2016: Player X vs Y vs Z

[doona]

Laird vs Kolodjasnij???? Anyone?

Laird >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> I could do this all day >>>>>>>>>>>>> KK

 

[FlowersByIrene]

- Varcoe v Rosa
- Nicholls v Leuenberger
- Franklin v Greene
- Crouch v Rich

None, none, none, Crouch
Or
None, none, Franklin, Crouch
Or
None, Nicholls, Franklin, Crouch

 

[nnnvvv]

None, none, none, Crouch
Or
None, none, Franklin, Crouch
Or
None, Nicholls, Franklin, Crouch

who would you go instead of varcoe/rosa then? go a rookie and make more money?

 

[FlowersByIrene]

who would you go instead of varcoe/rosa then? go a rookie and make more money?

Sheridan, Lonergan, Seedsman maybe are all there and abouts, or go lower and use the money for a rookie

 

[doona]

Sheridan, Lonergan, Seedsman maybe are all there and abouts, or go lower and use the money for a rookie

Howe, Harwood, Tippa, Dea would be the only sub 300k players I would want on the field.

Though I have Dea & broad on the pine.

 

[BigVic]

Hannerbery v Pendlebury v Steven
Houli v KK v Yeo
Harwood v Tippa v Francis

 

[nnnvvv]

tossing up between these two options
A) M.Boyd(D2), M.Crouch(M6), Duggan/B.Kennedy or similar sub $250k(M7)

or

B) Laird (D2), M.Robinson (M6), B.Kennedy or similar sub $244k (M7)

 

[Vin28]

I don't know who to pick out of A Hall or T Greene. Currently have Greene but Hall could start the season like a house on fire.

 

[nnnvvv]

I don't know who to pick out of A Hall or T Greene. Currently have Greene but Hall could start the season like a house on fire.

Both are awesome options. I had greene in my team, but swapped for Buddy, was a bit cheaper saved money to upgrade another

 

[Thetrader15]

1. SGray + Dea, or
2. Wells + Howe

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Lewis & Ellis vs Rockliff & Ablett

Pro's of LE, unique, fit, no concerns. Pro's of RA, proven fantasy pigs, underpriced?

Cons of Rocky and Ablett tho.. unfit, no pre season, not unique.

 

[Thetrader15]

Lewis & Ellis vs Rockliff & Ablett

Pro's of LE, unique, fit, no concerns. Pro's of RA, proven fantasy pigs, underpriced?

Cons of Rocky and Ablett tho.. unfit, no pre season, not unique.

RA for me...just can't say no

 

[RickSanchez]

Sam Mitchell + Lance Franklin
vs
Tom Mitchell + Aaron Hall

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Sam Mitchell + Lance Franklin
vs
Tom Mitchell + Aaron Hall

Titch and Hall

 

[Thetrader15]

Titch and Hall

A for me...just. Franklin and SM can got 140+ while not sure the other 2 can

 

[FlowersByIrene]

A for me...just. Franklin and SM can got 140+ while not sure the other 2 can

When has Sam Mitchell ever scored regular 140's? Tom Mitchell has. Also Franklin is the most unreliable player in the game. Never know when he's going to give his all

 

[Thetrader15]

How many vests did TM get last year? I know they are gone but he could be tagging, hb happy or dropped any week. JL doesn't like him for some reason. Not sure that i said SM was a 'regular' 140 man.

Agree it's a tough call and would be happy with either

 

[Benjodt]

One dilemma that I have been questioning as of recent:

Sidey + Leuy
VS
Menzel/JDG/Kennedy + Gawn

 

[LordHaart]

Yeo vs Sheppard vs Sheridan vs other 350-450k defender

Really tough this one

I don't think Yeo has a role figured out yet. Probably needs another 0.5-1 season before he gains consistency.

Sheppard blossomed last year and is pretty consistent. Critical link up player and had a very promising preseason. I've included him in my team at the moment.

I've also included Sheridan, also seems like he could have a bit of a breakout year. I don't see either of him or Sheppard breaking an 85 average really but if they can get to the 75-80 range then that's not all that much lower than the next tier of defenders who cost another $100K or more, so I'm making the value play.

 

[VSTone]

tossing up between these two options
A) M.Boyd(D2), M.Crouch(M6), Duggan/B.Kennedy or similar sub $250k(M7)

or

B) Laird (D2), M.Robinson (M6), B.Kennedy or similar sub $244k (M7)

Boyd will score big but miss a handful of games, so have good bench cover if you choose A

 

[Jozzy]

Option A: Jason Johannisen and Nick Graham

OR

Option B: Rory Laird and Daniel Wells

Pretty much, do I risk it or be more conservative? I think I'm going to go with Option B, In a dream world I would hope Johannisen could go and averages 90-95pts a game. In reality though it's what most people would expect Laird to scoring probably hoping for even higher. Graham has a far higher ceiling than Wells but I don't see why Wells couldn't average 80pts a game and with out the sub rule this year we don't need to worry about him starting as a sub every second week.

 

[Scrotes2000]

Option A: Jason Johannisen and Nick Graham

OR

Option B: Rory Laird and Daniel Wells

Option B for sure A could pay off big time but the risk is too high for me.

 

[Scrotes2000]

Who would you guys go out of Mitch Duncan vs Lachie Hunter.

Anyone going both?

 

[samFFC]

J.Simpkin (226k) or J.Anderson (224k) up forward ?

 

[samFFC]

Option B for sure A could pay off big time but the risk is too high for me.

Yup B for sure

Yeo vs Sheppard vs Sheridan vs other 350-450k defender

Really tough this one

Sherro I would have thought.