List Mgmt. The 2019 Trade and Free Agency Thread

[Gysberts2Bate]

What pick would you rate him on an open market (ie. not constrained by whatever picks Hawthorn may have)?

Honestly I don’t think 10 is that far off the mark. Frosty is drastically underrated bc of commentators pointing out brainfades and skill errors (which he actually doesn’t make that many of anymore) but his skill set combo is almost unique across the comp. Best 22 KPD who’s done numerous jobs on the league’s best forwards and can break lines. How many of those do you find in the first round of the draft, even if they concede a few goals from turnovers?

 

[schmuttt]

Honestly I don’t think 10 is that far off the mark. Frosty is drastically underrated bc of commentators pointing out brainfades and skill errors (which he actually doesn’t make that many of anymore) but his skill set combo is almost unique across the comp. Best 22 KPD who’s done numerous jobs on the league’s best forwards and can break lines. How many of those do you find in the first round of the draft, even if they concede a few goals from turnovers?

10 for frost fmd I hope the hawks are that dumb

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

10 for frost fmd I hope the hawks are that dumb

Where would you have him then? With the number of hacks taken around pick 10 in the last 5 years I’d much rather keep frost

 

[dee_mac]

I reckon Frost is worth somewhere between 25 - 35 on the market. But he's value to us is greater than that so we'd want more to let him go. How many teams would give up a first rounder for him?

 

[harry000]

I reckon Frost is worth somewhere between 25 - 35 on the market. But he's value to us is greater than that so we'd want more to let him go. How many teams would give up a first rounder for him?

I'd wan't something top 20. Anyone can tell me that's overs and my response is, if that's overs we will keep him, bye bye

 

[jhong]

Unless he is asking for more than we can afford , why the * would we trade out a bloke that has pace ,something most on here have said we need more of .
If they want him that badly they can cough up pick 10 or stuff them .

 

[cougar000]

I reckon Frost is worth somewhere between 25 - 35 on the market. But he's value to us is greater than that so we'd want more to let him go. How many teams would give up a first rounder for him?

Hawthorn has 28 that would be about right. Then 28 for Langdon? Freo would want 20 no doubt. Could go 20 and 28 for Langdon and 24?

 

[schmuttt]

Where would you have him then? With the number of hacks taken around pick 10 in the last 5 years I’d much rather keep frost

Late 2nd

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

I’d hope we’re asking for 10 with 38 going back. Hawthorn are constantly paying overs to get the players they target anyway.

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Late 2nd

Christ - if there are defenders better than Frost in the late second round this year we should just delist him and let him walk for free IMO

 

[Demon 16]

Given OMacs regression and the injury risk with Lever/May, I would be extremely hesitant to let Frost go for anything that isnt overs.

His market value is probably around pick 28-32, but I wouldn't want us to take the risk unless we were getting pick 16-19.

 

[ponsdale]

With Petty coming along, and (potentially) Tomlinson joining, Frost may be nervous of his place in the team.

I feel somewhere around 25-30 would be about right.

Don't get me wrong, I love the crazy bloke, but in terms of consistency and predictability, which is what you need from a defence....

 

[TheCount]

With Petty coming along, and (potentially) Tomlinson joining, Frost may be nervous of his place in the team.

I feel somewhere around 25-30 would be about right.

Don't get me wrong, I love the crazy bloke, but in terms of consistency and predictability, which is what you need from a defence....

But Petty is coming along as a forward ... he was pretty average as a defender. While the apparent plan for Tomlinson is on the wing.

It could just be his management giving us a bit of a kick along to get an offer on the table.

 

[blitznu]

But Petty is coming along as a forward ... he was pretty average as a defender. While the apparent plan for Tomlinson is on the wing.

It could just be his management giving us a bit of a kick along to get an offer on the table.

Yes but then we need to find spots for Jetta, Lever and Fatty hopefully all fit then Hore, Salem and that bald headed campaigner should get a game down back. He is hoping for injuries to get a game or that we go for him over Hore and using Lever as he should be. Where as the hawks could give him 22 games no worries and have an actual ******* system. Any player would be mad not to leave for the same money we pay them

 

[blitznu]

If we get pick 10 for Frost in a straight swap ill do a Topkent FMD

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

But Petty is coming along as a forward ... he was pretty average as a defender. While the apparent plan for Tomlinson is on the wing.

It could just be his management giving us a bit of a kick along to get an offer on the table.

Yeah I hope Frosty is just driving his price up etc

 

[TheCount]

Yes but then we need to find spots for Jetta, Lever and Fatty hopefully all fit then Hore, Salem and that bald headed campaigner should get a game down back. He is hoping for injuries to get a game or that we go for him over Hore and using Lever as he should be. Where as the hawks could give him 22 games no worries and have an actual ******* system. Any player would be mad not to leave for the same money we pay them

B: Jetta - Frost - Lever
HB: Hibberd - May - Hore
Is my ideal back 6

Salem can be used delivering the ball inside 50 where we desperately need him, and I thought Jones looked best playing as a forward anyway, assuming he gets a game at all.

 

[pjfairbairn]

I love Frosty... but I would consider trading him for Isaac Smith/Conor Glass and a pick upgrade

 

[Demon bhoy]

If we get pick 10 for Frost in a straight swap ill do a Topkent FMD

Same bloke, if the club could turn a skunk like Frost into pick 10 it would be the greatest trade steal of all time, s**t if we got 28 the club is still sticking it to them

 

[blitznu]

B: Jetta - Frost - Lever
HB: Hibberd - May - Hore
Is my ideal back 6

Salem can be used delivering the ball inside 50 where we desperately need him, and I thought Jones looked best playing as a forward anyway, assuming he gets a game at all.

Salem brings his own treadmill out on field though bloke is ******* slow id want him up the ground if we had quicker players around him but hes a liability with no 2 way runners around him. I forgot Pig probably cause he did * all this year. Yeah id have the same back 6 but if Hibberd doesnt drop atleast 5 kegs the end will come quickly for him. Im just tryna be in Frosts shoes didnt get a game for most of 18 only played this year cause of injuries. If i could go to hawks on same money i wouldnt think twice * this club

 

[PerfectFooty]

I must admit i love watching Crazy Frost ball. But to be very honest, if he goes he goes, i won't be to upset over it

 

[stabler]

* me if we trade frostball im legit done with this club

 

[harry000]

Pick 28 and Isaac Smith for Frost wouldn't be too bad.

 

[harry000]

Whats so funny eldorado ??

 

[Daemon]

Every time there's been a dull moment today I've pulled out my phone to look at this note:

C: Tomlinson Petracca/Brayshaw Langdon
R: Gawn Oliver Harmes

Has brightened things up considerably.

Interesting how no one has Viney in the midfield in all of these discussions...