2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[Daniels]

Need 2 defenders

Rance v Houli v Enright v Laird v Hodge v Smith

Laird and Hodge

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

Assuming Ellis Yolman is named, should I trade Ellis Yolman or Griffen to Sloane?

 

[Krujan]

Assuming Ellis Yolman is named, should I trade Ellis Yolman or Griffen to Sloane?

If CEY is named and is not the sub, I would trade Griff > Sloane. You will have enough time before lockout to make that call.

 

[Lums23]

If CEY is named and is not the sub, I would trade Griff > Sloane. You will have enough time before lockout to make that call.

I haven't been on as much this week as I've been sitting in a dark room rocking back and forthforth and sobbing over these byes, but is there anything more to this CEY getting dropped stuff than the fact that he got subbed in the last game so he might get dropped, or start sub?

 

[Lums23]

Dahlhaus vs Bont for my last fwd spot?

Dahlhaus died off towards the end of the year last year, while bont is about 100k cheaper and CD love him. However Dahlhaus obviously has the runs on the board so far

 

[PoopingHindi]

Dahlhaus vs Bont for my last fwd spot?

Dahlhaus died off towards the end of the year last year, while bont is about 100k cheaper and CD love him. However Dahlhaus obviously has the runs on the board so far

Dahl for me. gets plenty of it, tackles and kicks the odd goal.

Bont has been playing injured i think, hence the recent decline in form. also someone said he missed training on Tues and may not get up for this week (its in the injury thread somewhere)


i have both

 

[rocker_oz33]

Dahlhaus vs Bont for my last fwd spot?

Dahlhaus died off towards the end of the year last year, while bont is about 100k cheaper and CD love him. However Dahlhaus obviously has the runs on the board so far

I'm looking at Dollhouse and Edwards already have bonts.
Yeah Dollhouse fell away last year in the second half unsure why did he play forward more? Heard he as unhappy with the coach.
Dollhouse more seasoned rather have him.
Bonts being second year player bonts was going to fall at some point,hoping he can have a good second half to the season.
But still ? marks on hes fitness atm tho.
Roughy and Dev are also priced pretty well also.

 

[Lums23]

Dahl for me. gets plenty of it, tackles and kicks the odd goal.

Bont has been playing injured i think, hence the recent decline in form. also someone said he missed training on Tues and may not get up for this week (its in the injury thread somewhere)


i have both

I'm looking at Dollhouse and Edwards already have bonts.
Yeah Dollhouse fell away last year in the second half unsure why did he play forward more? Heard he as unhappy with the coach.
Dollhouse more seasoned rather have him.
Bonts being second year player bonts was going to fall at some point,hoping he can have a good second half to the season.
But still ? marks on hes fitness atm tho.
Roughy and Dev are also priced pretty well also.

Cheers guys. I was thinking Bonts may be able to run the season out better given he's had the extra weeks break but if he's still a bit sore I'm probably worth staying away

 

[TimC]

Wines or Cotchin?

 

[MightyMark]

Wines or Cotchin?

Wines

 

[Lums23]

Wines or Cotchin?

Wines


Dahlhaus and Hodge vs Deledio and Laird

 

[TimC]

Wines


Dahlhaus and Hodge vs Deledio and Laird

Cheers.

Dahlhaus and Hodge

 

[PAFC1996]

Roughead v Dahlhaus v Edwards v any other last weeks bye forward?
Currently have Gray, Martin, Swan, Franklin, and Bont.

 

[Amazing Bombers]

Roughead v Dahlhaus v Edwards v any other last weeks bye forward?
Currently have Gray, Martin, Swan, Franklin, and Bont.

Dahl

 

[Super Gusto]

Steph Martin and Laird or Blicvas and Hodge

Martin has the bonus of having already had the bye but I don;t know alot about Laird (scores have been good though)

 

[scaryness]

Steph Martin and Laird or Blicvas and Hodge

Martin has the bonus of having already had the bye but I don;t know alot about Laird (scores have been good though)

Martin and Laird, imo.

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Not so much a player x v player y question but...

Do I keep Oxley this week, even though it will give me a donut or

Trade him for Simpson?

 

[Kadog]

Dahlhaus vs Bont for my last fwd spot?

Bont

Wines or Cotchin?

Wines

Dahlhaus and Hodge vs Deledio and Laird

Dahl Hodge....just.

Roughead v Dahlhaus v Edwards v any other last weeks bye forward?
Currently have Gray, Martin, Swan, Franklin, and Bont.

Edwards. Deledio if you can afford him.

Steph Martin and Laird or Blicvas and Hodge

Stef Laird

Not so much a player x v player y question but...

Do I keep Oxley this week, even though it will give me a donut or

Trade him for Simpson?

Hold. Ox B/E 5 still has some moo in him whilst giving you great scores.

 

[crownie]

Cotchin or B.Ellis?

 

[Flandersss]

Cotchin or B.Ellis?

B.Ellis

 

[keithrichards]

Of the rookies, anyone want to have a go at ranking the JS of:

Hamling
Steele
Neale-Bullen
Stretch

There's a good chance I might pick up 2 or 3...

 

[pincrusher]

Of the rookies, anyone want to have a go at ranking the JS of:

Hamling- Shaky
Steele- extremely shaky
Neale-Bullen- ridiculously shaky
Stretch- Outrageously shaky

There's a good chance I might pick up 2 or 3...

 

[keithrichards]

Haha. Thanks.

 

[pincrusher]

Haha. Thanks.

On the serious side, it's hard to judge Steele as he hasn't had a game yet. ANB and Stretch will get games ,but will they get vested and will they play regularly? Hard to say.

I'll be getting Hamling today as he's on the bubble and the dogs have a good draw coming up, but I'm still not sold on his ability to stay in the team. However, he is 22yo and has a more mature body than the others. Steele would need to tear it up in his first two games for me to look at getting him. GWS could field a whole team of midfielders with the talent they have on their list.

 

[keithrichards]

On the serious side, it's hard to judge Steele as he hasn't had a game yet. ANB and Stretch will get games ,but will they get vested and will they play regularly? Hard to say.

I'll be getting Hamling today as he's on the bubble and the dogs have a good draw coming up, but I'm still not sold on his ability to stay in the team. However, he is 22yo and has a more mature body than the others. Steele would need to tear it up in his first two games for me to look at getting him. GWS could field a whole team of midfielders with the talent they have on their list.

I actually decided the same. Brown>Hamling locked in.

I'm going to wait a week on Steele. If my league game tomorrow is close, I may get one of the Dees players in, just in case it's the difference.