List Mgmt. Trade & F/A - 2018/2019 - Part 2!

[Old Spice]

I think you are overrating May.

You sure you're not underrating him?

I think Collingwood supporters suffer from Comingtousitis. Symptoms: as soon as a quality player appears interested in coming to Collingwood the sufferer breaks into cold sweats and their estimation of said player drops rapidly. aka wouldntwanttobepartofaclubthatwouldhavemeasamember

 

[McOrist]

You sure you're not underrating him?

I think Collingwood supporters suffer from Comingtousitis. Symptoms: as soon as a quality player appears interested in coming to Collingwood the sufferer breaks into cold sweats and their estimation of said player drops rapidly. aka wouldntwanttobepartofaclubthatwouldhavemeasamember

Fair enough -there might be a bit of that in my comment. But I'd still rather a player of real offensive class, such as Gaff -especially if it doesn't cost us numerous draft picks. Defensive full backs are easier to find or even create. Offensive defenders -Rance, McGovern etc are much more valuable. I've never viewed May in that last category.

 

[Old Spice]

Fair enough -there might be a bit of that in my comment. But I'd still rather a player of real offensive class, such as Gaff -especially if it doesn't cost us numerous draft picks. Defensive full backs are easier to find or even create. Offensive defenders -Rance, McGovern etc are much more valuable. I've never viewed May in that last category.

I can definitely see value in either approach.

 

[unplugged]

I'd definitely trade Phillips as part of a May trade to GCS if we could get Gaff as a Free Agent.

 

[mike123]

Let's get Weidamen

 

[Kreme Pie]

May is worth a 1st round pick. Maybe add a 4th rounder or fringe player as well.

Moore is worth a first round. Maybe also a 4th rounder or a fringe player as well.

 

[Kreme Pie]

Let's get Weidamen

Weideman would be good.
Also Richards would be good.
Picken in his prime a few years ago.
Stewart would be ok.
We missed Shaw in his prime.

I'm a nostalgic romantic.

Did I miss anyone else connected to Collingwood?

 

[Scottabe_pendles]

You have to be ruthless to be successful.

May makes us more successful.

People overrate draft picks imo. We don't need more kids. We need players who can take us next level.

May is that player.

Why not then Fasolo compensation and Moore compensation (Or a first and Fas compensation) seems fairer?

 

[left at home]

Weideman would be good.
Also Richards would be good.
Picken in his prime a few years ago.
Stewart would be ok.
We missed Shaw in his prime.

I'm a nostalgic romantic.

Did I miss anyone else connected to Collingwood?

Merrett’s

 

[Scottabe_pendles]

Espsically that we can't have a Chance to Match the Offer

Upside is - now we arent getting Lynch we will get a level of compensation depending what Carlton pay for him (Per year)

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Weideman would be good.
Also Richards would be good.
Picken in his prime a few years ago.
Stewart would be ok.
We missed Shaw in his prime.

I'm a nostalgic romantic.

Did I miss anyone else connected to Collingwood?

Get action Jaxson back
Theres a Starcevich at the Lions

 

[Apex36]

Let's get Weidamen

A couple of months ago I would have said no, but he’s quickly winning me over tonight.

 

[legendstatus]

Pretty much what I said about JDG years ago - see what I did there?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Roverjg]

Can anybody advise how Harrison Petty and Oscar Clavarino (two tall defenders drafted last year) went this year?

 

[Apex36]

Pretty much what I said about JDG years ago - see what I did there?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Except Weideman has been invisible for the past few years playing VFL, whereas any mug could see that JDG was going to be a star. Yep, almost exactly the same.

 

[mike123]

Pretty much what I said about JDG years ago - see what I did there?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Yeah but you were a flog about.

 

[TradeDraft]

Can anybody advise how Harrison Petty and Oscar Clavarino (two tall defenders drafted last year) went this year?

Petty been good for Casey.

Don't know about Clavario

 

[Kreme Pie]

Merrett’s

Ah yes, Zach Merrett would be awesome.

 

[legendstatus]

Yeah but you were a flog about.

How so?

Got a like from Apex so must feel good about it?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Tbone McGraw]

Do you think that will get May

Why not then Fasolo compensation and Moore compensation (Or a first and Fas compensation) seems fairer?

 

[sr36]

Weideman would be good.
Also Richards would be good.
Picken in his prime a few years ago.
Stewart would be ok.
We missed Shaw in his prime.

I'm a nostalgic romantic.

Did I miss anyone else connected to Collingwood?

Let's re-sign Moore

 

[brysie]

I'm not sold on May for the following reasons:

1. He is contracted and GC are losing Lynch, their other co-captain. This means we will have to pay steeply for May in order to secure him, rather than waiting a year and assessing whether he is still keen to move and picking him up for free

2. Although May is a good player, Dunn has shown that there is plenty of value in drafting or trading for experienced, big defenders who are capable of locking down an opponent. Our resources in my opinion would be better spent on continuing to inject pace into the midfield and forward line, or finding a genuine offensive weapon capable of stretching an opposition's defence and providing a mobile third target (i.e. Gunston).

Of the players who are available, M McGovern would fit the bill in relation to the forwards, Billings/Lonie for the mid/forward combination, and Shiel for the pure midfielder

 

[BEEG]

No to Weideman.

Make that a double ‘no’

Triple

Why do you think Weidemen is a good target?

Watched him live tonight 3rd year player and just all class, doesn't matter now anyway we are no chance of getting him.

Melbourne should look to trade Hogan to Freo/West Coast they don't need him with McDonald and Weiderman.

 

[Matt_352]

Watched him live tonight 3rd year player and just all class, doesn't matter now anyway we are no chance of getting him.

Melbourne should look to trade Hogan to Freo/West Coast they don't need him with McDonald and Weiderman.

Yep I got that wrong. Kid can play.

 

[Roverjg]

Yep I got that wrong. Kid can play.

Ditto....