2016 trade hypotheticals

[adammania9]

Stephen Coniglio is an absolute star and without even factoring in the contracted part of him, he is worth equal or even more of Adam Treloar. I think people really underestimate how good he really is. IMO he's the best mid at the Giants under 25 and Callan Ward is the only better mid altogether.

 

[cotter101]

David astbury? Brisbane were willing to give up a second rounder last year. Backs dont go cheap and has had a good year, what's his value?

Can't say I'd be giving up our early second round pick. A late second/early third imo.

 

[HeHateMe]

What about Fremantle's pick 3 and 2017 2nd rounder (pick 25ish) for Lobb, McArthy and Coniglio

Assuming Coniglio happy to go home

Seems potentially like a win-win trade

a win for freo.

Loss for GWS.

why is this even suggested.... click bait?

 

[HeHateMe]

3=Coniglio
Top 10= Lobb
Top 20= McCarthy

You're way off

People overrate draft picks way to much. i would have Lobb and McCarthy rated even higher then you, so im completely shocked someone thinks there not even rated a 1st round pick together!

Lobb and McCarthy for a 2017 2nd...... Pfft, see door use door.

 

[The 747]

a win for freo.

Loss for GWS.

why is this even suggested.... click bait?

'The 12 most outrageous AFL trade suggestions, you won't believe #10!"

 

[blueiris]

David astbury? Brisbane were willing to give up a second rounder last year. Backs dont go cheap and has had a good year, what's his value?

Richmond wanted a first round pick for him last season definitely wasn't worth that only reason we were interested was Leppa is my thinking can't see us being interested if Leppitsch left

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

Deledio - Dogs
Prestia - Tigers
Dogs 1st Rnd - Gold Coast

No one even had ago at this.
I think its a fair deal.

 

[Ian Dunross]

Have to agree to disagree

Sitting out a year of football w "mental health issues" affects your trade value - just ask Melbourne re Mitch Clarke

Would be hugely surprised if McArthy fetches more than a 3rd rounder

Lobb then fetches 2 early to mid second rounders - more than fair value when you're able to use points to spend on academy selections

 

[Membling]

No one even had ago at this.
I think its a fair deal.

Gc getting reemed.

 

[Red Black and Blue]

Gc getting reemed.

Doggies as well, when has a first rounder been given for a 30 year old yet alone one with recent injury problems.

 

[HornyLlamas]

Can't say I'd be giving up our early second round pick. A late second/early third imo.

Early second at a minimum. Wont get traded with chaplin retired imo

 

[blueiris]

Early second at a minimum. Wont get traded with chaplin retired imo

Hopefully you keep him don't want him didn't want last year either

 

[Thetrader15]

David astbury? Brisbane were willing to give up a second rounder last year. Backs dont go cheap and has had a good year, what's his value?

Who?

 

[Thetrader15]

What value the following players?
Sam Shaw
Ricky Henderson
Brodie Smith

 

[Ian Dunross]

Brodie Smith an interesting one

Has plummeted this year

Looked ready to burst into elite category only recently

 

[Mego Red]

Brodie Smith an interesting one

Has plummeted this year

Looked ready to burst into elite category only recently

We'll keep him, thanks.

 

[I Lost My Keays]

What value the following players?
Sam Shaw
Ricky Henderson
Brodie Smith

Shaw - we would get nothing at all
Henderson - UFA
Smith - I wouldn't trade him

 

[Thetrader15]

Shaw - we would get nothing at all
Henderson - UFA
Smith - I wouldn't trade him

Agree on the market value of the first 2

 

[Nuggs Bunny]

Saints trade 2017 1st to GWS for jack Steele and late 2016 st (16-18)

Saints trade 2 2016 1sts (9 and 16-18) to Essendon for Hurley + 2nd round pick (likely hibbered pick)

GWS gain 2017 1st, lose Steele and 2016 1st

Essendon gain 2 x 2016 1sts, lose Hurley & Hibbered

Saints lose 2016+2017 firsts, gain Hurley, Steele and 2016 second.

It's a good trade for Essendon and the Saints, but I'd expect GWS fans to disagree.

 

[HornyLlamas]

Hopefully you keep him don't want him didn't want last year either

Not even trolling he would actually be your best defender by a mile imo

 

[cotter101]

Early second at a minimum. Wont get traded with chaplin retired imo

Wouldn't net you an early second round pick. If he's contracted, your better off keeping him.

 

[Ian Dunross]

We'll keep him, thanks.

Answering a question posed by one of your own champ

 

[Mego Red]

Answering a question posed by one of your own champ

Ummm, no.

I responded to your post. We rate him as part of a premiership-quality 22.

Your opinion of him is meaningless.

 

[rusman]

Ummm, no.

I responded to your post. We rate him as part of a premiership-quality 22.

Your opinion of him is meaningless.

Read the message litterally before his first message you quoted. And Take a chill pill

 

[Rimmer]

It is so hard to be objective when you are considering who you might like at your club and what you would trade to get them.
We all tend to value our own too more highly than others do.
Imagine the guy you most want at your club is already yours ... and someone else wants him ...

You would offer a first rounder maybe and a fringe player or two to get the Bont or Cyril or Danger or Rance and figure it was not such a bad deal
... but what if Bont, Cyril or Danger or Rance were already at your club ... would you accept a first rounder and a couple of fringe players for them?