Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[DaTBird187]

Are you sure?

View attachment 1317719

That's a Choose your own Adventure Book.

Choice one, you get an autograph and go home happy. Choice two and you end up dead in a hotel room.

 

[VainGlorious]

That's a Choose your own Adventure Book.

Choice one, you get an autograph and go home happy. Choice two and you end up dead in a hotel room.

 

[VainGlorious]

Ok seriously though peeps:

Rowell V Berry V Fin V JHF.

Will post puppies.

 

[Flandersss]

Ok seriously though peeps:

Rowell V Berry V Fin V JHF.

Will post puppies.

Berry

 

[buttox]

Ok seriously though peeps:

Rowell V Berry V Fin V JHF.

Will post puppies.

I think it depends on the rest of your team
If it is for m5
Berry-Rowell-JHF-Macrae
If it is for m6
JHF-Macrae-Berry-Rowell.

 

[VainGlorious]

I think it depends on the rest of your team
If it is for m5
Berry-Rowell-JHF-Macrae
If it is for m6
JHF-Macrae-Berry-Rowell.

It’s for M5

I’ve had Rowell @ M5 since the team picker became available, purely based on those 3 matches in his first season and potential. 141, 114 and 171 for a first year player is absurd - the injuries, awkwardish price, and an odd 2021 campaign have me second-guessing him though.

And Gold Coast are poo.

 

[buttox]

It’s for M5

I’ve had Rowell @ M5 since the team picker became available, purely based on those 3 matches in his first season and potential. 141, 114 and 171 for a first year player is absurd - the injuries, awkwardish price, and an odd 2021 campaign have me second-guessing him though.

And Gold Coast are poo.

You wont be able to make a decision until the pre season games on all 4 of the guys you mentioned.
You are on the right track though all should be decent.

 

[VainGlorious]

You are on the right track though all should be decent.

You’re absolutely right friendo

 

[St Steady]

rioli (D6) and walsh vs milera (D6) and jmcrae

 

[buttox]

rioli and walsh vs milera and jmcrae

Macrae is a must have.
The others are not.
I think I would take a rookie over Milera though.

 

[Flandersss]

rioli and walsh vs milera and jmcrae

Rioli & Walsh (I think Rioli could potentially be a D6/F6 keeper 90 avg)

 

[King Max]

D4 Short/Ridley and F2 Heneey.
OR
D4 Sicily and F2 Duncan/Taranto.

 

[Lord De Goey]

D4 Short/Ridley and F2 Heneey.
OR
D4 Sicily and F2 Duncan/Taranto.

Sicily and Duncan

 

[Skipper_]

fwd rookie and Sicily vs def rookie and Heeney

 

[WaynesWorld19]

fwd rookie and Sicily vs def rookie and Heeney

fwd rookie and Sicily

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Touk vs Oliver vs titch

 

[Northernsoul74]

Touk vs Oliver vs titch

Oliver. I wonder if a fit and firing Rowell just skims a bit off Touks ceiling. Touk already appears at his likely max price.

 

[St Steady]

Sicily v anyone a bit dearer or a bit cheaper

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Sicily v anyone a bit dearer or a bit cheaper

What range we talking?

If up to Whitfield
Whitfield over Sicily

Under Sicily I don’t like anyone bar hewett. Rioli/Coleman are also decent d/f options or go down to a rookie

 

[kool kangas]

Thinking of swapping F. Macrae for C.Curnow. Any thoughts?

 

[St Steady]

heres an interesting one for this thread

macrae and preuss v rowell and grundy (905k or 970k the combo)

rowell would be m5 , rucks would be darcy/preuss or darcy/grundy

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

heres an interesting one for this thread

macrae and preuss v rowell and grundy (905k or 970k the combo)

rowell would be m5 , rucks would be darcy/preuss or darcy/grundy

Macrae is the first player picked imo.

A different SP mid makes it an actual choice. (I think Preuss is a trap though for what it's worth)

 

[Lord De Goey]

Dawson v Short

I feel like Dawson makes more sense as an upgrade target but I also think he has more upside than Short

 

[Duckworthy]

Macrae is the first player picked imo.

A different SP mid makes it an actual choice. (I think Preuss is a trap though for what it's worth)

1000%

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Dawson v Short

I feel like Dawson makes more sense as an upgrade target but I also think he has more upside than Short

Watch the pre season game on Dawson
Apparently going to get inside time

I want to see how that plays out before I pick him. He’s in the mix and could go 100+

Short we know what we’ll get
22 games at 95+
It’s a matter of the safe pick or the upside pick. Short I actually see averaging 100+ In 2022 but Dawson could go even higher.

Monitor the pre season reports