List Mgmt. 2022 Trade, Draft, etc thread

[Scythe]

Dory_77 – might be worth pinning this? Gets updated after every move.

 

[LarryDavidNeitz]

If we’re into a proper winger that’s good. Bit worried about whether Hunter’s head is still in the game but he’d be perfect if he can play at his past standard.

I’ll be sad if Harmes goes but if he does I’d see Jordon as becoming our tagger and Sparrow picking up more midfield minutes.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Lemmey would be a good late round KPF target. Was highly rated but had his season ruined by injury. As a late pick he is boom or bust.

I like him mate, would probably prefer to draft him late round 1 than Jefferson with a top 10 pick. Very good ball user for his height, excellent set shot. Much like Jefferson though, he likely isn't doing much inside the first two years other than trying to put weight on.

So far on what ive seen:

Tier 1:

(1.Tsatas, likely gone before we are picking)

1. Sheezel
2. Cadman
3. Hewett

Tier 2:

4. MacKenzie
5. Phillipou

Tier 3:

=6. Jefferson
=6. Lemmy
8. Clark





Tier 28:

9.. Humphrey

 

[Fork n Hell]

Id love to get Cadman but id be very happy with JVR and Petty also, massive upgrade on the s**t we trotted out there this year.

Also, fire in the disco to the backline, exciting times. Very keen to see if Turner can take his opportunity.

me too, i just want to see more of Turner after the VFL GF when he smothered two players in a row, got the ball out of bounds, then got in the face of the oppo players like a huge campaigner and started a big fight with 5 minutes to go when the game was already in the bag. it was awesome!

 

[Scythe]

Would be pretty disappointing to lose Harmes. Must not be able to offer him enough to want to stay, would guess he’d take less than market so depends how apart the offers are.

Can’t stand Hunter, so fully expect he’ll be a Dee. Fluffing that running bounce on the wing was a GF highlight after he goal he kicked from ducking.

I'm pro the Hunter move, but picking up one of the league's best duckers just as the rules have changed feels a bit...Melbourney

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Hypothetically, I don't hate this for next year (would rather keep Harmes, but this is in the case we lose all of Harmes, Bedford, Tomlinson, Hunt):

FB: Hibberd May Lever
HB: Brayshaw Turner Bowey
C: Hunter Viney Langdon
HF: Fritsch Petty ANB
FF: Pickett Gawn JVR
RR: Grundy Oliver Petracca
IC: Rivers Spargo Salem Sparrow

May be a touch tall up front, but don't mind it

I very much hope we rotate the rucks off the bench.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

I'm pro the Hunter move, but picking up one of the league's best duckers just as the rules have changed feels a bit...Melbourney

Need to wash The Western off him.

 

[LittleG]

I like him mate, would probably prefer to draft him late round 1 than Jefferson with a top 10 pick. Very good ball user for his height, excellent set shot. Much like Jefferson though, he likely isn't doing much inside the first two years other than trying to put weight on.

So far on what ive seen:

Tier 1:

(1.Tsatas, likely gone before we are picking)

1. Sheezel
2. Cadman
3. Hewett

Tier 2:

4. MacKenzie
5. Phillipou

Tier 3:

=6. Jefferson
=6. Lemmy
8. Clark





Tier 28:

9.. Humphrey

I don’t have Lemmy in my top 30. He can be got later. Cadman, Jefferson, Sheezel, Hewitt; should be your targets early in the draft.

Why don’t you like Humphrey? He appears a solid medium forward / midfield option….

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

I don’t have Lemmy in my top 30. He can be got later. Cadman, Jefferson, Sheezel, Hewitt; should be your targets early in the draft.

Why don’t you like Humphrey? He appears a solid medium forward / midfield option….

Cant kick for shit, no burst from packs. The only elite thing he does to my eye is mark very well for his height.

We have enough inside mids and blokes who cant kick already.

If Lemmy is a pick after 30 hes a steal. Id very much hope we pick him up if hes there at that point. Excellent value, project with high upside.

 

[Topkent]

If you are paying all your draftees $300k then you won't have the cash to pay your top 24-30 year old players $1m a year and they are the ones which win games. Some players will take serious unders to try and win a premiership but plenty will go looking for their worth.

The difference we have here is that we pay so much money to kids for potential, the idea that Freo are going to pay Jackson $1m a year is insane, and realistically probably $250k - $300k a year more than what we were offering.

You don't pay all your draftees 300 lol you take the best one or 2 each year. You don't need to take 5-6 speculative ones. Plus there's like 50x bomber, pies and tigers supporters than Dees we would almost never get anyone good. It's just a stupid idea.

 

[Toump Ass]

Would be s**t to lose Harmes. He's not our best mid but arguably our most versatile. A very handy player to have who can tag, go forward (and actually be a goalkicking threat!), or win his own ball.

So handy!

Maybe I wasn't paying attention but I feel like we never took advantage of his strengths this year. Every game we lost bar Geelong we allowed teams to roll us over and do whatever they wanted, perfect time for Chompers to put a clamp on someone, didn't happen. or just plunk him in the forward line to see if he could "get on the end of a couple".

 

[CWaffles]

I don’t mind the Harmes move, has been a good player but we need to make tough decisions to make our team better and having a pure winger opposite Langdon is a good move.

We had way too many inside mids and just putting them on the wing and half forward just wasn’t working anymore.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

I don’t mind the Harmes move, has been a good player but we need to make tough decisions to make our team better and having a pure winger opposite Langdon is a good move.

We had way too many inside mids and just putting them on the wing and half forward just wasn’t working anymore.

Id have much preferred to keep Harmes over Viney honestly. Viney would net us a bigger return, Harmes can play a run with role (not many/if any else can) and a far better kick.

 

[Topkent]

**** Angus Brayshaw

10

Angus Brayshaw

Age

29

Ht

188cm

Wt

90kg

Pos.

D/M

Career

Season

Last 5

D

19.7

5star

K

11.1

4star

HB

8.6

5star

M

3.7

4star

T

4.3

5star

MG

233.5

4star

D

15.5

4star

K

7.7

3star

HB

7.8

4star

M

2.0

2star

T

3.2

4star

MG

233.5

4star

D

11.4

3star

K

8.2

4star

HB

3.2

3star

M

3.4

4star

T

5.6

5star

and his midfield demands. **** Clarry Trac and him for eating up all our midfield minutes and money. We barely made top 4, lose Jackson and still have to shed a bunch of depth to make the list balance.

I'd prefer Harmes over Gus as a mid, should have gone to Freo

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

* Angus Brayshaw and his midfield demands. * Clarry Trac and him for eating up all our midfield minutes and money. We barely made top 4, lose Jackson and still have to shed a bunch of depth to make the list balance.

I'd prefer Harmes over Gus as a mid, should have gone to Freo

I like the way you think Mr. Snrub

 

[Topkent]

I like the way you think Mr. Snrub

I think Gus Brayshaw can **** off

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

I think Gus Brayshaw can * off

He can **** off to half back or head on down to Casey if hes keen for midfield minutes.

Also, him and Gawn need a call in segment on the podcast. Id love to give him a call and ask him why hes so selfish.

 

[Brian_45]

Surely Harmes stays, he's been a Dees supporter his whole life. Lachie Hunter is slow, a dinky kick and a trouble maker off the field.. we should go nowhere near him.

 

[Topkent]

He can * off to half back or head on down to Casey if hes keen for midfield minutes.

Also, him and Gawn need a call in segment on the podcast. Id love to give him a call and ask him why hes so selfish.

Hey mate why did you go from being a superstar HBF to being another 30 disposal 0 impact inside mid. Is it because you're a selfish campaigner who wants Brownlow votes? So you can hold your best mates hand all game? Get stuffed ya helmet ****

 

[TheBoss]

Hypothetically, I don't hate this for next year (would rather keep Harmes, but this is in the case we lose all of Harmes, Bedford, Tomlinson, Hunt):

FB: Hibberd May Lever
HB: Brayshaw Turner Bowey
C: Hunter Viney Langdon
HF: Fritsch Petty ANB
FF: Pickett Gawn JVR
RR: Grundy Oliver Petracca
IC: Rivers Spargo Salem Sparrow

May be a touch tall up front, but don't mind it

If the plan is to swing Petty forward then I imagine that Gawn will spend more time playing as the spare in the back 50.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Surely Harmes stays, he's been a Dees supporter his whole life. Lachie Hunter is slow, a dinky kick and a trouble maker off the field.. we should go nowhere near him.

Probably the worst argument for Harmes staying and why we shouldn't bring Hunter in ive ever seen.

 

[schmuttt]

Will say Brayshaw contract is genuinely horrific if he plays midfield again next year. FMD he was so good at half back then we move him into the middle for another vanilla inside player

 

[TheBoss]

Surely Harmes stays, he's been a Dees supporter his whole life. Lachie Hunter is slow, a dinky kick and a trouble maker off the field.. we should go nowhere near him.

Harmes has 2 years left on his deal. He will be 28 at the start of his next contract which will be his last major payday, and playing out of position for MFC just hurts his value. He is better off going to a team that can give him minutes in his preferred role because he won't get a sniff at playing significant time on ball with our current personnel.

 

[Brian_45]

Probably the worst argument for Harmes staying and why we shouldn't bring Hunter in ive ever seen.

So you're saying Hunter is a long kick who has no issues off the field then? Have you ever watched a dogs game before?

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

So you're saying Hunter is a long kick who has no issues off the field then? Have you ever watched a dogs game before?

Give me a dinky kick that hits targets over JJ blasting it long down the line to absolutely no one. Have you ever watched a dees game before?

 

[Brian_45]

Give me a dinky kick that hits targets over JJ blasting it long down the line to absolutely no one. Have you ever watched a dees game before?

And to think you have spent so much time on this board... as long you're happy though I guess

You might wanna look at how many games Hunter has played over the last couple of years.