2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[DV2000]

Liam picken or Rory Laird??

 

[anditsadraw69]

i have both griffen and selwood
who should I keep? need to flick one of them off this week

 

[anditsadraw69]

Liam picken or Rory Laird??

can't go wrong
I'd go Picken as he seems to play more midfield, but Laird is a great young player, marks the ball well

 

[JuddgementDay]

planning on getting sloane...
who to gey rid off first jelwood or griffen
had enough of both players this year

 

[Judd_Magic]

planning on getting sloane...
who to gey rid off first jelwood or griffen
had enough of both players this year

Griff.

 

[Lums23]

Just wondering why not?

I'm new to this so don't know but. ..

Experienced player, coming back so rested and seems to scope well regardless of whether saints win or not.

Not many players can average 120 for a year, especially ones at his age. Plus he has a bit of an injury history

 

[JuddgementDay]

Griff.

Thanks JM,
I was a bit lazy on my phone. The real story is I've got a bit of money issue really.
I've only got $27K in the bank.

So the equation is really:
A. Out Griffen & Kmac In Sloane & Lambert
OR
B. Out Jelwood & Kmac In Sloane & Smith
OR
C. Out Jelwood In Sloane
and save the 2nd trade for next week, e.g. Steele is better than Lambert etc

So what do you think A , B or C?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Thanks JM,
I was a bit lazy on my phone. The real story is I've got a bit of money issue really.
I've only got $27K in the bank.

So the equation is really:
A. Out Griffen & Kmac In Sloane & Lambert
OR
B. Out Jelwood & Kmac In Sloane & Smith
OR
C. Out Jelwood In Sloane
and save the 2nd trade for next week, e.g. Steele is better than Lambert etc

So what do you think A , B or C?

Option A

Can still get Steele after next week too once he's played his second game.

 

[Kadog]

Thanks JM,
I was a bit lazy on my phone. The real story is I've got a bit of money issue really.
I've only got $27K in the bank.

So the equation is really:
A. Out Griffen & Kmac In Sloane & Lambert
OR
B. Out Jelwood & Kmac In Sloane & Smith
OR
C. Out Jelwood In Sloane
and save the 2nd trade for next week, e.g. Steele is better than Lambert etc

So what do you think A , B or C?

Option B for mine

 

[Krujan]

Current prices, averages and breakevens aside (those things are irrelevant to me as far as this question goes)

Who do you guys think will score more points from Rds13-23

Tom Mitchell or JPK ?

 

[juddola]

Current prices, averages and breakevens aside (those things are irrelevant to me as far as this question goes)

Who do you guys think will score more points from Rds13-23

Tom Mitchell or JPK ?

My gut feel is telling me JPK will come home strong, I think more and more opposition teams will focus on Mitchell and Parker which will give him some space.

 

[PoopingHindi]

My gut feel is telling me JPK will come home strong, I think more and more opposition teams will focus on Mitchell and Parker which will give him some space.

i cant see any team sending a player to Mitchell before JPK and I think Titch is stealing some of his points.

my gut feel is to go with Mitchell...even though im still doubtful if he can maintain form, fitness and even js.

 

[Kadog]

Current prices, averages and breakevens aside (those things are irrelevant to me as far as this question goes)

Who do you guys think will score more points from Rds13-23

Tom Mitchell or JPK ?

JPK

 

[Lums23]

Current prices, averages and breakevens aside (those things are irrelevant to me as far as this question goes)

Who do you guys think will score more points from Rds13-23

Tom Mitchell or JPK ?

I'm leaning towards Mitchell, but he never seems to go really big. JPK would be more likely to pump out two 140s and catch up. I reckon they'll be abouf the same

 

[keithrichards]

Anyone want to offer their thoughts on:

Dahlhaus vs Bontempelli?

$100k difference in price is appealing, anyone think they can average the same?

 

[SnappyHappy]

Anyone want to offer their thoughts on:

Dahlhaus vs Bontempelli?

$100k difference in price is appealing, anyone think they can average the same?

I think Dahl will average slightly more (105-110 vs 95-100), Bont more likely to miss games though as he's shown and being a younger player may get rested later or slow down in scoring. I'd go with Dahl

 

[Krujan]

I think Dahl will average slightly more (105-110 vs 95-100), Bont more likely to miss games though as he's shown and being a younger player may get rested later or slow down in scoring. I'd go with Dahl

Dahl slowed down big time last year, averaging 75ish from the last 6 games. Burnman!

 

[SnappyHappy]

Dahl slowed down big time last year averaged like 75 from the last 6 games. Burnman!

Yeah another preseason & experience under his belt, playing more midfield so I'm not expecting that to happen again. Bont more likely to do that this year IMO

 

[Krujan]

Yeah another preseason & experience under his belt, playing more midfield so I'm not expecting that to happen again. Bont more likely to do that this year IMO

With all due respect, Dahl was in his 4th season last year and was playing plenty of time in the midfield when I traded him in. Probably doesn't have the tank to play in the guts for a whole season.

 

[CotchyPls]

Dahl slowed down big time last year, averaging 75ish from the last 6 games. Burnman!

This is my only worry, traded him in last week.

 

[Juddy88]

Hanners V JPK + 90k

 

[stevebbb]

Hanners V JPK + 90k

Hannah
JPK plays more forward when Swans vs trash teams and scores trash

 

[keithrichards]

Dahl slowed down big time last year, averaging 75ish from the last 6 games. Burnman!

In that case, any thoughts on best available fwd to take Mitch Clarks spot?

Current line up is:
Gray, Swan, Martin, Franklin, Mitchell, Clark (Krakour, Dale)

I can make 1 trade for a player less than $526k or 2 trades to get a player less than $640k

 

[SC fish]

Hanners V JPK + 90k

Hard to pass up JPK on his current price, but with a BE of 130 he could wait another week?

Have you considered Harvey?

 

[Juddy88]

Hard to pass up JPK on his current price, but with a BE of 130 he could wait another week?

Have you considered Harvey?

Maybe for a FWD spot, but don't think he'll cut out as a mid.