Prediction 2018 trade hypothetical thread

[Tyruddanaut]

Direct trade:
Jake Lloyd + #33
Future 1st round (Carlton) + #23

 

[Jeremias]

Direct trade:
Jake Lloyd + #33
Future 1st round (Carlton) + #23

No thanks.

 

[Tyruddanaut]

No thanks.

Jake Lloyd is one reportedly on our watchlist.
Also, SOS says our preference is to trade future picks.
He will take the pressure off Simpson for the time that he is still playing, and allow O'Brien to push up onto the wing.

 

[Jeremias]

Jake Lloyd is one reportedly on our watchlist.
Also, SOS says our preference is to trade future picks.
He will take the pressure off Simpson for the time that he is still playing, and allow O'Brien to push up onto the wing.

Happy to be interested in Lloyd but we’d be mad to pay that price. We’re not giving up a potential top 5 pick for an out of contract Lloyd, and upgrading their 2nd.

LOB can move up to a wing (he’s been spending time there this year anyway) without Lloyd. We’ve got Docherty and Williamson returning next year.

 

[Joao]

Direct trade:
Jake Lloyd + #33
Future 1st round (Carlton) + #23

Master troll (of your own team no less)?

That's horrible for you guys. Jake Lloyd gets 75% of his touches from chips in the back line or handball receives from someone who just marked a chip in the backline.

LLoyd for pick 20 is probably as far as you would want to go there IMO.

 

[Red Black and Blue]

Direct trade:
Jake Lloyd + #33
Future 1st round (Carlton) + #23

Future first is likely to be another top 5 pick, that is rubbish for you. 2 second rounders is value IMO.

 

[Tyruddanaut]

Future first is likely to be another top 5 pick, that is rubbish for you. 2 second rounders is value IMO.

A good offseason and Lloyd could make us skyrocket. Especially with the injuries. But maybe an exchange of future first rounds could be alright

 

[Savage Kent]

Saints: 2019 1st round pick + Ross + Billings
Blues: pick 1 + pick 25

 

[Dez!]

Saints: 2019 1st round pick + Ross + Billings
Blues: pick 1 + pick 25

Yeah Carlton aren't giving up pick 1 for a future first round pick.

 

[Tyruddanaut]

Yeah Carlton aren't giving up pick 1 for a future first round pick.

Our preference is to trade our future picks. Confirmed by SOS himself

 

[Dez!]

Our preference is to trade our future picks. Confirmed by SOS himself

Read his trade again.

He has you giving up pick 1 to get St Kilda's future first round pick, not Carlton trading a future first.

 

[Tyruddanaut]

Saints: 2019 1st round pick + Ross + Billings
Blues: pick 1 + pick 25

We'll do 2019 first round and 23

Edit: That's a great trade for us either way. Ticks all our boxes apart from the receipt of a future pick

 

[THE_GUN]

Saints: 2019 1st round pick + Ross + Billings
Blues: pick 1 + pick 25

Why would St Kilda want pick #1 ?? Surely Lukosius is not a priority for the saints

 

[Savage Kent]

Why would St Kilda want pick #1 ?? Surely Lukosius is not a priority for the saints

Saints need to get their hands on as much a-grade talent as possible. Lukosius is most highly touted prospect in a long time. Saints potentially end up with picks 1&2. Pick up potentially the next Riewoldt and select best available mid.

There are still question marks on whether Paddy will make it as well.

 

[Turbocat]

Our preference is to trade our future picks. Confirmed by SOS himself

Picks as in plural? so picks from R2 on..

 

[Tyruddanaut]

Picks as in plural? so picks from R2 on..

He said is we are going to get a player like Shiel, our preference would be a future pick. We're assuming it's first because we won't be able to get him with anything less.

 

[adammania9]

Sam Frost to Collingwood in exchange for a 2019 3rd round draft pick

Or

Jack Hombsch to Collingwood in exchange for a 2019 3rd round draft pick

 

[Dez!]

Sam Frost to Collingwood in exchange for a 2019 3rd round draft pick

Or

Jack Hombsch to Collingwood in exchange for a 2019 3rd round draft pick

Nope on Frost, gonna have to pay more than that if you want him especially since Lever won't be back until at least mid year next year.

 

[Julia#13]

Sam Frost to Collingwood in exchange for a 2019 3rd round draft pick

Or

Jack Hombsch to Collingwood in exchange for a 2019 3rd round draft pick

We wouldnt let Jack go for just a third rounder either. He's probbaly worth more to us than the market but would say it would have to be at least a pick between 25 -35 or something like Hombsch + 3rd rounder for 2nd rounder

 

[adammania9]

We wouldnt let Jack go for just a third rounder either. He's probbaly worth more to us than the market but would say it would have to be at least a pick between 25 -35 or something like Hombsch + 3rd rounder for 2nd rounder

I’d be all for that if the Pies target him.

 

[Tyruddanaut]

How will Cripps award trophy look like when he retires.
How many premierhsips?
Brownlows?

Does he get any?

Most likely 1 Premiership. Max of 3
1 Brownlow this year, most likely 2 max of 4.
AA almost every year until he's 31

 

[PAFC_1870]

We wouldnt let Jack go for just a third rounder either. He's probbaly worth more to us than the market but would say it would have to be at least a pick between 25 -35 or something like Hombsch + 3rd rounder for 2nd rounder

No way would I move him on for anything over 30

 

[blueiris]

Sam Frost to Collingwood in exchange for a 2019 3rd round draft pick

Or

Jack Hombsch to Collingwood in exchange for a 2019 3rd round draft pick

You can have Jack Frost back for a 4th round pick was your best defender at Collingwood at the time of being traded

 

[adammania9]

You can have Jack Frost back for a 4th round pick was your best defender at Collingwood at the time of being traded

How kind of you

 

[Mego Red]

Saints need to get their hands on as much a-grade talent as possible. Lukosius is most highly touted prospect in a long time. Saints potentially end up with picks 1&2. Pick up potentially the next Riewoldt and select best available mid.

There are still question marks on whether Paddy will make it as well.

There's no point having two A Grade Players and then a team full of C Grade Players.