List Mgmt. 2020 Trade and List Management Thread III

[Del191229]

Well, he is being talked about as pick 1 as well, we've just got no f***ing idea what Adelaide are gonna do.

I reckon Adelaide ... who have a a major hole at full forward ... will pick him.

But the way he's being talked about, there shouldn't be any dispute on that.

 

[blackshadow]

I reckon Adelaide ... who have a a major hole at full forward ... will pick him.

But the way he's being talked about, there shouldn't be any dispute on that.

You'd think so.

I'll be rapt with Holland or DBG at #2.

 

[Del191229]

You'd think so.

I'll be rapt with Holland or DBG at #2.

Hollands, Hollands, Hollands.

 

[New_Roo]

You would defend him as I think you’re the same person

I think I liked jmac marginally more!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[The Filth Wizard]

I reckon Adelaide ... who have a a major hole at full forward ... will pick him.

But the way he's being talked about, there shouldn't be any dispute on that.

I think so too but who knows with that club nowadays. It'd be funny to see some more supporter melts for them to reach for somebody (even Thilthorpe who is logical for them isn't what their fans seem to want).

 

[Kanga Glory]

So the crows are on a promise not to pick ugle-hanan at pick 1 !!!


Dogs, Crows pick up

JAY CLARK

THE Western Bulldogs and Adelaide could strike a pick swap that would help both clubs’ draft positions.
The Dogs have pick No.14 and are open to trading it as the selection will be absorbed by the club’s bid for freakish forward and next generation academy member Jamarra Ugle-Hagan.
Adelaide has picks 22 and 23 and could hand them both to the Dogs for No.14.
It would suit Adelaide’s desire to move higher up the draft order to get its hands on another top talent as part of the club’s rebuild.
It would also bolster the Dogs’ points balance for the Ugle-Hagan bid.
Pick 14 is worth only 1161 points whereas nabbing No.22 and No.23 from the Crows is worth 1660 to the Dogs.
To even out the pick swap the Dogs could give Adelaide their second pick, No.41, which is worth 220 points.
The Dogs would also hope the Crows do not bid on Ugle-Hagan at pick No.1, which would save the Dogs as many as 500 points on the bid.
North Melbourne (No.2), Sydney (No.3) and Hawthorn (No.4) are the next in line in the national draft order.

 

[Snake_Baker]

So the crows are on a promise not to pick ugle-hanan at pick 1 !!!

This seems to be a logical conclusion to me.

 

[King Hansen]

Pick 14 is worth only 1161 points whereas nabbing No.22 and No.23 from the Crows is worth 1660 to the Dogs.

I'd rather take 22 & 23 into the draft than just 14.

 

[DuckYeah]

I reckon Adelaide ... who have a a major hole at full forward ... will pick him.

But the way he's being talked about, there shouldn't be any dispute on that.

They have major holes everywhere

 

[G0ther00s]

I’m torn on whether North should trade the pick down or not. I don’t believe they will.
Option 1 and potential outcomes
- Keep the pick and he turns into a superstar
- Keep the pick and he turns into a bust


Option 2 and potential outcomes
- Trade down to 6 and 7 and draft two really good players
- Trade down to 6 and 7 and draft one really good player and one bust
- Trade down to 6 and 7 and draft two busts

6 and 7 are just examples of what we could potentially get.

Out of the two options with their potential outcomes what are we most willing to live with?

 

[darko]

I'm only thinking Adelaide takes Thilthorpe because he's a local kid and they've lost tons of players over the years with this whole go home factor.

 

[koshari]

how about dutchy hollands and sam berry if he is still around for our godees pick?

 

[darko]

I'd rather take 22 & 23 into the draft than just 14.

I wouldn't. We need quality over quantity.

 

[krakouers]

I'm only thinking Adelaide takes Thilthorpe because he's a local kid and they've lost tons of players over the years with this whole go home factor.

McDonald has family in SA, he’s a pretty safe bet for them

 

[Merlin007]

This seems to be a logical conclusion to me.

indeed, but close to draft tampering surely?

 

[darko]

McDonald has family in SA, he’s a pretty safe bet for them

His close family is in WA.

Then again go home factor isn't big between WA and SA.

 

[darko]

indeed, but close to draft tampering surely?

It is but how do you prove it?

 

[Heaps of fun]

I'm only thinking Adelaide takes Thilthorpe because he's a local kid and they've lost tons of players over the years with this whole go home factor.

Adelaide has never been conservative with their drafting and I'd doubt they'd change their process now when pick 1 is in their hands. If they take Thilthorpe it'll be because they rate him the best player in the draft.

 

[Joycey]

Five goals in the 2017 prelim, turn it up Joyces.

On SM-G950F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Yeah a once off. Thanks for proving my point. He was flakey at best.

Majak once kicked 4 in a final too.

Prior to that game his previous multiple goal game was in RD10 against Freo. RD10 - Prelim...a lot of time between drinks for a player that was second fiddle to betts and largely a stay at home forward pocket.

The general consensus at the time was Brisbane paid overs for him. Then he really came into his own and he has been very consistent. Good on him. He put in the work.

 

[Kanga Glory]

we keep pick 2, i wouldn't be trading it

 

[King Hansen]

I wouldn't. We need quality over quantity.

We need to turn the list over A LOT. So we need quantity too. A draft like this where apparently it's even from 15-30, I'd rather 22 & 23.

 

[LB2Snake]

So the crows are on a promise not to pick ugle-hanan at pick 1 !!!


Dogs, Crows pick up

JAY CLARK

THE Western Bulldogs and Adelaide could strike a pick swap that would help both clubs’ draft positions.
The Dogs have pick No.14 and are open to trading it as the selection will be absorbed by the club’s bid for freakish forward and next generation academy member Jamarra Ugle-Hagan.
Adelaide has picks 22 and 23 and could hand them both to the Dogs for No.14.
It would suit Adelaide’s desire to move higher up the draft order to get its hands on another top talent as part of the club’s rebuild.
It would also bolster the Dogs’ points balance for the Ugle-Hagan bid.
Pick 14 is worth only 1161 points whereas nabbing No.22 and No.23 from the Crows is worth 1660 to the Dogs.
To even out the pick swap the Dogs could give Adelaide their second pick, No.41, which is worth 220 points.
The Dogs would also hope the Crows do not bid on Ugle-Hagan at pick No.1, which would save the Dogs as many as 500 points on the bid.
North Melbourne (No.2), Sydney (No.3) and Hawthorn (No.4) are the next in line in the national draft order.

Crows tried to actively “assist” saints in their offer to crouch to get themselves band 1......so if ya think for one minute they aren’t using the leverage of promises to not bid on JUH you’d be wrong. There would be all sorts of deals on the table.

 

[Heaps of fun]

So the crows are on a promise not to pick ugle-hanan at pick 1 !!!


Dogs, Crows pick up

JAY CLARK

THE Western Bulldogs and Adelaide could strike a pick swap that would help both clubs’ draft positions.
The Dogs have pick No.14 and are open to trading it as the selection will be absorbed by the club’s bid for freakish forward and next generation academy member Jamarra Ugle-Hagan.
Adelaide has picks 22 and 23 and could hand them both to the Dogs for No.14.
It would suit Adelaide’s desire to move higher up the draft order to get its hands on another top talent as part of the club’s rebuild.
It would also bolster the Dogs’ points balance for the Ugle-Hagan bid.
Pick 14 is worth only 1161 points whereas nabbing No.22 and No.23 from the Crows is worth 1660 to the Dogs.
To even out the pick swap the Dogs could give Adelaide their second pick, No.41, which is worth 220 points.
The Dogs would also hope the Crows do not bid on Ugle-Hagan at pick No.1, which would save the Dogs as many as 500 points on the bid.
North Melbourne (No.2), Sydney (No.3) and Hawthorn (No.4) are the next in line in the national draft order.

All this bidding and academy shit invites so much potential for draft tampering that it should be discarded for that alone.

 

[Luke72]

This seems to be a logical conclusion to me.

If they have agreed not to bid that would need to be compensated you would think.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Still can’t believe afl haven’t finalised list size and cap size

so much strategy revolves around that yet we likely won’t know till after trade period