Analysis 2016 AFL Trade Week Thread

[LFC2010]

I don't see any mixed message there.

you might not, but others might.

 

[Forzaport]

Sam Mitchell deal done:

Mitchell, #54 and #72 for #52, #70 & #88.

Pick #88 and a minor down grade of R3 & R4 picks.

 

[charcolechaddy]

Sheesh I would've given a future 2nd rounder for Jack Steele, that seems like a good deal for the Saints. Shame we didn't make more of a play.

WTF saints and freo making off like thiefs in the night, we are more like peeping toms.

 

[Alberton Proud]

Sam Mitchell deal done:

Mitchell, #54 and #72 for #52, #70 & #88.

Pick #88 and a minor down grade of R3 & R4 picks.

Bargain !

 

[dav3]

Sheesh I would've given a future 2nd rounder for Jack Steele, that seems like a good deal for the Saints. Shame we didn't make more of a play.

Who says we didn't? In the end he wanted to go to the Saints, and that's where he ended up.

 

[Doctor Feel]

Port will pay pick 9 for Barrett.

 

[bringbackbucky]

I'm not too fussed about the lack of action. Other than the seemingly difficult task of getting rid of Lobbe...

As long as we nail our first round pick and then play the kids next year I'll be happy.

 

[charcolechaddy]

Can we delist everone, sit out next year and then start again with GWS like concessions?

 

[Doctor Feel]

I think people are most frustrated with the lack of trading out, rather than in.

 

[CharlieKelly]

so with our first rounder next year, there's a few SA players coming out of contract who we could potentially trade to the club with it, like Brodie Grundy or Luke Dunstan

 

[Harro59]

In all honestly we need another young tall but besides say Marshall or English would you look to use a first rounder on a developing tall?

Getting a few 2nd round picks is the key.

 

[CharlieKelly]

In all honestly we need another young tall but besides say Marshall or English would you look to use a first rounder on a developing tall?

Getting a few 2nd round picks is the key.

I'd trade Pick 9 to Sydney for Picks 14 and 17

 

[Harro59]

I'm not too fussed about the lack of action. Other than the seemingly difficult task of getting rid of Lobbe...

As long as we nail our first round pick and then play the kids next year I'll be happy.

I think thats the idea. Bonner, Austin, Palmer, Snelling, Frampton and Howard depending on recovery are the keys. Remeber that Ryder is back and yes well are all frustrated at Lobbe but as I said before take a breath and relax.

 

[Harro59]

I'd trade Pick 9 to Sydney for Picks 14 and 17

Yes if that would work ok, maybe we can land a tall and a skillful mid as well.

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

Yea I'm not swapping 9 for picks that''ll slide out to 20ish

 

[SR17]

Marcus Adams has requested a trade back to WA..
Have i missed something? What's the deal with everyone wanting to go to WA now

 

[David Puddy]

Marcus Adams has requested a trade back to WA..
Have i missed something? What's the deal with everyone wanting to go to WA now

After one season with the Dogs? Shows how ridiculous trade period is getting now.

Perth clubs just basically getting freebies in Hill, Hamling, Marsh, Adams.

 

[Coobk001]

I'd trade Pick 9 to Sydney for Picks 14 and 17

Using the draft pick value calculator we would need about pick 26/27 to add to 9 to make this deal happen. You know, the pick we gave to GC.

Anyway, it would depend on the draft, it sounds like keeping 9 will be significantly better in terms of talent than 14 and 17, so we should take the top end talent.

 

[Coobk001]

Marcus Adams has requested a trade back to WA..
Have i missed something? What's the deal with everyone wanting to go to WA now

Ouch, that'll hurt the dogs. They would've been very excited about getting their injured key back, back into that lineup.

 

[CharlieKelly]

Using the draft pick value calculator we would need about pick 26/27 to add to 9 to make this deal happen. You know, the pick we gave to GC.

not sure points value is relevant in this case, Sydney have no Academy talent coming through this year, plus they've already got a strong list, just one top 10 pick will bolster it even further, I think it's win/win for both clubs

 

[Popielnicki]

Marcus Adams request trade back to WA bulldogs will need key defenders trengrove for there pick 18 throw in Lobbe for there 2nd

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

Marcus Adams request trade back to WA bulldogs will need key defenders trengrove for there pick 18 throw in Lobbe for there 2nd

Trengove ain't going anywhere cripes he's the one player with moxie & aggression we have.

 

[Magus]

Marcus Adams request trade back to WA bulldogs will need key defenders trengrove for there pick 18 throw in Lobbe for there 2nd

Trengove is a required player.

 

[David Puddy]

Marcus Adams requests trade back to WA. Bulldogs will need key defenders so give them O'Shea for whatever we can get, throw in Lobbe for a 2nd

Fixed mate.

 

[RossFC]

Marcus Adams request trade back to WA bulldogs will need key defenders

O'Shea for some twix.