List Mgmt. 2016 Trade Thread

[Jade]

He's a very good player Hibberd. Good in the air for his size and a beautiful kick of the ball.

A much, much better player than Lumumba.

Suspect this trade will be as smooth as the Melksham one.

 

[Theo X]

But Lumumbum has been AA so by your reasoning must be more valuable than Hibberd.

 

[Jade]

But Lumumbum has been AA so by your reasoning must be more valuable than Hibberd.

Sure mate. Offer him in a straight swap and see how that goes.

 

[The Dr]

Sure mate. Offer him in a straight swap and see how that goes.

Melksham for Hibberd?

 

[Jade]

Melksham for Hibberd?

Ha!

Would probably consider it TBH.

 

[dewah07]

haha have fun dees fans with all of this

 

[markm106]

haha have fun dees fans with all of this

Yeah let's face it needs aren't going near Carlisle deal territory.

 

[Jade]

Yeah let's face it needs aren't going near Carlisle deal territory.

We demand your first....

....your

....well shit, your first pick.

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

But Lumumbum has been AA so by your reasoning must be more valuable than Hibberd.

I don't care what happens on other boards - but leave this petty targeting there please.

 

[Theo X]

I don't care what happens on other boards - but leave this petty targeting there please.

Oh woops, I thought it was the D+T board thread, seriously, clicked on it from alerts. Why the hell is Jade here?

 

[dewah07]

Oh woops, I thought it was the D+T board thread, seriously. Why the hell is Jade here?

they don't go, they stay before trade period, during and after haha.

any word on Jay Kennedy-Harris' future?

 

[Rack Watts]

Ignore all this horse shit about Essendon wanting more than a second rounder.
You're not like Ameet Bains, trying to low-ball us because of a player's circumstance.
He's worth an early second rounder, you paid too much for Melksham, I am sure we'd trade you Hibberd with that in mind.

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

Oh woops, I thought it was the D+T board thread, seriously, clicked on it from alerts. Why the hell is Jade here?

Thanks mate - I guess because of Hibberd.

 

[The Bomb]

I can see what your club has done,
soften us up with the Melksham deal to bend us over on this one.
Hibberd is a bloody good player.

 

[LeverPuller]

they don't go, they stay before trade period, during and after haha.

any word on Jay Kennedy-Harris' future?

Still contracted but can't get a game. Wouldn't be worth Hibberd...but might be a part of the deal.

 

[Pedantic]

they don't go, they stay before trade period, during and after haha.

any word on Jay Kennedy-Harris' future?

JKH apparently has a contract offer from Carlton, according to commentators on Casey community radio.

 

[Theo X]

Still contracted but can't get a game. Wouldn't be worth Hibberd...but might be a part of the deal.

Might've been asking more for StKilda perhaps I think, do they need small forwards though?

JKH apparently has a contract offer from Carlton, according to commentators on Casey community radio.

Anything about what they might offer us? Not much I guess

 

[stabler]

It's a second round pick or nothing. No need to bend over on this one.

Edit. For hibberd I'm referring to

 

[Jade]

Reality is I think if it really comes down to it, we'll take your second.

Dodoro will no doubt see what angle he can work, but the Melksham trade was smooth as. If that was slight overs I'd be happy to accept slight unders for Hibberd.

 

[qarocks]

Just need to remind essendon why exactly Hibberd is leaving, they can take what they get for him. Also what much better payers were traded for last year, ie Danger, second rounder is totally fair.

They could take Dawes though.

 

[Theo X]

Just need to remind essendon why exactly Hibberd is leaving, that can take what they get for him. Also what much better payers were traded for last year.
Second rounder is totally fair.

They could take Dawes though.

Well yeah that and it seems Essendon aren't prepared to offer him a 4 year contract.

 

[Pedantic]

Might've been asking more for StKilda perhaps I think, do they need small forwards though?

Anything about what they might offer us? Not much I guess

Nah, they didn't say anything about that I don't think. I'd suspect Carlton's third rounder but that's just an educated guess.

 

[PerfectFooty]

Wouldn't be against off loading JKH to the blues. If you asked me in 2014 i would have said no bloody way! But the blues might need that extra small forward and we can try and get something out of it. While not shocked about it, am a bit sad. Didn't mind JKH, really used to get me excited and is a decent guy. All the best if he stays here or goes elsewhere

 

[stabler]

Reality is I think if it really comes down to it, we'll take your second.

Dodoro will no doubt see what angle he can work, but the Melksham trade was smooth as. If that was slight overs I'd be happy to accept slight unders for Hibberd.

Let's be honest, Dodoro is a **** but he gets results. He'll be demanding a Salem, Neal-Bullen or Hullett and quite honestly, he can get ****ed. We paid overs for Melksham and even Mediator Mahoney isn't going to play the nice guy again on this one

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

I'd be happy to add in a fringe youngster to get the deal done - a JKH/ANB type even.

I like both players but feel there's not a heap of room for them at the moment.