Remove this Banner Ad

Game Day 2017 National Draft

The OP for our new picks must be accurate and informative. Who should do it?

  • Anyone

    Votes: 39 35.5%
  • Wait for TD

    Votes: 71 64.5%

  • Total voters
    110
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

My 1st Round Mock Draft at the Moment:

1: Brisbane - Andrew Brayshaw
2: Frematle - Cameron Rayner
3: Carlton - Paddy Dow
4: North - Luke Davis/Unikale
5: Freo - Adam Cerra
6: Collingwood - Aaron Naughton
7: St Kilda - Darcy Fogarty
8: St Kilds - Nick Coffield
9: Buldogs - Jaidyn STEPHENSON
10: Carlton - Aidan Bonar
11: GWS Giants - Oscar Allan
12: Adelaide - Lachie O'Brien
13: West Coast - Ed Richards
14: Sydney - Hunter Clark
15: Brisbane - Lachlan Fogarty
16: Bulldogs - Nathan Murphy
17: Richmond - Jarrad Brander
18: Brisbane - Jack Higgins
19: Gold Coast - Charlie Constable
 
Josh Thomas NOT promoted to senior list, per Patrick Keane on twitter.

I agree with that Move. He can play RD 1 next year anyway as now Rookies can play when ever they are Selected
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Josh Thomas NOT promoted to senior list, per Patrick Keane on twitter.

Interesting, that'd make 70 a live pick. It seems the sensible thing.

EDIT: apparently pick 70 isn't live.
 
Last edited:
My 1st Round Mock Draft at the Moment:

1: Brisbane - Andrew Brayshaw
2: Frematle - Cameron Rayner
3: Carlton - Paddy Dow
4: North - Luke Davis/Unikale
5: Freo - Adam Cerra
6: Collingwood - Aaron Naughton
7: St Kilda - Darcy Fogarty
8: St Kilds - Nick Coffield
9: Buldogs - Jaidyn STEPHENSON
10: Carlton - Aidan Bonar
11: GWS Giants - Oscar Allan
12: Adelaide - Lachie O'Brien
13: West Coast - Ed Richards
14: Sydney - Hunter Clark
15: Brisbane - Lachlan Fogarty
16: Bulldogs - Nathan Murphy
17: Richmond - Jarrad Brander
18: Brisbane - Jack Higgins
19: Gold Coast - Charlie Constable

Rayner at 1.

LDU at 2

Dogs will take Ed Richards at 9 if Coffield is gone and Higgins at 16.

Nathan Murphy to Swans at 14.

;)
 
Rayner at 1.

LDU at 2

Dogs will take Ed Richards at 9 if Coffield is gone and Higgins at 16.

Nathan Murphy to Swans at 14.

;)
If Ed goes at nine, six is not that far of a reach then.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

If Richards played The Champs I think we’d be keen as to take him at 6.

Depends how we went IF he did Play. What would of Happened IF he had a Poor Champs?
 
If Richards played The Champs I think we’d be keen as to take him at 6.
I see Richards type of player a need as much as Naughton. Is there good chb types later on in the draft
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

And some one reckons this is a shallow drat, plenty to pick from.
This is where the good recruiters shine. All of them will be keen to show their skills later in the draft in picking up the good players. Hope this is one where we can look back and say ‘we did really well here, look who this club picked’ and we laugh all the way to the flag.
 
Crunched the numbers.

White
Oxley
Keeffe
Sinclair
Ramsay
McCarthy*
Schade*
Mackie*

Did I miss anyone? All delisted off a senior list of 39 and 6 rookies (including 1x Cat B). Takes us to 34 and 2 (Cox not Cat B eligible so list drops from 45 to 44).

To date, we've added Murray, and we have to add Cox to the senior list. Leaves us with 36 and 2. So now I'm confused as to why we've been saying 4x live picks while assuming Thomas was already on the senior list because that's what the clubs website said, when with the confirmation today that Thomas is still on the rookie list, we still only seem to have 4x picks? Where has the confusion come from?
 
And some one reckons this is a shallow drat, plenty to pick from.

All with queries. Rayner (tank), Bonar (injuries), Naughton (kicking), Coffield (inside game), Fogarty (form), Stephenson (kicking), LDU (does he want it enough) and Murphy (what’s his role). The only guys I see as certainties are Dow, Brayshaw and Cerra. Even then are they top 3 on a list talents?
 
All with queries. Rayner (tank), Bonar (injuries), Naughton (kicking), Coffield (inside game), Fogarty (form), Stephenson (kicking), LDU (does he want it enough) and Murphy (what’s his role). The only guys I see as certainties are Dow, Brayshaw and Cerra. Even then are they top 3 on a list talents?
Most kids have queries on them in any draft, and most are not top three on a list at this stage, does not that mean any that you mentioned will not make a top of any list in the future though.
Nothing is certain at this stage, but l will back most of them in to around top five to ten in most clubs going forward
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom