Recommitted Tim Kelly [requested a trade to West Coast]

[Moo]

Zero chance Fremantle give up any pick in the top 10. Having 2 picks in there once we get 6 is vital and trading one away would be silly.

If you look at the talent spread and especially the number of WA boys in the 10-20 range ....it'd be unlikely but not zero.

Would have to be a pretty tempting, however, I'd rather Freo profit from this in some way.

 

[MadMundy]

If you look at the talent spread and especially the number of WA boys in the 10-20 range ....it'd be unlikely but not zero.

Would have to be a pretty tempting, however, I'd rather Freo profit from this in some way.

Yeah fair point mate. As long as we benefit and get the best picks of the WA bunch I'll be happy.

 

[Suma Magic]

Taylor can we get the thread name changed to reflect his request?

“Tim Kelly has today formally requested a trade to the West Coast Eagles” - statement from his manager.

 

[Wojcinski]

14+24+2020 1st is more, not less

Wells is a w***er

Imagine having no reading or comprehension skills

 

[Two Planks]

Why would you give up 3 top 20 picks for Kelly?

Why would you give up pick 9 for Papley

 

[Two Planks]

Handbaggers Franchise fans carried on deluxe about family values to the same hymn book where it came to Dangerfield and Ablett.
They were like Deep South American Republican Politicians.
If they now let a young Indigenous Family with kids with disabilities go to WCE without causing any drama and for a good deal for WCE then they are justified in their assertions that they are better than the rest of us.

If they don’t then they justify what we already think about them and that we were right all along.

I’m just happy to watch.

Now you play the race card.

You wouldn't be a tree hugging lefty by any chance.

Will you keep the name Suns when you move to Tassie

 

[Moo]

Taylor can we get the thread name changed to reflect his request?

“Tim Kelly has today formally requested a trade to the West Coast Eagles” - statement from his manager.

Can we also add Geelong prefers Fremantle

 

[Happy Mastenator]

Geez these replies get dumber and dumber. Trelor played injured a heap at GWS. Thats according to Adam Trelor who's said that in an interview. You reallze one of those firsts was a guaranteed Pick 7 not Pick 14 like West Coasts first. Considering Collingwood werent likely to be contending for a premiership the year after the trade like West Coast should be in 2020 the future first also had less value than a West Coast future first. FFS the Trelor trade is WAY above what West Coast fans want for Kelly and its not even close to being close. Ed Langdon averaged 25 possessions in 2019. Means nothing if you cant use the ball well like Ed cant and like Trelor has struggled with at times. Trelor never had a year where he was considered in the top ten by coaches, players and umpires, let alone top 5 like Kelly was in 2019.

Treloar came second in GWS best and fairest in the year he left at age 22. He was fourth the year before and Fifth the season before that.

Don’t rewrite history to pretend Treloar wasn’t a gun, while being much younger than Kelly.

 

[Herne Hill Hammer]

Sure..

The Herald Sun reported earlier on Wednesday that the Giants knocked back West Coast’s proposed pick swap, meaning the Eagles couldn’t get their hands on the Giants’ No. 9, which they received from Essendon for losing Dylan Shiel.

So that left 9 other clubs with a top 10 pick?

Did it say what the WCE offered up in exchange for pick 9?

 

[Moo]

So that left 9 other clubs with a top 10 pick?

Did it say what the WCE offered up in exchange for pick 9?

To be fair they'd have thought you would have blinked.

However let's not remember they didn't blink either.

Fascinating to watch this play out, genuinely hope he and his family get home.

 

[Herne Hill Hammer]

To be fair they'd have thought you would have blinked.

However let's not remember they didn't blink either.

Fascinating to watch this play out, genuinely hope he and his family get home.

In the 45 years I've been following the Cats, it's the first time they haven't blinked, we've always been a soft touch.

I don't mind the club digging their heels in for once.

 

[Suma Magic]

Thanks Taylor

 

[DanWA]

Imagine having no reading or comprehension skills

The fine people of Corio still get by

Will Geelong be using 14 to get Jack Steven? St Kilda could then use that for Brad Hill

 

[Two Planks]

Can we change the thread title to Tim Kelly - requests a trade to West Coast and Geelong have demanded 4 1st rounders and Dusty.

 

[marty36]

The fine people of Corio still get by

Will Geelong be using 14 to get Jack Steven? St Kilda could then use that for Brad Hill

What realistic currency does West Coast have, forget the BS of trading picks in, what do they have available as it stands now

 

[DanWA]

What realistic currency does West Coast have, forget the BS of trading picks in, what do they have available as it stands now

14, 24 & 33

 

[DanWA]

Can we change the thread title to Tim Kelly - requests a trade to West Coast and Geelong have demanded 4 1st rounders and Dusty.

That was Chris Scott's demand

Unsure if he was crying at the time

 

[Two Planks]

That was Chris Scott's demand

Unsure if he was crying at the time

Fair chance

 

[Two Planks]

14, 24 & 33

Plus future picks and players.

 

[catman2006]

That was Chris Scott's demand

Unsure if he was crying at the time

Not as much as someone who put TK as their Avatar already hahaha

 

[Suma Magic]

That was Chris Scott's demand

Unsure if he was crying at the time

Tears in his eyes, tongue in his cheek.

 

[Two Planks]

So Daniher is worth picks 5 and 9 and has been injured for 2 years and had ongoing groin issues.

Papley is worth pick 9.

But Tim Kelly is worth picks 14 and 24.

FFS.

 

[numbat06]

14+33 for Kelly seems fair

 

[marty36]

Plus future picks and players.

Cant trade players if they don't want to leave, so that really cant be considered

With that, the very best Geelong could hope for is pick 14 and next years first which on predictions I would have that at around 16

Would that get the deal done, considering that is the very best they have

 

[Pure_Ownage]

So St Kilda, How would you feel about trading Pick 6, Blake Acres and your 2020 second round pick for 14, 33 and our 2020 first round pick? Why west coast Blake is feeling like he could do with more opportunity and that draft seems suitable to all parties involved.

Now Mr Wells. We have two options for you, both of which you only get to hear if you stfu.
1. We see you on draft night when we draft Tim Kelly for pick 6
2. We'll give you pick 6 and 24 for Kelly and your first round pick and this is all conditional on you not being campaigners and trading your nominal second round pick to St Kilda for Jack Steven.

West Coast pay 2 first rounders, one of which is a top 6 pick, get Acres, Kelly, 17 and a 2020 second round pick.
St Kilda get pick 14, a 2020 first round pick, pick 33, pick 36 and lose pick acres, steven and pick 6.
Geelong Lose Kelly, their first round pick, their second round pick and get Steven, 6 and 24.

West Coast do well out of the scenario, St Kilda do well out of the Scenario and Geelong pay their dues for Steven get pick 6 and 24 for this years draft. Maybe I'm being too kind to Geelong.

Saints and West coast make out like bandits.

The minute st kilda trade 6 the hill deal is off. Honestly couldnt think of aless workable trade proposal if i tried.