Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[JuddgementDay]

Gee. That really cleared things up. Thanks

Witherden

 

[rocker_oz33]

If Trac plays, then Trac for me.

Hawkins v Duncan v Treloar v De Goey

Not Duncan. Only getting 80s .

Prob Figjam degoey.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Gee. That really cleared things up. Thanks

 

[Deliverance]

If Trac plays, then Trac for me.

Hawkins v Duncan v Treloar v De Goey

Degoey.
Get Hawkins when they start their run of games at Kardinia Park.

 

[Juzzomac]

Sicily v Pendles.

(Need R12 bye defender).

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Sicily v Pendles.

(Need R12 bye defender).

Doubt there is much between them scoring wise over the season.

Depends whether you want a POD or not for SC finals.

 

[Quazza]

Super Sexy Patty C/Vlaustin/Sam Hayes(on field)
v
Super Sexy Patty C/Preuss/Sam Hayes (On bench) + 130k

 

[Dalsantowhatastar]

Tom Mitchell vs Petracca?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Super Sexy Patty C/Vlaustin/Sam Hayes(on field)
v
Super Sexy Patty C/Preuss/Sam Hayes (On bench) + 130k

Second one. You've missed Flosstones best score. He tends to have a few bigs games a season but won't average as much as other defenders.

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Tom Mitchell vs Petracca?

don't like either if you want a guaranteed top 8

Mitchell's role has changed and Petracca seems to be managing a knee issue

can you reach Brayshaw/Parish/Walsh?

 

[Northernsoul74]

don't like either if you want a guaranteed top 8

Mitchell's role has changed and Petracca seems to be managing a knee issue

can you reach Brayshaw/Parish/Walsh?

Not sure Parish gets up for this weeks game. Coach didn’t sound positive today.

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Not sure Parish gets up for this weeks game. Coach didn’t sound positive today.

ah yeah forgot about his ankle

 

[rocker_oz33]

don't like either if you want a guaranteed top 8

Mitchell's role has changed and Petracca seems to be managing a knee issue

can you reach Brayshaw/Parish/Walsh?

Trac still avg 30 touches .
Same AVG as parish .

Tracc way more dangerous than parish ..aswell.

Parish under an inj aswell.

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Trac still avg 30 touches .
Same AVG as parish .

Tracc way more dangerous than parish ..aswell.

Parish under an inj aswell.

forgot about the Parish ankle - want to see Trac turn his form around before I consider him, his price isn't going to jump dramatically

 

[rocker_oz33]

forgot about the Parish ankle - want to see Trac turn his form around before I consider him, his price isn't going to jump dramatically

Green another option ...

 

[Dalsantowhatastar]

don't like either if you want a guaranteed top 8

Mitchell's role has changed and Petracca seems to be managing a knee issue

can you reach Brayshaw/Parish/Walsh?

If I trade JHF instead of Rachele then I can grab Brayshaw/Oliver/Keays or pretty much anyone other than Mills.

Was preferring to keep JHF however...

 

[TempletonTheRat]

If I trade JHF instead of Rachele then I can grab Brayshaw/Oliver/Keays or pretty much anyone other than Mills.

Was preferring to keep JHF however...

hmmm - best player to cull is Rachele - best player to bring in is Oliver

what other trades are you doing?

 

[Dalsantowhatastar]

hmmm - best player to cull is Rachele - best player to bring in is Oliver

what other trades are you doing?

Grundy -> Hayes and Xerri -> Parker

I could also go Xerri -> Heeney and JHF -> Green instead.

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Grundy -> Hayes and Xerri -> Parker

I could also go Xerri -> Heeney and JHF -> Green instead.

this is just my personal preference and other will see it differently

1st preference would be X > Rozee and Rachele > Oliver (rather take a risk in fwds than mids)

2nd X > Parker and JHF > Oliver

3rd X > Parker and Rachele > Trac

it would also depend a bit on how the rest of you team is set up.

 

[rocker_oz33]

this is just my personal preference and other will see it differently

1st preference would be X > Rozee and Rachele > Oliver (rather take a risk in fwds than mids)

2nd X > Parker and JHF > Oliver

3rd X > Parker and Rachele > Trac

it would also depend a bit on how the rest of you team is set up.

Trac b4 Green.....?

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Trac b4 Green.....?

don't know, I wouldn't get that far as I think Oliver should the target

Green looks the goods but can he keep it up full season + Leon. He may turn out to be a "foolproof" GWS gun

 

[rocker_oz33]

don't know, I wouldn't get that far as I think Oliver should the target

Green looks the goods but can he keep it up full season + Leon. He may turn out to be a "foolproof" GWS gun

Tracc more proven given he's older.

Just unsure on he's knee issues that keeps bobing up.

Green looking good tho..

 

[rocker_oz33]

1 ) Rosas and tracc or Green.

Vs .

2) Clark risky and Alicia keys .

 

[Soggy2112]

Deciding how to cover Hewett.

Option A

Rachele at M8
NOD at D5
Gibcus/Perez loophole at D6

Option B
Gibcus and Perez at D5 and 6
NOD/Rachele loop at M8

 

[zoomba23]

Tossing and turning over Sprayshaw v. Touk. Both seem destined to finish as top 12 avging mids, which is my realistic goal for my midfielders, if not top 8. Sprayshaw potentially still has his avg. score for the season inflated by that 189, but Touk with a BE of 130 isn't looking like a must have at the minute. Can't afford Steele and already have most of the usual suspects