List Mgmt. Trade/Draft/Targets Part II

[Meteoric Rise]

Another dumb decision, average player at senior level

I don’t mind Aish but don’t rate him top class. Definitely an AFL footballer, so it all depends what you pay for him at the trade table and also contract wise. I would rate him around pick 20 and $350-400k pa. I have a feeling Freo will pay more for him on both counts.

 

[Mr Magic]

I don’t mind Aish but don’t rate him top class. Definitely an AFL footballer, so it all depends what you pay for him at the trade table and also contract wise. I would rate him around pick 20 and $350-400k pa. I have a feeling Freo will pay more for him on both counts.

pick 20 and 350-400k does not compute with Ellis

 

[Phar Ace]

pick 20 and 350-400k does not compute with Ellis

It's not meant to, you are comparing value to compensation

 

[Mr Magic]

Think they cooled on freo

I agree, Aish to Freo is turning the club into a tip.


Few players there would have to consider start exiting apart from Hill in the next few years.


Talk about junk time when people are mentioning Rupert Wills

It always amazing me the ways Collingwood try to attempt to dump their garbage

 

[Mr Magic]

It's not meant to, you are comparing value to compensation

Do do you think a mature player 350-400K is worth pick 20 in a normal draft??

 

[Phar Ace]

How many games has Danispud played in the last 2 years, now he is the world greatest forward?

Only at Essendon can you get delusion levels this HIGH, must be the Dank Kool-aid they have in the back refrigerator!

Just five in each of 2018 and 2019, and they are baulking at Sam Reid as a bit fragile. Geez Essendon live on another planet for most of the week and then visit and pretend to know this world.

 

[matt_y106]

Not sure it has been mentioned, but Ollie Wines has asked if a trade could be facilitated to the blues. Is this something we could get in on?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[hyperfuzz]

Do do you think a mature player 350-400K is worth pick 20 in a normal draft??

do you think we could have traded pick 3 for tom lynch

 

[Phar Ace]

Do do you think a mature player 350-400K is worth pick 20 in a normal draft??

I didn't say that, you did. I'm saying you don't compare what someone is worth in the trade hemisphere to the Free Agency compensation guidelines. I'm not saying it's right, but it is what it is. To base an argument on the two systems is stupid, fun to watch, but stupid all the same.

 

[SplintWhisky]

Not sure it has been mentioned, but Ollie Wines has asked if a trade could be facilitated to the blues. Is this something we could get in on?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

That has to be a joke

 

[Mr Magic]

do you think we could have traded pick 3 for tom lynch

Thats not the game????

Value, compo goes to the club losing the player as it should!!!

A club receiving a player vis FA pays through the salary and age of the player they obtain and the risk he does not keep getting it going

 

[Phar Ace]

Not sure it has been mentioned, but Ollie Wines has asked if a trade could be facilitated to the blues. Is this something we could get in on?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

We should, he likes the Tiges. Though he is having discipline issues I believe, it's how he rolls outside of footy. Good culture might be good for him.

 

[tony__montana]

Not sure it has been mentioned, but Ollie Wines has asked if a trade could be facilitated to the blues. Is this something we could get in on?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Isn’t he rumoured to be on 850k?

 

[NZ_Tiger]

We’d need port to pay some of Ollie’s wage. Ollie would also have to accept that the Port portion of his salary would be paid late and be light on.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Mr Magic]

Just listening to trade radio, saying Menadue leaving for not much, Barret reply, "yeah", similar to Butler, then talks up the greatness of Aish!!!

Trade radio sounds more like a propaganda outlet for Collingwood care of Barret!!!

 

[JR82]

Overall the trade period has been dead boring let's be honest, from our point of view it is fantastic seeing how desperate the other Clubs are, i don't miss waiting to see which C grade player we'll get to be the messiah or "Doozy" as other Clubs are doing atm. Some rather average players have become Superstars over the last week or so it seems...

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Do do you think a mature player 350-400K is worth pick 20 in a normal draft??

For a 23 year old yes(Aish is 23, will be 24 at the start of next season.) Say the same contract is given to a 26yo, he might only be worth a pick in the low 30’s. So I guess they are really recruiting a 24yo and I might downgrade him a few spots for that, worth about pick 23. I suspect his contract offer might be at least $450k though and Freo might cough up pick 18 or equivalent value for him.

 

[tiger_tough]

I don’t mind Aish but don’t rate him top class. Definitely an AFL footballer, so it all depends what you pay for him at the trade table and also contract wise. I would rate him around pick 20 and $350-400k pa. I have a feeling Freo will pay more for him on both counts.

Pick 20? In the rookie draft maybe

 

[docko911]

Not sure how on Earth we could pay him but I’d throw our first this year and next year and a bag of chips for Wines.

 

[Mr Magic]

For a 23 year old yes(Aish is 23, will be 24 at the start of next season.) Say the same contract is given to a 26yo, he might only be worth a pick in the low 30’s. So I guess they are really recruiting a 24yo and I might downgrade him a few spots for that, worth about pick 23. I suspect his contract offer might be at least $450k though and Freo might cough up pick 18 or equivalent value for him.

Pick 20 for a fringe role player that is still unproven?

I guess I might be biased it I think theres not much difference between Menadue and Dish so I am not really rating Aish a 350-400K player

 

[tigs2010]

People think our team are full of A-Graders here and we can't entertain any players who play a role from other clubs because they're "s**t"

Fair call when you're 89 points better than 2nd place

 

[Michaels]

feels like St Kilda are really trying to force success and wins by overpaying a heap of players to come to the club.

they want to keep the masses happy, not sure how it will pan out for them though.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Pick 20 for a fringe role player that is still unproven?

In my opinion Aish is a genuine AFL level footballer, reads the play well, is a good ball user and good runner. He also offers some versatility. Collingwood is a strong club and he sat comfortably in their best 22 when fit over the last couple of seasons.

 

[Mr Magic]

feels like St Kilda are really trying to force success and wins by overpaying a heap of players to come to the club.

they want to keep the masses happy, not sure how it will pan out for them though.

Already have to wait another 3 years at least for the other King...

 

[Mr Magic]

Maybe RFC get involved in GWS Hawks Patton trade?

RFC get pick 11, GWS get pick 40 or similar Hawks get picks 38 and 41 with another pick to balance it out