Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[lids2richo]

Crips v Dawson

 

[JuddgementDay]

Crisp vs Sinclair..

Not much between them.

Decide based on your byes

Crisp for me, as you probably got too many RD12 defenders already

 

[rocker_oz33]

Decide based on your byes

Crisp for me, as you probably got too many RD12 defenders already

I get 3 weeks of out of Crispy b4 bye...

Only 50 points different between the two..

Both top 8 mids IMO.

 

[Soggy2112]

Stewart vs Sinclair vs Dawson.

None have the R14 bye so bye planning isn’t a factor at this stage for me.

 

[Petrify]

Mills vs Laird as my final mid. Bye isn't a factor

 

[Scythe]

Mills vs Laird as my final mid. Bye isn't a factor

Much of a muchness IMO. If you want consistency, Laird, if you want an excellent VC option who can go enormous, Mills.

I've went the latter.

 

[JyeDye]

Mills vs Laird as my final mid. Bye isn't a factor

Probably average similar. Mills more VC option with higher ceiling.

Biggest split here is watchability which has nothing to do with supercoach. Do you want to watch Mills bite of a risky corridor kick which leads to one of the teams kicking a goal. Can your heart take an 80 point quarter to only watch his score go backwards for the next one? Or do you want to go to sleep early watching Laird rack up 25 useless handballs to Keays to just dump kick for his 120 points.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Stewart vs Sinclair vs Dawson.

None have the R14 bye so bye planning isn’t a factor at this stage for me.

All good choices .

I think you listed them in order .

You'll want at least 2 of those.
But plenty of def premo s this year.

 

[Soggy2112]

All good choices .

I think you listed them in order .

You'll want at least 2 of those.
But plenty of def premo s this year.

I think Stewart is the best, just not sure he’s the best pick at his price right now

 

[rocker_oz33]

I think Stewart is the best, just not sure he’s the best pick at his price right now

Sinclair prob the best value ..

 

[balmainforever]

Walsh vs Laird

 

[THECHIEFTON]

Walsh vs Laird

Walsh

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Walsh vs Laird

Laird

Less competition for points at Adelaide
Walsh is great but any of those blue mids could pop off in any given week

Laird is a 1 man army for the crows in that midfield scoring wise, especially with no Matt crouch and now Keays scoring fading

 

[T4P]

With Bont and Smith likely getting DPP status. The real question is, how many dogs players are too many?

I'm pretty set on three, and will trade in Bont to have Dunk - Smith - Bont.

 

[Johnson Geoffrey]

Walsh to finish midfield?
OR
Stewart to finish defence??

What do we think? (getting Walsh helps my Rd 13 but I don't necessarily want the byes to decide my picks)

 

[Judd_Magic]

Walsh vs Laird

Jelly.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Jelly.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Walsh vs Laird

When undecided, choose a player from a team that will win more games - easy!

 

[Tulendeena]

Keep SDK or McCartin for the rest of the year?

 

[Gia77]

Keep SDK or McCartin for the rest of the year?

Trade both when good rookie options become available ie Cleary this week (pending bye management)

 

[St Steady]

Keep SDK or McCartin for the rest of the year?

same dilema, im leaning to keeping paddy

 

[Tulendeena]

Trade both when good rookie options become available ie Cleary this week (pending bye management)

Cleary has very dodgy JS longterm, and i just want a D7 with decent JS

D7 I think will be an issue post-byes, we don't really have D/M rookies like in the past and the defensive rookies past SDK/McCartin are dogwater
Not taking one through will be a big risk IMO

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Keep SDK or McCartin for the rest of the year?

I'm going to try and hold SdK. Rock solid JS and doesn't have the concussion risk that McCartin does.

 

[Gia77]

I'm going to try and hold SdK. Rock solid JS and doesn't have the concussion risk that McCartin does.

Ive to Skinner as well so will hold SdK and use him at D/F7 when needed whilst cashing in McCartin for $$$

 

[weltschmerz]

Keep SDK or McCartin for the rest of the year?

I'm probably trading both durng their bye round.