List Mgmt. 2025 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

[Kbroome]

How does Francis survive the delistings and Fox doesn't?

Im guessing they are waiting to see if they can bring in a serviceable KPD to get rid of him especially if Hamling is gonsky

 

[NinjaSwan]

Yeah I mean I know Carlton fans don't agree but 9 plus f1 (whatever draft they want) is more than reasonable. It's actually beyond fair. Lets not pretend he's Jeremy Cameron okay.

That'd be a terrible trade for Carlton, our pick 9 will end up 12 after compensation + Uwland match in what's considered a weak draft, and our f1 next year could easily end up 20 as you'd expect us to be top 4, would love Curnow but don't see how we get him.

 

[Donza]

Paton, Mitchell, Kirk fair calls.

Francis, Rampe to follow.

Good that Leidler survived, at least for now.

Rampe?

He's not going anywhere.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

That'd be a terrible trade for Carlton, our pick 9 will end up 12 after compensation + Uwland match in what's considered a weak draft, and our f1 next year could easily end up 20 as you'd expect us to be top 4, would love Curnow but don't see how we get him.

I agree, but there is nothing that will get 2 out of WCE unless it's one of the ones that some would call untouchable. I'll say this though and I know what people will say on here okay...but I would consider Blakey if it gets us Curnow, big if though

 

[JackHiscoxWasFast]

Only 4 players cut ? Are we kidding ourselves ? There has to be more to come.

We’ve taken to the list with pruning shears when what we need instead is a chainsaw. Maybe we really can’t get anyone to join us.

Come on Pav, swing the axe !

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Im guessing they are waiting to see if they can bring in a serviceable KPD to get rid of him especially if Hamling is gonsky

I'd rather have one less than have Francis anywhere near our side. Just take a chance on one late as a mature age defender.

 

[Wheresbuddy]

Only 4 players cut ? Are we kidding ourselves ? There has to be more to come.

We’ve taken to the list with pruning shears when what we need instead is a chainsaw. Maybe we really can’t get anyone to join us.

Come on Pav, swing the axe !

Might be losing a few established stars as part of any trades we might be looking at brokering?

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Only 4 players cut ? Are we kidding ourselves ? There has to be more to come.

We’ve taken to the list with pruning shears when what we need instead is a chainsaw. Maybe we really can’t get anyone to join us.

Come on Pav, swing the axe !

You can't delist the whole squad you know. Look I'd have gotten rid of Francis, Rampe is probably a wait, maybe Rampe to the rookie

 

[JackHiscoxWasFast]

Might be losing a few established stars as part of any trades we might be looking at brokering?

Can only hope.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

The only one I can see that may broker a pick 2 are Logan (and I'd be hesitant we are selling at the low end), Blakey (would he even want to go to Perth) or Chad and the latter one we spent a year trying to get him to agree to a deal, seems a little silly if we traded.

 

[Bloods86]

Rampe?

He's not going anywhere.

I think he should retire.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

I think he should retire.

He's one I hope we at least talk about delisting then re rookie, either him OR Fox

 

[Bloods86]

He's one I hope we at least talk about delisting then re rookie, either him OR Fox

I mean, based on the announcement, I think Fox is completely done as a Swan.

 

[Jeffers]

Not surprised about the changes so far. Sid was a goner, just lacks talent. Fox is a shame but an injury plagued year at his age is not
Good.

If we’re fair dinkum Rampe should be delisted
To and re rookied as a break in case of emergency, Francis gone and let Lloyd walk. That will be true change

Florent and McLean trade bait

 

[LukeParkerno1]

I mean, based on the announcement, I think Fox is completely done as a Swan.

I'm just happy we didn't keep Kirk for other reasons wasting a list spot there.

 

[Andyjh]

McDonald is very happy at the Swans and his value hasn't been lower.

Won't be part of the trade.

Now this is controversial, but if we are chasing Curnow, I can see Rowbottom possibly being part of a trade to bring him in.

First rounders 25 + 26 and Rowbottom - Out
Curnow + 2nd rounder 25 - In
(Other clubs would have to be involved).

F Off! Rowy?? Have you lost the plot?

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Not surprised about the changes so far. Sid was a goner, just lacks talent. Fox is a shame but an injury plagued year at his age is not
Good.

If we’re fair dinkum Rampe should be delisted
To and re rookied as a break in case of emergency, Francis gone and let Lloyd walk. That will be true change

Florent and McLean trade bait

I'm not the biggest McLean fan but I'd keep purely as depth

 

[LukeParkerno1]

F Off! Rowy?? Have you lost the plot?

You want to get Curnow one of these good players is going. Impossible to see how it gets done with selections only

 

[Bloods86]

You want to get Curnow one of these good players is going. Impossible to see how it gets done with selections only

Rowy doesn't strike me as the type who wants out. Would have to be another club involved anyway as the Blues wouldn't be after another inside mid.

 

[McGowan3]

Rowy doesn't strike me as the type who wants out. Would have to be another club involved anyway as the Blues wouldn't be after another inside mid.

No way he goes. We are soft enough at the moment. Terrible blue if we let go our toughest player.

 

[FreeAgent1]

There is some discussion here about “overs”.

No such phrase exists for Carlton. Three firsts would be their starting point.

Will ask for more than Cameron. If people aren’t ok with this then don’t propose anything just be against the trade.

 

[Cadsky]

McDonald is very happy at the Swans and his value hasn't been lower.

Won't be part of the trade.

Now this is controversial, but if we are chasing Curnow, I can see Rowbottom possibly being part of a trade to bring him in.

First rounders 25 + 26 and Rowbottom - Out
Curnow + 2nd rounder 25 - In
(Other clubs would have to be involved).

Ive been thinking Rowy could be on the chopping block for a while now and when he was moved forward more than only served to affirm it even more. I really wouldn't be surprised if we did move him on. Great defensively and id never question that. But doesn't get enough of the ball.

 

[Bonz]

F Off! Rowy?? Have you lost the plot?

Not necessarily saying I would do the trade, but it's going to take something like that to get the trade done.

Yes Curnow has had a few injuries and is 28, but his still one of if not the premier forward in the competition.

If we want to bring him in we are going to have to trade something of value and two firsts simply won't cut it.

 

[Bonz]

Ive been thinking Rowy could be on the chopping block for a while now and when he was moved forward more than only served to affirm it even more. I really wouldn't be surprised if we did move him on. Great defensively and id never question that. But doesn't get enough of the ball.

My exact thinking.

With Sheldrick getting more time and the possibility of Mills moving back to the midfield it's the one area of the ground we could maybe trade someone out.

 

[Kbroome]

Ive been thinking Rowy could be on the chopping block for a while now and when he was moved forward more than only served to affirm it even more. I really wouldn't be surprised if we did move him on. Great defensively and id never question that. But doesn't get enough of the ball.

Guess Tom Aitkens, Willem Drew, Jack Graham, Connor Nash, Alex Davies, Ned Long should all be moved on from their respective clubs because they play the Rowbottom role