Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Hawkboy62]

Curnow or JHF?

 

[VainGlorious]

Curnow or JHF?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Curnow or JHF?

Depends where you need a rookie most. Forward line is likely to be harder to fill.

JHF will be very high ownership (currently 51% vs Curnow 24% which will be higher by round one)

Probably both tbh.

 

[weltschmerz]

Serong and Maginness, or Rowell and Rayner?

 

[rocker_oz33]

Serong and Maginness, or Rowell and Rayner?

R n R .

 

[rocker_oz33]

Depends where you need a rookie most. Forward line is likely to be harder to fill.

JHF will be very high ownership (currently 51% vs Curnow 24% which will be higher by round one)

Probably both tbh.

Hopefully 4 forward wookies 2 and 2 .

 

[rocker_oz33]

View attachment 1320571

That gif is gold.

 

[weltschmerz]

Hopefully 4 forward wookies 2 and 2 .

 

[Northernsoul74]

Serong and Maginness, or Rowell and Rayner?

R and R. Serong price is no man’s land and Maginess is no guarantee to make the Hawthorn team.

 

[weltschmerz]

R&R substitution made.

JHF or Caldwell? JHF seems a safer option while Caldwell could score higher but could also ping a hamstrig immediately.

 

[buttox]

R&R substitution made.

JHF or Caldwell? JHF seems a safer option while Caldwell could score higher but could also ping a hamstrig immediately.

Caldwells highest score is 84 in 3 years.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

R&R substitution made.

JHF or Caldwell? JHF seems a safer option while Caldwell could score higher but could also ping a hamstrig immediately.

No to Caldwell ....that's not an endorsement of JHF though

Having Rookies around $200K is difficult, as it impacts other aspects of your team .....this year 3 x mids; JHF, Ward, and Daicos ......going by their junior fantasy scores, Ward and Daicos are my preferred Rookies at that sort of price

 

[weltschmerz]

No to Caldwell ....that's not an endorsement of JHF though

Having Rookies around $200K is difficult, as it impacts over aspects of your team .....this year 3 x mids; JHF, Ward, and Daicos ......going by their junior fantasy scores, Ward and Daicos are my preferred Rookies at that sort of price

I do have Ward and Daicos. Maybe a Fin Macrae in that spot? Or shift Cogs to the midfield and find a 300k forward?

 

[buttox]

I do have Ward and Daicos. Maybe a Fin Macrae in that spot? Or shift Cogs to the midfield and find a 300k forward?

Post your team in the teams thread and I will take a look.
You seem to be asking about a lot of mid pricers.
Playing a few rookies is not a bad thing.
That is how you make the cashola.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Caldwells highest score is 84 in 3 years.
View attachment 1320638

He played well Vs cats in praccy match before round one last year..

Still unknown .
What he can do .

 

[rocker_oz33]

No to Caldwell ....that's not an endorsement of JHF though

Having Rookies around $200K is difficult, as it impacts other aspects of your team .....this year 3 x mids; JHF, Ward, and Daicos ......going by their junior fantasy scores, Ward and Daicos are my preferred Rookies at that sort of price

Dil Stephens...maybe .
Swans look to be playing younger guys these days .

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Dil Stephens...maybe .
Swans look to be playing younger guys these days .

Stephens is very outside .....reading between the lines of quotes, when the Coach says "we want him bigger and stronger, we know he can run" .......my AFL Coach speak dictionary says that means they want Stephens to contest more

Now question is can he .....if not, he's not a viable SC option IMO

 

[buttox]

Rayner + 123k mid rookie
vs
Curnow + Ward.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Rayner + 123k mid rookie
vs
Curnow + Ward.

Too early to say. Hope this Ward kid is as good as he's been hyped up to be though.

 

[MacStradbroke]

Rayner + 123k mid rookie
vs
Curnow + Ward.

Curnow Ward easily for me…at this early stage. I have both and havent considered Rayner once.

Rayner too ‘burst’ for me as a SC option, Curnow though, if upright for long enough has massive tank so can accumulate quickly for a big fella. Goes alright at footy too!

 

[Mofra]

Defender rookie: Sinn $157.8k vs Kemp $156.8k?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Defender rookie: Sinn $157.8k vs Kemp $156.8k?

Kemp probably has more JS

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Defender rookie: Sinn $157.8k vs Kemp $156.8k?

Kemp seems likely to play, 3rd year player vs 1st year.

And you save $1,000.00

 

[Andrew Birch]

Defender rookie: Sinn $157.8k vs Kemp $156.8k?

I know Kemp hasn't played much, but still 3rd year vs 1st year.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Kemp seems likely to play, 3rd year player vs 1st year.

And you save $1,000.00

I know Kemp hasn't played much, but still 3rd year vs 1st year.