Opinion The 'Carlton related stuff that doesn't need it's own thread' thread Part 2

[ITCHY EYEBALLS]

Got into Williams and Docherty re poor defensive efforts. Showed vision and more or less criticised Teague's defensive game plan. I can't see him as an applicant after what he said. Also, Sam McClure reckons we've approached Chris Newman as an assistant.

I see the opposite. I think he’s jump at the chance.

 

[Burgers45]

I see the opposite. I think he’s jump at the chance.

He did a video review with Lloyd and was scathing of the lack of effort by our players. Didn't know whether it was the game plan itself, or the players not understanding it or not wanting to follow it, etc. Called it individual defence as opposed to team defence. Sounded like he knew what he was taking about, and if he gets the job would probably fix our defence up. He would weed out some of our softer/unskilled players who would have to be replaced with harder skillful players, and may put us back about 2 to 3 years.

 

[JustaBattler]

Got into Williams and Docherty re poor defensive efforts. Showed vision and more or less criticised Teague's defensive game plan. I can't see him as an applicant after what he said. Also, Sam McClure reckons we've approached Chris Newman as an assistant.

He was 100% spot on in everything he said and I doubt that his comments are news to Teague or his fellow band of merry men. It is awful watching the ease by which Carlton allows uncontested marks all over the park from every opposition it plays against - just awful coaching.

Regarding player selection or selection integrity he started hsi response by conveying a lesson he learned the hard wau in Sydney and that was choosing favourites who aren't performing - he suggested it is failed leadership and sends a poor message to the whole list regarding accountability for on field performance.

Nothinhg Lyon said hasn't be said on here by total amatuers.

 

[Blue Bloods]

Good on Brown for saying it as it is, extremely refreshing and what Zac needed to hear 10/10.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

Agreed at the time. He said they left 100 pieces of footage on the cutting room floor of a lazy Williams. That is alarming.

Footy Classified just said they went through the game and found all that footage and came up with the exact same footage The Couch used. So where is this 100 piece of footage and believe me they would have show it, just imedia BS. And can’t believe I fell for it and Brown one of my favourites said it.

Not saying Williams has played well the opposite in fact. But the couching panel will know and if he has in fact multiple footage of lazy play he will be dropped or at the least taken to task.

 

[SkyhorseTamer]

Same old excuses....

What excuse? Your hard on for hating SPS is one of the most embarrassing things I've seen from any supporter. Ever. It's also hilarious that my comments on him are somehow a reflection of SPS and making excuses like that somehow impacts him. Get a grip, look at the stats and use your noggin.

 

[BlueTang]

Agreed at the time. He said they left 100 pieces of footage on the cutting room floor of a lazy Williams. That is alarming.

Footy Classified just said they went through the game and found all that footage and came up with the exact same footage The Couch used. So where is this 100 piece of footage and believe me they would have show it, just imedia BS. And can’t believe I fell for it and Brown one of my favourites said it.

Not saying Williams has played well the opposite in fact. But the couching panel will know and if he has in fact multiple footage of lazy play he will be dropped or at the least taken to task.

Jonathan Brown was referring to the season for Williams ‘100 pieces’. The crux of it all was Williams took the big money, with that comes expectations on effort and fitness; both areas he has been underwhelming in.

The spray was wholly justified, not sure why posters are trying to pull apart the minor details. Maybe it's the rocket that pushes him back into form? I hope it is.

 

[Madblue]

What excuse? Your hard on for hating SPS is one of the most embarrassing things I've seen from any supporter. Ever. It's also hilarious that my comments on him are somehow a reflection of SPS and making excuses like that somehow impacts him. Get a grip, look at the stats and use your noggin.

The blind faith that you and a few others have in SPS is equally embarrassing. The guy hasn't played AFL for six weeks for many reasons and yet you seem to know better. If or when he is back in and warrants staying in the team then I will support him.

 

[Del9Sep24]

Ross Lyon.. why not

 

[Stamos]

The blind faith that you and a few others have in SPS is equally embarrassing. The guy hasn't played AFL for six weeks for many reasons and yet you seem to know better. If or when he is back in and warrants staying in the team then I will support him.

LOL. You think selection integrity is a strong trait of our current match committee?

 

[Madblue]

LOL. You think selection integrity is a strong trait of our current match committee?

But yours is ?

 

[Stamos]

But yours is ?

Yes

 

[Madblue]

Yes

I admire your blind faith but in reality you have NFI. Thank God you have nothing to do with our club

 

[Stamos]

I admire your blind faith but in reality you have NFI. Thank God you have nothing to do with our club

You reckon playing a mummified Martin is doing us any good?

 

[Arr0w]

You reckon playing a mummified Martin is doing us any good?

No, it's not, but that doesn't mean other players don't have flaws in their game

 

[Stamos]

No, it's not, but that doesn't mean other players don't have flaws in their game

So we should be going with the least bad choice then right?
Which we haven't been doing at all.

 

[95blues]

Gotta love some of those reserves reports.

Willo - Needs to be more proactive in the gap he gives his man (yikes)

Cotts - Needs to get forward more, is to biased towards getting back and defending

 

[Arr0w]

So we should be going with the least bad choice then right?
Which we haven't been doing at all.

We should be picking the best side per position, who are fit, committed intent, with a team first mentality

Then let it evolve from that point

 

[Stamos]

We should be picking the best side per position, who are fit, committed intent, with a team first mentality

Then let it evolve from that point

That's my point.
The mad one has an opposite view.

 

[Madblue]

So we should be going with the least bad choice then right?
Which we haven't been doing at all.

In your opinion

 

[Madblue]

We should be picking the best side per position, who are fit, committed intent, with a team first mentality

Then let it evolve from that point

Couldn't agree more hence why SPS is currently not in the team !

 

[Madblue]

That's my point.
The mad one has an opposite view.

Actually you do, you continue to contradict yourself time and time again

 

[Madblue]

Couldn't agree more hence why SPS is currently not in the team !

I tell you what Stamos let's call a truce. I think most of what you post is rubbish and you clearly think the same of me. I think SPS isn't getting a game for obvious reasons as do the club but you think otherwise. You ignore me and I'll ignore you and we move on ?

 

[Arr0w]

Couldn't agree more hence why SPS is currently not in the team !

I think SPS ticks most of the boxes I mentioned, but still has work to do on improving his intent.

Based on what we know and see, I would have him in the side

 

[Blue__Balls]

Couldn't agree more hence why SPS is currently not in the team !

Could've sworn it was because he was getting played down back and asked to be dropped to the reserves to try and stake a claim for a midfield role....

But hey, you do you.

 

[Madblue]

Could've sworn it was because he was getting played down back and asked to be dropped to the reserves to try and stake a claim for a midfield role....

But hey, you do you.

And you do you especially when your info is completely wrong