List Mgmt. 2020 List Management II

[Opine]

You have lost me, it was just a light hearted joke.

Don't be lost; mine was light hearted advancement of your light hearted joke.

 

[DangerousD]

Don't be lost; mine was light hearted advancement of your light hearted joke.

It made me think too hard.

 

[TommyPinch]

So Williams puts us at capacity on senior list. Not sure why we rushed to upgrade Gibbons.

Would look to move Betts, Macreadie and Polson to rookie list (though Macreadie a risk I guess), and delist Moore which opens up 3 senior spots for the draft.

That seems about right. Anyone else we add would need a player moved on, Graham/Narkle for Kennedy is straightforward, then potentially a call on Jack, LOB, Dow depending on Saad and/or other targets.

From both a list management and culture perspective It's the right move and message to upgrade Gibbons. The bloke has played almost every game the past 2 years.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Player 'A' plays for your club - he is automatically a 20% better play than he is (until he is a scapegoat then he become 20% worse than what he is)
Player 'B' plays for opposition club - he is automatically 20% worse than he is until he becomes so good you cant deny it anymore.......until he becomes overated.

Not sure that applies around here lately. The board is fairly split in valuing or devaluing our own.

There are a heap of opposition players we seem to love around here who haven't shown anywhere near enough as well. Caldwell is a prime example.

I think it's just different perceptions based on discussions we get involved in, but the truth is probably somewhere in the middle.

 

[HavUEvaSeenTheRain]

Have North still got their third? If so that pick would be about 40 which sounds all most spot on

 

[I bleed Blue]

If he goes to Norf, Ill buy 1 less Blues membership in 2021 and direct that money into a norf membership; and I'll feel friggin great about doing it. Come at me.

Take a breath.

I'll be pretty down if JSOS leaves... but no one is bigger than the club.

 

[I bleed Blue]

Good to see its begun already

Round 23: Geez not much in the reserves to cover the 4 blokes who are playing crap
Off Season: We are a couple of players from being a premiership side
Round 1: Geez its so tough to make a round 1 side, we have so much depth.
Following rnd 1 loss to tigers: we are a rabble.

Its funny because it's true.

That beautiful hope of trade period and the offseason certainly gets us to bust out our rose coloured glasses

 

[Brackets]

From both a list management and culture perspective It's the right move and message to upgrade Gibbons. The bloke has played almost every game the past 2 years.

Fair point, but likely limits our ability to move Macreadie to a rookie spot, in which case may be forced to move him on if we need to free up places.

 

[Arr0w]

Sam Skinner from Brisbane should be cheap...

But I like Macreadie (if only he could play)

Plenty of short term back ups, to cover an injury and allow Macreadie to develop

 

[Macca43]

Definitely could be, Macca. I think he could be worth that mid-2nd rounder if a club were desperate, which North are.

Looking at the landscape of the trade period last year - 3rd talls and KPFs went fairly cheaply. Patton for a 2020 4th round (injuries and needed to get rid of salary so understandable), Jenkins for basically 37, and Bruce for 32+51. So I do think Jack can between 30-40 and reason being is his versatility to play numerous positions unlike the 3 above. If he goes, I’d say a good result if we net that.

Were any of those contracted?

 

[Brackets]

Good to see its begun already

Round 23: Geez not much in the reserves to cover the 4 blokes who are playing crap
Off Season: We are a couple of players from being a premiership side
Round 1: Geez its so tough to make a round 1 side, we have so much depth.
Following rnd 1 loss to tigers: we are a rabble.

Round 6: It's all finally clicked - lid is off.

 

[Opine]

Take a breath.

I'll be pretty down if JSOS leaves... but no one is bigger than the club.

Thats bloody good advice IBB; and fair enough 2. We each respond in our own way. That's just my way

 

[Aphrodite]

If he goes to Norf, Ill buy 1 less Blues membership in 2021 and direct that money into a norf membership; and I'll feel friggin great about doing it. Come at me.

That would take their M/ship tally to 11.

 

[Opine]

That would take their M/ship tally to 11.

psml

 

[Aphrodite]

I reckon his value is pick 53

Is that because #Dodorotrades nominated JSOS at pick 53.

 

[BluesTragic]

Wow,
I can’t believe how many pages have been clogged up with posts about Jack Silvagni.....
I hope the CFC still manages to survive if he leaves !!!!!!

 

[FRUMPY]

Not sure that applies around here lately. The board is fairly split in valuing or devaluing our own.

There are a heap of opposition players we seem to love around here who haven't shown anywhere near enough as well. Caldwell is a prime example.

I think it's just different perceptions based on discussions we get involved in, but the truth is probably somewhere in the middle.

Unproven first round draft picks are always rated gold around here. But its players who arent up for trade and are players 15-25 on other clubs lists that people on here ridicule or downplay how good they are. Same as oppositon supporters do to other clubs.

Its the same how every team thinks the other team gets a good ride with the umpires.......ill give you a tip - every supporter thins their team gets dudded by the umpires

 

[Stamos]

Its the same how every team thinks the other team gets a good ride with the umpires.......ill give you a tip - every supporter thins their team gets dudded by the umpires

Surely not Dogs supporters?

 

[FRUMPY]

Round 6: It's all finally clicked - lid is off.

Is that quarter or half time against hawthorn? PUT THE LID BACK ON!!!!!

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Unproven first round draft picks are always rated gold around here. But its players who arent up for trade and are players 15-25 on other clubs lists that people on here ridicule or downplay how good they are. Same as oppositon supporters do to other clubs.

Its the same how every team thinks the other team gets a good ride with the umpires.......ill give you a tip - every supporter thins their team gets dudded by the umpires

The reality is all teams get dudded by umpires so they're all right.

I rate plenty of opposition players who are fringe best 22 for their teams.

 

[FRUMPY]

Surely not Dogs supporters?

Every supporter.

I remember as a kid watching footy at the ground and i would always lament why the game is always played on the other side of the ground where im sitting, not realising that im so enthralled when the game is played on my side that i dont notice where its being played.

Its like gameday for umpire bashers - they only remember the dodgy free kicks we gave away or didnt give away. They dont remember the ones we got or got away with.

 

[Stamos]

The reality is all teams get dudded by umpires so they're all right.

Footscray? West Coast? Brisbane at the Gabba?

 

[FRUMPY]

The reality is all teams get dudded by umpires so they're all right.

I rate plenty of opposition players who are fringe best 22 for their teams.

It was a general consensus on this board and all other boards, not aimed at any individual.

 

[Stamos]

Every supporter.

I remember as a kid watching footy at the ground and i would always lament why the game is always played on the other side of the ground where im sitting, not realising that im so enthralled when the game is played on my side that i dont notice where its being played.

Its like gameday for umpire bashers - they only remember the dodgy free kicks we gave away or didnt give away. They dont remember the ones we got or got away with.

Surely even the Dogs supporters know they chuck it with impunity? And they got given an armchair ride for their 2nd flag?

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

It was a general consensus on this board and all other boards, not aimed at any individual.

I find that to be a side effect of watching our games and not watching enough of other games. If you see an opposition player do well against us, or do poorly about us, opinions are formed that may not be reflective on how they've gone against 16 others clubs.

I'm starting to widen my appreciation for other teams' players this year as I've seen more games. I've even staked a claim on some youngsters before they really took off.

Posters should be a little less definitive in whether they want or don't want a player based on limited viewings.