Mega Thread 2013: Trade Hypotheticals

[Suma Magic]

Ash Smith - not sure if he will be keen to leave, but any guesses on his value if he does?

He polarises Eagles' fans, with many not thinking he's worth much.

Cheers for any responses, even if you reckon he's not worth a spot on your list.

And a general comment - instead of r3/4 pick etc, I think it's more useful to use numbers, such as pick 50-60 or 40-50 etc.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Yarran, Warnock + Pick 8??

Would be closer to the mark ... but then I think we may be overpaying lol

 

[Jell]

Yarran, Warnock + Pick 8??

Yarran won't go to GWS.

More like Yarran to WCE for their first pick.

Then our 1st pick, WCE 1st pick + Warnock to GWS for pick 1 and their 2nd round pick (19 or 20)

 

[Stylo]

I can't see WCE trading a top ten pick for Yarran. Much better off going to the draft.

Yarran would land you a late first at best IMO

 

[Sydswans0512]

I can't see WCE trading a top ten pick for Yarran. Much better off going to the draft.

Yarran would land you a late first at best IMO

Was thinking the same thing

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

I can't see WCE trading a top ten pick for Yarran. Much better off going to the draft.

Yarran would land you a late first at best IMO

I agree with this.

In saying that though, if all thats on offer is a pick which is late first round (say 19ish), I'd rather we kept Yarran and persisted with him.

We won't be able to land one of the premium talls in this draft with that pick (partly because there are none in this draft).

I'd back Mick to try and get the best of Yarran, because his ability showcases that he has the talent to be better than anyone that may be available at 19 - who knows, he may have an awesome 2014 and up his value in a draft where there are better (or more) decent KPP on offer.

The downside though is that he will be out of coming out of contract this time next year, so it would need to be a very calculated risk.

 

[HARKER]

Robinson, Warnock + Pick 8 to Gws

Pick 1 to Carlton

I'd do that but it looks just a little skinny unfortunately.

 

[footyfan000001]

Western Bulldogs give Pick 22 and Pick 40 to Carlton for Robert Warnock and Pick 45
(Exchange of 3rd Round Picks)

Western Bulldogs give Robert Warnock, Easton Wood and Pick 4 to GWS for Pick 1

WB
Get: Pick 1, Pick 45
Lose: Pick 4, Pick 22, Pick 40, Wood
Carl
Get: Pick 22, Pick 40
Lose: Warnock, Pick 45
GWS
Get: Warnock, Wood, Pick 4
Lose: Pick 1

Thoughts??

 

[HARKER]

Western Bulldogs give Pick 22 and Pick 40 to Carlton for Robert Warnock and Pick 45
(Exchange of 3rd Round Picks)

Western Bulldogs give Robert Warnock, Easton Wood and Pick 4 to GWS for Pick 1

WB
Get: Pick 1, Pick 45
Lose: Pick 4, Pick 22, Pick 40, Wood
Carl
Get: Pick 22, Pick 40
Lose: Warnock, Pick 45
GWS
Get: Warnock, Wood, Pick 4
Lose: Pick 1

Thoughts??

Pretty balanced doggie.

Seems to meet everyone's needs.

 

[Red Black and Blue]

Thoughts??

You're paying overs for Warnock and I don't think he'd be of much value to GWS.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Western Bulldogs give Pick 22 and Pick 40 to Carlton for Robert Warnock and Pick 45
(Exchange of 3rd Round Picks)

Western Bulldogs give Robert Warnock, Easton Wood and Pick 4 to GWS for Pick 1

WB
Get: Pick 1, Pick 45
Lose: Pick 4, Pick 22, Pick 40, Wood
Carl
Get: Pick 22, Pick 40
Lose: Warnock, Pick 45
GWS
Get: Warnock, Wood, Pick 4
Lose: Pick 1

Thoughts??

I would take that.

 

[footyfan000001]

Pretty balanced doggie.

Seems to meet everyone's needs.

Sometimes I wonder why I am not the list Manager at the Dogs

 

[Igloo]

We are paying way too much in that scenario. We'll want pick 1, but if we can't get it without selling the farm, we wont go for it.

 

[tigs2010]

We are paying way too much in that scenario. We'll want pick 1, but if we can't get it without selling the farm, we wont go for it.

It's giving away 3 picks and a player

 

[Sydswans0512]

We are paying way too much in that scenario. We'll want pick 1, but if we can't get it without selling the farm, we wont go for it.

I thought it was a fair trade. Selling the farm?????

 

[Igloo]

I thought it was a fair trade. Selling the farm?????

Warnock isn't worth a high 2nd round pick, especially not with downgrading our 3rd pick. Pick 45 isn't going to be much use in this draft, imo. So we're pretty much giving pick 4, 22 and Wood for pick 1. Far too much.

 

[Zach Package]

Ash Smith - not sure if he will be keen to leave, but any guesses on his value if he does?

He polarises Eagles' fans, with many not thinking he's worth much.

Cheers for any responses, even if you reckon he's not worth a spot on your list.

And a general comment - instead of r3/4 pick etc, I think it's more useful to use numbers, such as pick 50-60 or 40-50 etc.

4th rounder IMO, but I like him. Prone to brainfades, but he has caught my eye with his pace and long kicking, maybe it's the hair and the tatts that make him stand out.

I see him more as a winger than a defender though, his defensive skills aren't that developed, is that fair comment?

 

[Sydswans0512]

Warnock isn't worth a high 2nd round pick, especially not with downgrading our 3rd pick. Pick 45 isn't going to be much use in this draft, imo. So we're pretty much giving pick 4, 22 and Wood for pick 1. Far too much.

Good luck then

 

[Sydswans0512]

Sometimes I wonder why I am not the list Manager at the Dogs

Dogs are setup better than anyone to trade for pick one you can go a year without getting midfielders as you already have the quality there. Perfect timing to bring Boyd in

 

[slashin_velvet]

Western Bulldogs give Pick 22 and Pick 40 to Carlton for Robert Warnock and Pick 45
(Exchange of 3rd Round Picks)

Western Bulldogs give Robert Warnock, Easton Wood and Pick 4 to GWS for Pick 1

WB
Get: Pick 1, Pick 45
Lose: Pick 4, Pick 22, Pick 40, Wood
Carl
Get: Pick 22, Pick 40
Lose: Warnock, Pick 45
GWS
Get: Warnock, Wood, Pick 4
Lose: Pick 1

Thoughts??

Seems fair, albeit a bit unbalanced with the ins and outs (not the content, but the amount of player movements). GWS cant take on 3 additional players, they dont have the list space....and I cant see carlton participating in any trade that ensures Boyd goes somewhere else.

 

[Suma Magic]

4th rounder IMO, but I like him. Prone to brainfades, but he has caught my eye with his pace and long kicking, maybe it's the hair and the tatts that make him stand out.

I see him more as a winger than a defender though, his defensive skills aren't that developed, is that fair comment?

That's the perfect summary. He's ok as a spoiler in contests, but is useless in contested situations.

But come to think about it i think he's contracted so would need to be a pick we'd use. So basically better than our third round pick which would be around 45ish or else we'd just keep him.

 

[scooter600x]

I would take that.

Pick 22 and a small 3rd round upgrade for Warnock, I'm bloody certain you would!

 

[doggies ftw]

Ash Smith - not sure if he will be keen to leave, but any guesses on his value if he does?

He polarises Eagles' fans, with many not thinking he's worth much.

Cheers for any responses, even if you reckon he's not worth a spot on your list.

And a general comment - instead of r3/4 pick etc, I think it's more useful to use numbers, such as pick 50-60 or 40-50 etc.

Wouldn't be upset if we gave up our early 3rd rounder for him, reunite him with Koby

 

[raymagoo]

Crameri according to Essendon fans "looked disinterested" in the VFL on Saturday, has delayed contract talks and the Bulldogs have made a bigger offer with 1 extra year.

Reasonably solid addition to a "rumour" file at least

Talk from maryborough is big offers & he is gone. Not sure where

 

[raymagoo]

They were saying he has been offered 520k I'd try and sign him for 5 years @ 650k a year

Would be one of the first players I'd have a crack at for Carlton! Game breaker