List Mgmt. 2017 Trade & FA Targets Part 2

[Roadto2018]

I highly doubt Robbo would 'want' to leave, but if he's getting offered 200k more at another club you couldn't really blame him could you? I fully expect us to reach an agreement though and sign him long term


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[STK2020]

The Hawks would still have to organise a trade. If he is in the AA squad they can offer all they want if we don't get what we want for him. They have a bunch of old guys and one or two goodish kids and a bunch of mid tier average players. And some how they don't have a first round pick this year. They have **** all we would want. If he wants to move send the campaigner back to Freo for Weller, Balic and Tucker.

Makes me ill to even think of Robbo leaving for Hawks but i reckon Bruest and their 2nd rounder with our 3rd going to them sounds about right .

 

[gringo2011]

Makes me ill to even think of Robbo leaving for Hawks but i reckon Bruest and their 2nd rounder with our 3rd going to them sounds about right .

**** that we want Bruest, their second and Burton. They can throw in half Loose Breasts salary too.

 

[Mowman]

Makes me ill to even think of Robbo leaving for Hawks but i reckon Bruest and their 2nd rounder with our 3rd going to them sounds about right .

Would rather Robbo every day of the week and twice on Sundays

 

[Saint Hendy]

Can someone explain to me how $700k is too much for Robbo? He's in All Australian conversations, rarely misses a target and is the right age demographic for us.
Surely it's affordable with the increased cap? Just pay the man [emoji389]

 

[VDS66]

So what would Robbo be worth in terms of picks? First rounder?

 

[STK2020]

**** that we want Bruest, their second and Burton. They can throw in half Loose Breasts salary too.

No chance Burton ,
If we manage to land Kelly , Bruest and Pittard as FA and hit the draft with Hawks 1st & 2nd picks ....happy days , ticks a few of our weaknesses... midfield star , add 30-40 goal fwd , run off half back , 2 x young stars .
Robbo who ?

 

[gringo2011]

So what would Robbo be worth in terms of picks? First rounder?

If he makes the AA extended list his value would go up. He has made a few club stand up and take notice I reckon. Probably a first rounder and some change, he's still young and looks ready to lead a finals defence.

I really hope we don't **** this up, it could be like Greg Williams or Eddie Betts where $20,000 cost us a whole lot of embarrassment when we let him go. ****ing Hawks ****ed us on Carlisle, ****ed us on Joel Smith and are just generally flogs. We should offer a heap for Burton straight up.

 

[gringo2011]

No chance Burton ,
If we manage to land Kelly , Bruest and Pittard as FA and hit the draft with Hawks 1st & 2nd picks ....happy days , ticks a few of our weaknesses... midfield star , add 30-40 goal fwd , run off half back , 2 x young stars .
Robbo who ?

He's in our top 5 players, you don't let those go to improve.

 

[George]

Talk about paying overs. Johannisen 5 years.

 

[Yawkey way]

This is why you don't overpay a Martin or Kelly to get them in the door, a premium yes but not stupid money.

Roberton and our other top players will want there money as well and fair enough.

Time for ameet to earn his money, nobody said it was easy it's hard enough playing SuperCoach.

 

[plugger66]

So what would Robbo be worth in terms of picks? First rounder?

Maybe around 16- 23 I reckon. He is having a great year but he is a HBF and even the best wouldn't be top 10 I reckon. We need to keep him. No point in getting one and losing a very good player.

 

[crasha301]

Robbo probably worth 450-500k a year, definitely not 700k a year.

Totally understand him wanting to get as much as he can thou.



On SM-G900I using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Mowman]

This is why you don't overpay a Martin or Kelly to get them in the door, a premium yes but not stupid money.

Roberton and our other top players will want there money as well and fair enough.

Time for ameet to earn his money, nobody said it was easy it's hard enough playing SuperCoach.

Yep so true, How much will Seb next contract cost

 

[plugger66]

This is why you don't overpay a Martin or Kelly to get them in the door, a premium yes but not stupid money.

Roberton and our other top players will want there money as well and fair enough.

Time for ameet to earn his money, nobody said it was easy it's hard enough playing SuperCoach.

I don't get what the pay to those guys has to do with Roberton. Can you explain. Of course we have to overpay them otherwise they wont leave. Nearly every good player that leaves a club gets overpaid at their next club.

 

[Mowman]

I don't get what the pay to those guys has to do with Roberton. Can you explain. Of course we have to overpay them otherwise they wont leave. Nearly every good player that leaves a club gets overpaid at their next club.

Surely you don't need that explained

 

[plugger66]

Surely you don't that explained

Yes I do. As you seem to know what he meant maybe you can explain.

 

[Glen Buterol]

**** that we want Bruest, their second and Burton. They can throw in half Loose Breasts salary too.

Surely we don't need anymore loose breasts, we already have mattress guts

 

[STK2020]

Hopefully our club has a plan B IF a player does leave .
Negatives into positive type stuff to keep members happy .

 

[Left_Billings]

Roberton easy worth 650k, just because he was chump change when we got him doesn't mean he hasn't become a premium part of our side, one of our most important players and top 3 in the bnf at this stage for sure. Pay him

 

[Persevering Saint]

and when I get that feelin, I want... Josh Kelly healin. Josh Kelly... heaaalin. Josh Kelly healin

Makes me feel so fine, it's such a rush
Helps to relieve the mind, and it's good for us

 

[Moral Decay]

Can someone explain to me how $700k is too much for Robbo? He's in All Australian conversations, rarely misses a target and is the right age demographic for us.
Surely it's affordable with the increased cap? Just pay the man [emoji389]

Maybe the improvement in Sinclair and Billings means their asking price has skyrocketed, a big payday for "Kelly and one other", (and we have no idea who and how good that other might be) means Robbo's form lift has caught the club by surprise?
Do we judge him on this years form alone or the whole of his previous contract? If Carlisle and Brown hadn't been so good would Roberton have as much licence to run?
With Stratton and Birchall getting older and injured, Hodge retiring and Gibson on his last legs, Roberton's height, run and disposal skills particularly his willingness and ability to hit targets going through the centre of the ground when most back men keep disposal efficiency high by going backwards and wide to an unmarked man, make him a no-brainer for Hawthorn to target.
Maybe it comes down to a choice between Roberton or Sinclair, if so I'll take the Jack.

 

[Longmembrey]

Robbo probably worth 450-500k a year, definitely not 700k a year.

Totally understand him wanting to get as much as he can thou.

What?? $450k is barely above the average wage post-eba! Worth a lot more



On SM-G900I using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Sir Skid]

Hawks giving us their next years 1st round pick +?

 

[Glen Buterol]

Johannson re-signed with the Dogs for $3M over 5 years. Robbo worth similar imo.