2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)

[Glorin]

I see others 50 -100k cheaper getting the same average as Kelly.
I see Coniglio as a big improver

Are you saying Kelly drops or others improve to match his 114?
There are other cheaper mids who could do it, but I have been burnt by many of them. After starting with Treloar last year on potential I am sticking with guys that have arrived and are at their prime. A lot of guys who have been there before are past their best and will have to return to that level. Prefer to stick to guys who are already there.
Coniglio is an intersting one but he is not cheap enough to be a real bargain and he has a big mountain to climb to be in top 10 mids so is he a keeper or a stepping stone? At least with Jager, if he does play, which all signs say yes at this stage, then at his price he is a bargain and a clear stepping stone. If he does hit potential then a m8 is realistic. If not he becomes Danger et al, when he hits 500k

 

[toxic]

Are you saying Kelly drops or others improve to match his 114?
There are other cheaper mids who could do it, but I have been burnt by many of them. After starting with Treloar last year on potential I am sticking with guys that have arrived and are at their prime. A lot of guys who have been there before are past their best and will have to return to that level. Prefer to stick to guys who are already there.
Coniglio is an intersting one but he is not cheap enough to be a real bargain and he has a big mountain to climb to be in top 10 mids so is he a keeper or a stepping stone? At least with Jager, if he does play, which all signs say yes at this stage, then at his price he is a bargain and a clear stepping stone. If he does hit potential then a m8 is realistic. If not he becomes Danger et al, when he hits 500k

Fwiw i had Kelly from Rd1 in 2017 and hecwas great value
I see Kelly as 105 -115 average in 2018, just dont see scope to go 125 average.
I see Fyfe Pendles Beams + a few others all with the 120+ average potential and cheaper than Kelly

 

[Hai_Newman]

Nope

Gawn gets more points
Petracca more points
Lever and Hibberd more points
Brayshaw more points

Redpubes Oliver, average points

Hmmm Petrecca hey forgot about him, is he fwd selectable again?
Oooohhh he is...

big bootaaaaah thoughts?

 

[Hai_Newman]

Fwiw i had Kelly from Rd1 in 2017 and hecwas great value
I see Kelly as 105 -115 average in 2018, just dont see scope to go 125 average.
I see Fyfe Pendles Beams + a few others all with the 120+ average potential and cheaper than Kelly

Fyfe yes, Beamer maybe...Pendles no...think his day are over...






Will be watching his JLT series closely.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Hmmm Petrecca hey forgot about him, is he fwd selectable again?
Oooohhh he is...

big bootaaaaah thoughts?

He’s a campaigner, no.

 

[Hai_Newman]

No need to change mind.
My 1st look at rucks is blah
Gawn and NutNut

Couple i have a watch on but just don't see much value there on 1st glance

Always cracks me up kenty!!

 

[toxic]

Fyfe yes, Beamer maybe...Pendles no...think his day are over...






Will be watching his JLT series closely.

Pendles is the ultimate professional

Will be pies highest SC average by 10 (above Tay Adams, Treroar, Reg Grundy)

 

[Hai_Newman]

Pendles is the ultimate professional

Will be pies highest SC average by 10 (above Tay Adams, Treroar, Reg Grundy)

Don't think he can be a top 10 mid this year tbh.
Now, Reg Grundy is the one that interest me the most, what do you see him averaging this year bruv?

 

[toxic]

Don't think he can be a top 10 mid this year tbh.
Now, Reg Grundy is the one that interest me the most, what do you see him averaging this year bruv?

With Cox locked in the team i see his SC scores dropping tbh

 

[markm106]

Don't think he can be a top 10 mid this year tbh.
Now, Reg Grundy is the one that interest me the most, what do you see him averaging this year bruv?

If Cox plays you can put a massive line through Grundy. Last couple years his average drops big time when cox plays. And it seems Buckley wants to play Cox.

 

[toxic]

Don't think he can be a top 10 mid this year tbh.
Now, Reg Grundy is the one that interest me the most, what do you see him averaging this year bruv?

I see a clear top 4 then a swag who could be 5-30. Pendles is in that bracket imo

 

[Seymour Skinner]

Fwiw i had Kelly from Rd1 in 2017 and hecwas great value
I see Kelly as 105 -115 average in 2018, just dont see scope to go 125 average.
I see Fyfe Pendles Beams + a few others all with the 120+ average potential and cheaper than Kelly

I'll probably end up gambling on either Rocky or Beams again this year moments before final lockout.

Beams more likely, but he just falls apart every year.

 

[toxic]

I'll probably end up gambling on either Rocky or Beams again this year moments before final lockout.

Beams more likely, but he just falls apart every year.

I want both

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

I like Pendles.
Name one uber premo who has averaged over 110 for years on end that you didn't go back one more time for the cherry?
Had him last year and he was average but still in the top 20 mids once you take out his injury scores.

This year with no injuries and the Pies on the improve and he could easily go back to a 120 average and at a bargain price.

 

[Kadog]

Interested to see Rocky in a decent Port side. Lots of pts to share but I think he'll bury his snout deep and return to pig status.

Beams is an SP all day everyday, health permitting.

 

[Flandersss]

I think he'll bury his snout deep and return to pig status.

Yes.

 

[Glorin]

Fwiw i had Kelly from Rd1 in 2017 and hecwas great value
I see Kelly as 105 -115 average in 2018, just dont see scope to go 125 average.
I see Fyfe Pendles Beams + a few others all with the 120+ average potential and cheaper than Kelly

Fyfe yes, Beamer maybe...Pendles no...think his day are over...






Will be watching his JLT series closely.

I had Kelly from start aswell. May be clouding my judgement but happy to start with him at the moment.
Agree with Fyfe. Lock.
Beams has been a favorite of mine and could end up in my side, but he would have to be my only risk.
Am in agreement with Hai_Newman on Pendles. Was first picked for a long time but just get the feeling his best is behind him.

 

[Hai_Newman]

I had Kelly from start aswell. May be clouding my judgement but happy to start with him at the moment.
Agree with Fyfe. Lock.
Beams has been a favorite of mine and could end up in my side, but he would have to be my only risk.
Am in agreement with Hai_Newman on Pendles. Was first picked for a long time but just get the feeling his best is behind him.

Fefes in ripping nick, Dusty, Danger locks and good luck on the rest....
Question marks will be on Danger, will he start off slow, will Dusty go back to being a 1/2 effort campainger Partay animal...
Neale...Fefe in great nick
Sloane... tagged out
JPK...sharing too many points with Parker, Heeney, Cabbage patch kent...

Cant see it being clear cut...

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Hey Herald Sun.
My bank details are...

 

[Flandersss]

Hey Herald Sun.
My bank details are...

View attachment 443253

Oliver>Bont

 

[Hai_Newman]

Hey Herald Sun.
My bank details are...

View attachment 443253

 

[Hai_Newman]

Oliver>Bont

 

[Hai_Newman]

Hey Herald Sun.
My bank details are...

View attachment 443253

That team bats deep, 16 potential keepers ..Risky ask *** but who knows after last years Witts ruck combo
shake em up, throw out all SC logic ...

 

[Hai_Newman]

Hai Judd_Magic Ruby puppies update you splendid kenty?

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

That team bats deep, 16 potential keepers ..Risky ask *** but who knows after last years Witts ruck combo
shake em up, throw out all SC logic ...

I ditch Bennell to a rook and turn Bont into Danger like magic.
****in expensive campaigner he is