Preview 2019 Round 22 - Richmond vs West Coast, Sunday 18th of August @ MCG, 1:10pm

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Grechy

Premiership Player
Mar 10, 2005
4,375
7,239
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Liverpool, Houston Rockets
Club has said Cotchins hammy was a little niggle but it's a 3 weeker which suggests it was a lot worse then first suspected. Wish they'd be a bit more upfront. Dimma said last week that he was right to go against Carlton but held him back another week. FWIW watch the first quarter against Collingwood. Cotchin was at his best, just a shame he can't string games together. 1 game against Brisbane won't be enough miles in the leg before finals especially with the bye. I rate Ross highly and reckon he is a perfect replacement but at this stage of his career he isn't the same leader or player Cotchin is.
 

Daffytrain

πŸ†πŸ†
Oct 4, 2017
1,031
3,759
Melbourne, VIC
AFL Club
Richmond
Club has said Cotchins hammy was a little niggle but it's a 3 weeker which suggests it was a lot worse then first suspected. Wish they'd be a bit more upfront. Dimma said last week that he was right to go against Carlton but held him back another week. FWIW watch the first quarter against Collingwood. Cotchin was at his best, just a shame he can't string games together. 1 game against Brisbane won't be enough miles in the leg before finals especially with the bye. I rate Ross highly and reckon he is a perfect replacement but at this stage of his career he isn't the same leader or player Cotchin is.
Agree but Ross seems to have that "effort to hunt the ball" edge that Cotchin excels in. Not to the same level of course. If we had to have a second string in his first year to replace Cotch, this guy is probably it at this stage. Hope we keep him long term, looks like he will be a jet.
 

Lsta062

Brownlow Medallist
Jul 15, 2014
13,508
26,814
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Chelsea
This is not the time of year to be content with a loss, that's for losers like bombre and pie fans.
Yeah for the players. I however am not one of them and would be content with a close loss if neither Dusty nor Cotchin get up. They have worked so hard to put themselves in this position and if they slip up by losing closely to the reigning premiers because of injuries to our top players then so be it. As long as they bounce back against Brisbane and finish in the top 4.

I believe we can win this game of course because of how tough they have become even with Dusty and Cotchin out, but I think we need to give our players some understanding pre-game at least once in a while.
 

Karp3_dm

Club Legend
Suspended
Jun 29, 2018
1,014
3,573
AFL Club
Richmond
I just hope Stack goes back to the HBF role played his best footy there enough with this experiment sometimes coaches do your head in.Bolton needs to stay in Xfactor and speed for me and stays permanently in the guts.
Totally agree!! Stack is better across half back imo!

All the people calling for Bolton to be dropped are the biggest knee jerk result based reactions! He has one fumbly, not great stats game in the wet..
week before he was good just was off target and should’ve passed a couple off rather than going for goal himself..

On the weekend he already rectified that by looking for a teammate in a better position rather than goal first instinct!

His speed and evasiveness gets us out of packs and creates forward momentum more than most. He’s a real weapon and people forget he’s only 20..
 

DontArgue4

πŸ†
May 3, 2013
16,535
50,611
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Houston Rockets, Arsenal, PhiEagles
Totally agree!! Stack is better across half back imo!

All the people calling for Bolton to be dropped are the biggest knee jerk result based reactions! He has one fumbly, not great stats game in the wet..
week before he was good just was off target and should’ve passed a couple off rather than going for goal himself..

On the weekend he already rectified that by looking for a teammate in a better position rather than goal first instinct!

His speed and evasiveness gets us out of packs and creates forward momentum more than most. He’s a real weapon and people forget he’s only 20..
agree completely

bolton needs to stay in imo
 

thedreamisreal

πŸ†πŸ†
Sep 27, 2017
517
2,345
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
Totally agree!! Stack is better across half back imo!

All the people calling for Bolton to be dropped are the biggest knee jerk result based reactions! He has one fumbly, not great stats game in the wet..
week before he was good just was off target and should’ve passed a couple off rather than going for goal himself..

On the weekend he already rectified that by looking for a teammate in a better position rather than goal first instinct!

His speed and evasiveness gets us out of packs and creates forward momentum more than most. He’s a real weapon and people forget he’s only 20..
So who comes out for Dusty? Stack to HB and Baker omitted?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

yeee_haaaa!!!!!

Club Legend
Aug 30, 2010
1,161
919
prahran
AFL Club
Collingwood
Club has said Cotchins hammy was a little niggle but it's a 3 weeker which suggests it was a lot worse then first suspected. Wish they'd be a bit more upfront. Dimma said last week that he was right to go against Carlton but held him back another week. FWIW watch the first quarter against Collingwood. Cotchin was at his best, just a shame he can't string games together. 1 game against Brisbane won't be enough miles in the leg before finals especially with the bye. I rate Ross highly and reckon he is a perfect replacement but at this stage of his career he isn't the same leader or player Cotchin is.
Rich are turning into collingwood when it comes to reporting on their injuries. We have been copping this crap from the club for years about injuries. Niggle = 6 weeks on the sidelines, in doubt for this week = misses a month. Cotchin was never playing this week, and i am pretty sure you will find he won't be there in rnd 23 either, it's a lot more serious than the club is letting on. You will also find that martin won't be out there this week - his "general soreness" is a lower leg problem that is a much bigger problem than they are letting on and he is no certainty for the bri game in rnd 23 either. cheers
 

JAKLAUGHING

πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†
Nov 20, 2008
26,936
47,102
Tokyo
AFL Club
Richmond
Rich are turning into collingwood when it comes to reporting on their injuries. We have been copping this crap from the club for years about injuries. Niggle = 6 weeks on the sidelines, in doubt for this week = misses a month. Cotchin was never playing this week, and i am pretty sure you will find he won't be there in rnd 23 either, it's a lot more serious than the club is letting on. You will also find that martin won't be out there this week - his "general soreness" is a lower leg problem that is a much bigger problem than they are letting on and he is no certainty for the bri game in rnd 23 either. cheers
Will still win!
 

Karp3_dm

Club Legend
Suspended
Jun 29, 2018
1,014
3,573
AFL Club
Richmond
So who comes out for Dusty? Stack to HB and Baker omitted?
Yeah I’m not too sure whether graham, Ross and dusty all play together.. I’d say they probably do but maybe not cotchin as well...

Whoever makes way for dusty will be extremely unlucky..
Ross or Baker or Bolton I guess
 

Dr Tigris

Premium Platinum
Aug 19, 2009
6,872
16,326
Canberra
AFL Club
Richmond
Cotch out is not good. But we still have the midfield to cause them many problems.

I like a Cotch, Ross Graham set up. Grunt and class. Causes hurt both defensively and offensively. Cotch out I guess means we'll move Dusty in there a bit more.
 

JAKLAUGHING

πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†πŸ†
Nov 20, 2008
26,936
47,102
Tokyo
AFL Club
Richmond
Yeah I’m not too sure whether graham, Ross and dusty all play together.. I’d say they probably do but maybe not cotchin as well...

Whoever makes way for dusty will be extremely unlucky..
Ross or Baker or Bolton I guess
At a guess I would say Baker!
 

sportshow

All Australian
Jul 6, 2011
637
1,560
AFL Club
Richmond
Rich are turning into collingwood when it comes to reporting on their injuries. We have been copping this crap from the club for years about injuries. Niggle = 6 weeks on the sidelines, in doubt for this week = misses a month. Cotchin was never playing this week, and i am pretty sure you will find he won't be there in rnd 23 either, it's a lot more serious than the club is letting on. You will also find that martin won't be out there this week - his "general soreness" is a lower leg problem that is a much bigger problem than they are letting on and he is no certainty for the bri game in rnd 23 either. cheers
Or .... they pulled up sore/not 100% from THIS weeks training and won’t be risked .... as you were ....
 

Grrr

Norm Smith Medallist
Aug 16, 2009
5,550
11,576
mildura
AFL Club
Richmond
Club has said Cotchins hammy was a little niggle but it's a 3 weeker which suggests it was a lot worse then first suspected. Wish they'd be a bit more upfront. Dimma said last week that he was right to go against Carlton but held him back another week. FWIW watch the first quarter against Collingwood. Cotchin was at his best, just a shame he can't string games together. 1 game against Brisbane won't be enough miles in the leg before finals especially with the bye. I rate Ross highly and reckon he is a perfect replacement but at this stage of his career he isn't the same leader or player Cotchin is.
Perhaps they are saving him for finals. Tune up against Brisbane. His hammy may be good enough to play but the more games he plays this season the bigger the risk of another hamstring.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top Bottom