2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[Goats]

Armitage v Hannebery v Beams v Mundy v JPK

I'm leaning towards Beams but Armitage is enticing at his price plus with the extra 50k I can look at Burgoyne/Rance for Oxley/Saad.

The order you have them in is my preference. Just brought Armitage in myself fwiw.

 

[Lotch]

Pending subs who should I start?

Steele or Lonie

 

[dUkezz]

Steele imo

 

[Flandersss]

Pending subs who should I start?

Steele or Lonie

Lonie.

Biased.

 

[Lums23]

Pending subs who should I start?

Steele or Lonie

Steele

 

[Feerits Elf]

Take Oxley's 78, or roll the dice on Lever in Perth?

 

[NinjaSwan]

Take Oxley's 78, or roll the dice on Lever in Perth?

Take Oxley's 78.

 

[Feerits Elf]

Agreed, will do

 

[Judd_Magic]

Need a replacement for Wallis.

Whose the best pick out of these guys?

Picken (DPP Hodge to mids)
Steven
Heppell
Macrae
Wines
Sidebottom
S.Mitchell

Have $115,300 to play with.

Not sure if there's any better options.

 

[juddola]

Need a replacement for Wallis.

Whose the best pick out of these guys?

Picken (DPP Hodge to mids)
Steven
Heppell
Macrae
Wines
Sidebottom
S.Mitchell

Have $115,300 to play with.

Not sure if there's any better options.

Heppell

 

[Judd_Magic]

Heppell

What makes you say Heppell?

 

[juddola]

No Watson, consistent, POD, played most of the top teams, someone's gotta get the points at the bombers.

 

[brentman]

For a draft league - on my bench i have Hartlett, Ryder, Doc and K Stevens.

I am looking at dropping Hartlett for either Eski or Merrett. What are your thoughts?

There are a few decent mids available in free agency so if i get a couple injuries i can pick one of these guys up (Dal Santo, Wallis, Griggs and Cross). There are a fair few decent FWD's in free agency (Christensen, Merrett, Darling, Billings, Paparone.) Free agent defenders of note are (Eski, Macmillan, Dunn, Langdon, Williams)

 

[stevebbb]

Hodge vs Picken vs Rance vs McDonald
30%, 20%, 15%, 5% ownership respectively

How important is having some $$$ in the bank for injuries/finals trades? Have 2 left
Picken/Hodge leaves me broke
Rance/TMac gives me a something to work with down the track ($71.7k/$113.5k)

 

[MightyMark]

Hodge vs Picken vs Rance vs McDonald
30%, 20%, 15%, 5% ownership respectively

How important is having some $$$ in the bank for injuries/finals trades? Have 2 left
Picken/Hodge leaves me broke
Rance/TMac gives me a something to work with down the track ($71.7k/$113.5k)

Hodge is pretty much a must have in the backline. Shaw and Hodge above everyone else easily. And Hodge will be at least 30K more this time next week.

 

[Kadog]

Which combo?

Jelwood/Picken

Rocky/Eski

Sidey/Tmac

 

[Judd_Magic]

Which combo?

Jelwood/Picken

Rocky/Eski

Sidey/Tmac

Sidey/Tmac IMO

 

[buttox]

Need a replacement for Wallis.

Whose the best pick out of these guys?

Picken (DPP Hodge to mids)
Steven
Heppell
Macrae
Wines
Sidebottom
S.Mitchell

Have $115,300 to play with.

Not sure if there's any better options.

macrae for mine.

 

[juddola]

Which combo?

Jelwood/Picken

Rocky/Eski

Sidey/Tmac

Would go Jelwood and Picken.

 

[Lums23]

Hodge is pretty much a must have in the backline. Shaw and Hodge above everyone else easily. And Hodge will be at least 30K more this time next week.

Picken has actually averaged more than both Hodge and Shaw since his role change

 

[MightyMark]

Picken has actually averaged more than both Hodge and Shaw since his role change

Touche, still prefer Shaw and Hodge over Picken though. But he has been in some ridiculous form.

 

[Stealthchicken]

Which combo?

Jelwood/Picken

Rocky/Eski

Sidey/Tmac

I'm stuck between Eski and Tmac.
Both have a reasonable run home.

 

[Pocket Aces]

For my last midfield and defender spots which combo would you take.

Selwood/Picken - Steele to cover Selwood this week
GAJ/Saad - possible to upgrade Saad later if I get some injury luck.

 

[Krujan]

I'm stuck between Eski and Tmac.
Both have a reasonable run home.

It's hard to make out what Eski will do in the run home, even with a favourable draw. He's been all over the shop SC scoring wise for his entire career. He's just as likely to average 70 as he is to average 100+ from here. I'm leaning on the side of 70 something myself.As you can see from the image below, he has gone 90+ from his full injury free seasons and has struggled in seasons where he has missed chunks of seasons due to injury.

 

[Stealthchicken]

Yeah I'm off both of them, look at spending the money and getting bit more of a ready made defender.


Sent from my HTC_0PJA10 using Tapatalk