I thought Rachelle > JHF. Did I miss something ?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
That would be some forward line too.If west Coast played their cards right, they should be looking at both Georgiades AND McDonald from Sydney over the next few seasons via hard nosed trading when these guys next come out of contract and in the meantime, use their high draft picks to restock their midfield and then look to bring in some key defenders via later picks / rookie draft / state leagues. Shuestar13
You’d be mad not to enquire about getting him over, the cost would be crazy though.
They would ask for Rachele and our 1st.You’d be mad not to enquire about getting him over, the cost would be crazy though.
What did we offer for the draft pick? Pick 4 and two future firsts (with their second coming back I think)From the Roos board
Right o, I’ve been sitting on this for a couple of weeks. And sorry to be the bearer of bad news. I was hoping we would show him a reason to stay but….
He wants to come back to SA, as soon as possible. I’d be very surprised if he signs on.
Edit: this begs the question if true, what would we give up to try and get him if we were a chance of landing him?
I'm not sure you give up more than two firsts for a player openly wanting to leave a club. Power goes back into the player.What did we offer for the draft pick? Pick 4 and two future firsts (with their second coming back I think)
You’d do the same again and any of McAsey, Fog, Sholl. In fact apart from Rachele or Thilthorpe, they can have anyone.
It would be more what would NM want for him.From the Roos board
Right o, I’ve been sitting on this for a couple of weeks. And sorry to be the bearer of bad news. I was hoping we would show him a reason to stay but….
He wants to come back to SA, as soon as possible. I’d be very surprised if he signs on.
Edit: this begs the question if true, what would we give up to try and get him if we were a chance of landing him?
Money talks. Reckon we could offer him a bigger contract.What makes anyone think he’ll choose the AFC? Very strong ties to the PAPs. If offers are similar, no way he’ll choose Crows.
On this trade, Boyd cost the Dogs a massive contract over multiple years for a player who hasn't done anything."A blockbuster deal in which Western Bulldogs captain Ryan Griffen would be traded for Greater Western Sydney's Tom Boyd has been done. Under the deal, which was finalised this afternoon, Griffen and the Dogs' first pick, No.6, goes to the Giants in return for Boyd."
Rory Sloane plus our first rounder? Start the car.
Absolutely agree money talks, but our offer would have to be substantially more. I don’t know how we’re positioned with available money and cap space.Money talks. Reckon we could offer him a bigger contract.
On this trade, Boyd cost the Dogs a massive contract over multiple years for a player who hasn't done anything.
Would hope the crows do the same for JHF.
Agreed. His output over the contract was rubbish, but the idea is valid. Your clubs biggest hole on field, available elite talent, salary cap space.. you do it every timeYep and Boyd won the Dogs a flag and I reckon every single team would do the same trade knowing how the rest of Boyd's career panned out
Don't take this as an insult, but North Melbourne suck.Don’t take this as an insult, but this reminds me of the Josh Kelly and David Swallow threads on our board. It just won’t happen.
What like Tim Kelly or Cameron?I'm not sure you give up more than two firsts for a player openly wanting to leave a club. Power goes back into the player.
Two firsts and a player who is borderline 22 or developing would be fair.
Like you say Fog or McAsey.
Would take both. Powell is better than Berry and Hately in my view.Just skimming the jhf thread on the North board, someone said Powell also isnt happy there. Could there be an exodus like at Brisbane years ago?
Don't take this as an insult, but North Melbourne suck.
Would take both. Powell is better than Berry and Hately in my view.
No current season stats available
I would give them Rachele for JHF and their firstThey would ask for Rachele and our 1st.