It's a major concern , they would have enough data to sink a ship and would know when they have seen enough.
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
List Mgmt. 2022 Trade Thread - Part III
- Thread starter Dard Ball Get
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Apr 24, 2021
- 11,561
- 19,413
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Absolutely get him to the clubSo we really need to bring in some mid depth. Hugely exposed last season.
Xavier O’Halloran, not contracted for next year, pick 22 in 2018.
Young Guns '21: Xavier O'Halloran
Xavier O'Halloran stepped into the limelight in 2021 and proved that hard work pays off for this versatile gun.www.gwsgiants.com.au
Looking at some of the contracts GWS have given there top players and they are just crazy
Josh Kelly is contracted till 2029 - he will be 35 when his contract is finished
Whitfield the contracted till 2027 , so he will be 33
They would have to get a couple of these off their books or they will suffer - the only thing they would have to pay some of the salary.
How have the AFL allowed these teams to make these contracts that will sink the team for years to come.
You can see a club doing it maybe for one or 2 players but they have Toby Greene and Coniglio on big contracts for another 4 yrs as well.
Josh Kelly is contracted till 2029 - he will be 35 when his contract is finished
Whitfield the contracted till 2027 , so he will be 33
They would have to get a couple of these off their books or they will suffer - the only thing they would have to pay some of the salary.
How have the AFL allowed these teams to make these contracts that will sink the team for years to come.
You can see a club doing it maybe for one or 2 players but they have Toby Greene and Coniglio on big contracts for another 4 yrs as well.
Trigger pulled...I like your style Jedi.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Tomlinson was going bloody well down back for Melbourne before he did his ACL last year. Was playing key back to allow Lever to play the intercepting role and was keeping Petty out of the team, who has subsequently gone really well since.
A team needing to add some height to defence could do far far worse than to get him. It’s no shame to be getting kept out by May, Lever and Petty, especially on your return from said ACL.
A team needing to add some height to defence could do far far worse than to get him. It’s no shame to be getting kept out by May, Lever and Petty, especially on your return from said ACL.
Given no one has nominated us, grab GCS's P32 for Long early and work on elevating our Draft position with BL who need major points for Ashcroft and Fletcher.
28 STK: 677
32 GC: 584
46 STK: 331
Subtotal: 1,592, just above Pick 8 all together.
I'd trade all of them for P15 from Bris (1,112pts). + Potential Hill, Bytel, Clark trades can assist this strategy.
No idea how Bris get Dunkley, Ashcroft (3000pts) and Fletcher (~1,000pts) done.
28 STK: 677
32 GC: 584
46 STK: 331
Subtotal: 1,592, just above Pick 8 all together.
I'd trade all of them for P15 from Bris (1,112pts). + Potential Hill, Bytel, Clark trades can assist this strategy.
No idea how Bris get Dunkley, Ashcroft (3000pts) and Fletcher (~1,000pts) done.
- Oct 18, 2011
- 11,875
- 33,089
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- St Kilda, Ocean Grove Collendina Cobras
Shierlaw as a intercept defender? A bit short but reads the play well and a great mark.
Grav
Cacas Suscito
A great one grab specialist, can kick goals too, our new Jake Carlisle?
- Oct 2, 2010
- 23,470
- 88,470
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
That pick 15 will have to go to the Dogs for Dunkley.
SchillaciSaint
Draftee
- Sep 3, 2021
- 13
- 38
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Getting Bowes and pick 7 would be a great get but seems really fanciful with little chance of happening. Ratugolea for a third or fourth round pick would also make me happy but aside from that I am not interested in any of the other names that have been thrown around.
It’s quite sad that we making up numbers on the lower rungs of the ladder whilst Geelong keep getting players of real quality through the trade period. It’s little wonder it’s seen as a destination club but it's amazing that they can fit them all in the cap.
It’s quite sad that we making up numbers on the lower rungs of the ladder whilst Geelong keep getting players of real quality through the trade period. It’s little wonder it’s seen as a destination club but it's amazing that they can fit them all in the cap.
Is that Psicosis? Seems an extremely weird unit.
The level of cope and delusion in their Clarko thread is also something to behold.
Unless they trade a Future 1st for Dunkley
Saint_Dos
Premiership Player
Bulldogs will want both this years and nexts given Brisbane likely to finish high on the ladder next year as well.
Brisbane would probably get something back in return (2nd rounder?)
gringo2011
Premium Platinum
He's been an okay pick up at where we took him but when we wanted Cyril and Shai Bolton who had been talked about as a top 12 pick literally drifted into our hands and was so much more Cyril.....you can see why Trout isn't here any more.
Most of us went "who the **** is Ben Long".
That said, if he stays he's decent depth and as much as we want it to be true not even GC are giving a second round pick for a depth player who isn't contracted. You'd ask and hope that they are so desperate to get on with other deals that they over pay, but just don't see it happening.
Any way you cut it, they've got a mammoth trade period, need to pull points from thin air- I hope we get involved in that space.
Esava for a late pick next year and 3 Top 30 picks this year please.
TBH given GC's situation we need to come away with a 2nd outright or it's a fail in my book.
What about getting GC pick 32, as you say, package them up, but for Bris 1st rounder next year, then trade to North pick 9 and Bris future 1st for pick 1?
IF Hill and Clark are still on the move (though I think Caro's article makes that harder), then we could almost trade that future back in as part of that deal?
CaptainRisky
Brownlow Medallist
By every stat he is below average so i guess he is a perfect fit
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Apr 24, 2021
- 11,561
- 19,413
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Captaincy experience from under 18s, good character, tough at the contest, good runner good tackler. Been played on the wing out of position, he’s exactly the type you steal for cheap
I remember watching our Intra Club and thinking Zac Jones was the clear standout. I was pretty bullish on his year ahead. So I’ve got absolutely no doubts that his personal time off at such a crucial stage of the year impacted his season majorly. He was definitely not the same player upon his return as he was when coming out of that preseason.
I don’t think he’s a world beater or some A Grade mid, but as you point out, when he’s flying he’s a great point of difference, and isn’t afraid to ruffle some feathers.
CaptainRisky
Brownlow Medallist
If he has been playing on the wing and getting the numbers he has been getting its a double no , He has had one good game for the season , next he will be bringing IP
Last edited:
- Apr 24, 2021
- 11,561
- 19,413
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Pushed to the wing/flanks is a pure inside mid. Similar to bytel getting crap numbers pushed out of position
- May 3, 2017
- 1,387
- 5,757
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Agreed with all of this. I think the way Jones plays lends himself to criticism because it highlights his deficiencies a little more than most. It’s an eye-catching style, good bad and otherwise. I still think we have use for his “good” and accept some of the “bad” along the way.
Similar threads
