely to re sign with Sydney. Again no decision until after the season. Club still working overtime to get him in

Would be most interesting to know what this is. Would put a lot of arguments to bed.

 

[ITCHY EYEBALLS]

Just a quick clarification.

Do you mean if they choose to leave?

Or if they choose Carlton we can get the deals done?

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

Or if they don’t choose * or Dawks

 

[BIuebagger]

Think tencentpiece means that we will be a massive chance to secure them both if they choose us. Shiel not to make his choice until after they are eliminated makes sense, Setterfield may have already chosen where he wants to end up though. Wouldn't be surprised if the club have already been indicated on that in order to start working on a appropriate deal with supposed club. Hopefully its us he would like to join.

Lloyd would be fantastic. Would fit us like a glove. Think he will re-sign with the Swannies though. If true, nice to see the club have identified his acquisition to be of high importance if he chooses to leave and are working hard to sway him.

 

[cocoscout]

Ask any Crows supporter, they wanted Teague to stay

Ask anyone in the coaching panel they wanted him gone - they wouldn't have if they thought he could coach....

 

[I bleed Blue]

Few pieces:

Setterfield and shiel carlton bound if they chose carlton (e.g GWS preference is to deal with us for a trade put forward). Not sure about Setterfield but Shiel won't look at offers until after the season. We might take salary dumps if required
Lloyd likely to re sign with Sydney. Again no decision until after the season. Club still working overtime to get him in

Thanks TCP.

Do we have an idea of who Shiel may be swaying towards at this stage?

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Would be most interesting to know what this is. Would put a lot of arguments to bed.

Well it won't be this years no.1 going off ironman29. Good mail with this one

 

[ferrisb]

Brad Pearce could football
3rd season, 50plus goals, 4 in winning gf.
Life was good

And a magnificent ponytail!

 

[DangerousD]

Ask anyone in the coaching panel they wanted him gone - they wouldn't have if they thought he could coach....

He was their forwards coach in the season they scored the most points and made the GF.

 

[gardiner stand]

Discussions have been going on between carlton,gws and Shiels manager all year. GWS asked for our first pick,now that it’s pick one we’ve said no. Lots of negotiating to do.

 

[ferrisb]

Currently dominating on the SRP board.

I thought the SRP board was made up just so ShanDog would stop asking to be a mod

 

[Bluella]

And a magnificent ponytail!

He looked permanently unwashed.

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Well it won't be this years no.1 going off ironman29. Good mail with this one

Ah ok, didn't see that one.