List Mgmt. 2022 List Management and trading thread

[Scorpus]

I saw this format on the West Coast board and thought it might help understand our current list position

 

[Bearded Clam]

There’s a few key forwards in this years draft

none of which will be ready to go next year..

takes a couple of years, sometimes more, before they start actually performing well enough..

 

[Bearded Clam]

Re: next year hoping we’re getting him to tank and come across more “injured” Keeler to replace Fogarty if traded

Straight swap with Pies - Fogarty > < Poulter

again..

fogarty doesnt have to go anywhere.. he’s contracted.

and how do you know Poulter wants to leave the pies?

all this trade players against their will talk is, and always has been, fanciful bullshit.

 

[Mutineer]

again..

fogarty doesnt have to go anywhere.. he’s contracted.

and how do you know Poulter wants to leave the pies?

all this trade players against their will talk is, and always has been, fanciful bullshit.

That I can agree with...them play stations really get a work out on Big Footy hey...

 

[GreyCrow]

Lemmey if available at our pick we can’t overlook

He will be our Ace of Spades

 

[Danger in Texas]

Poulter seems like wishful thinking at this point, particularly if he gets back in the Pies’ side later this season and does well

I don’t think Fogarty looking for more opportunity is a stretch, though, if we say to him ‘you’re not gonna be getting that many games at all next year’. If a club gives him a deal until 2024 and greater opportunity, he probably takes it

 

[Viva la Mattner]

again..

fogarty doesnt have to go anywhere.. he’s contracted.

and how do you know Poulter wants to leave the pies?

all this trade players against their will talk is, and always has been, fanciful bullshit.

Makes sense

• Fog goes gets more game time
• Poulter- see above

Fill a need for both teams

 

[Dewy006]

again..

fogarty doesnt have to go anywhere.. he’s contracted.

and how do you know Poulter wants to leave the pies?

all this trade players against their will talk is, and always has been, fanciful bullshit.

Come the end of the season and Fog hasn’t broken back into the Seniors for an extended period it would be malpractice by his management to not put feelers out and see if anyone can offer him a starting 22 spot.

It might be Fog bringing to us a trade request to move for greater opportunity. Happens all the time across the league. Now what we would get in return I agree with you. It would be 2/5ths of stuff all.

 

[rubbers0ul]

WDay? JLukosius? TToranto? KAmon?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Viva la Mattner]

Will Day? - sadly contracted
Jack Lukosius? - Port bound by reports, will cost too much
Tim Toranto? - unlikely heads to SA
Karl Amon? - ties to St.Kilda he’ll end up there


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Gtowncrow]

What are those weapons?
The only thing he has over Laird is more height, but he still doesn’t have better inside numbers.

More creative play maker. Better vision when under pressure.
That said, I'm not bagging Laird, just giving my opinion of the two.

 

[Sanders]

PlayStation out of mothballs early this year

 

[FR0GGY]

PlayStation out of mothballs early this year

It’s school holidays

 

[Mego Red]

That I can agree with...them play stations really get a work out on Big Footy hey...

You say a lot of good stuff on here - but responding to every trade suggestion with "pLaYsTaTiOn tRaDe" is really the most pointless, closed minded thing you post.

If you don't want to discuss trades, ignore the posts where people suggest them.

Multiple contracted players get traded every single year.

 

[Mego Red]

Poulter seems like wishful thinking at this point, particularly if he gets back in the Pies’ side later this season and does well

I don’t think Fogarty looking for more opportunity is a stretch, though, if we say to him ‘you’re not gonna be getting that many games at all next year’. If a club gives him a deal until 2024 and greater opportunity, he probably takes it

Poulter isn't getting games - he's getting less opportunity this year than Fogarty has.

 

[Mego Red]

PlayStation out of mothballs early this year

Do you have anything to offer?

 

[Sanders]

Do you have anything to offer?

Suggest EBay, if you want to sell your vintage gaming console.

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

none of which will be ready to go next year..

takes a couple of years, sometimes more, before they start actually performing well enough..

And? We would have 4 talls who are afl ready. A draftee could still play 10-15 games.

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

More creative play maker. Better vision when under pressure.
That said, I'm not bagging Laird, just giving my opinion of the two.

Based on what? Dunkley isn’t the player you think he is.

 

[AFC979810]

Its Completely unrealistic - but here is my list of players we should target.

1. De Goey - throw the check book at him. Highly unlikely he will want to go to Adelaide. But it's a dream. Is the exact player our list lacks and needs.

2. Dunkley - Use a bit less cash than we throw at De Goey.

3. Rankine - Talented, but unsure whether he will want it enough. Worth the risk though. Pairing him and Rachele

4. Luko - Has slipped down a little, more based on the emergence of Frampton, Himmelberg and Gollant. I would still love to have him, especially if he stays hurt all year and the trade costs less.

5. Francis - Worth the risk. Hugely talented, but obviously mental health issues have been a limiting factor. A move to SA might be enough to re-invegorate his career. Will be 25 when the 2023 season starts so he fits perfectly into our list age profile.

 

[Sanders]

Its Completely unrealistic - but here is my list of players we should target.

1. De Goey - throw the check book at him. Highly unlikely he will want to go to Adelaide. But it's a dream. Is the exact player our list lacks and needs.

2. Dunkley - Use a bit less cash than we throw at De Goey.

3. Rankine - Talented, but unsure whether he will want it enough. Worth the risk though. Pairing him and Rachele

4. Luko - Has slipped down a little, more based on the emergence of Frampton, Himmelberg and Gollant. I would still love to have him, especially if he stays hurt all year and the trade costs less.

5. Francis - Worth the risk. Hugely talented, but obviously mental health issues have been a limiting factor. A move to SA might be enough to re-invegorate his career. Will be 25 when the 2023 season starts so he fits perfectly into our list age profile.

Let’s be more adventurous. This is a list of impossibles, and SA recycles and retreads.

We need quality through the middle, who might fit the bill?

 

[CrowsB4hoes]

Let’s be more adventurous. This is a list of impossibles, and SA recycles and retreads.

We need quality through the middle, who might fit the bill?

No such thing as impossibles. I’d ask the question of Rowell and Anderson, Green and Ash.

Let’s see who GC/GWS love more and focus in on the other. Pay a couple first rounders to get them in.

 

[Danger in Texas]

Let’s be more adventurous. This is a list of impossibles, and SA recycles and retreads.

We need quality through the middle, who might fit the bill?

No-one realistic, tbh, unless we delve into contracted players

Parfitt maybe, but I’ve cooled on him

 

[AFC979810]

Let’s be more adventurous. This is a list of impossibles, and SA recycles and retreads.

We need quality through the middle, who might fit the bill?

The way I see it we are limited to the following:

SA ties - Betts, Dawson, Thompson.

Rejected out of staters - Lynch, Jenkins, Seedsman, Keays, Jacobs.

Occasional offer to superstar - Carey, Cameron (unsuccessful).

 

[Danger in Texas]

The way I see it we are limited to the following:

SA ties - Betts, Dawson, Thompson.

Rejected out of staters - Lynch, Jenkins, Seedsman, Keays, Jacobs.

Occasional offer to superstar - Carey, Cameron (unsuccessful).

Jacobs and Seedsman weren’t ‘rejected’, from what I remember. The rest you have right, I think

 

[AFC979810]

Jacobs and Seedsman weren’t ‘rejected’, from what I remember. The rest you have right, I think

Its a long time ago, but I thought that Jacobs was in a massive competition for the 2nd ruck job at Carlton. They had Kruezer as their #1 with Warnock, Hampson and Jacobs fighting it out for 2nd Ruck duties.

Seedsman also wasn't entrenched at Collingwood. Played a combined 21 games in 2014/2015 before the Pies accepted pick 32 for him.

Perhaps Rejected was a little harsh, maybe slightly undesirable is a better term.