Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2022 Trade Thread - Part III

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

He wouldnt be the worst selection, we definitely need players who can kick goals.

I still think at some stage, we are going to need to find another tall key forward/ruckman.

We see rucks fly around every year it seems. For what he cost, Grundy would have been pretty awesome but I'm also happy to go in with RoMa + Hayes next year.

Maxy Heath doing well enough in reserve and Tommy Campbell is playing on yeah?

Agree that we need another Hayes type forward who can pinch hit.
 
We see rucks fly around every year it seems. For what he cost, Grundy would have been pretty awesome but I'm also happy to go in with RoMa + Hayes next year.

Maxy Heath doing well enough in reserve and Tommy Campbell is playing on yeah?

Agree that we need another Hayes type forward who can pinch hit.
I can see Hayes being a Ross favourite
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

We see rucks fly around every year it seems. For what he cost, Grundy would have been pretty awesome but I'm also happy to go in with RoMa + Hayes next year.

Maxy Heath doing well enough in reserve and Tommy Campbell is playing on yeah?

Agree that we need another Hayes type forward who can pinch hit.

There are some in the draft.

Probably gone by our second round picks.
Harry Barnett.
Issak Keeler.

Maybe gone by our third round pick.
Harry Lemmey

Others:
Thomas Scully
Will Verrall
Phoenix Foster.
 
Speaking of fast???, apparently we have interest in Mitch Wallis :sick:
He spent the whole of the Elimination final in 2020 playing for free kicks and the umpires mostly obliged. Probably not a valid reason for passing on him but it would take a while for me to get over that.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Has limitations but can seriously play under the right coach
Very unlucky to be on the outer at freo even according to freo supporters
Agreed, can have the occasional good game, but never truly “cracked it”. Probably due to the combination of his work ethic and physical limitations.
I struggle to see where he fits with us, we don’t need a slow, one-dimensional mid, we already have Bytel.

Connor played juniors at a club in the South West near me and was in carnivals with my bro so I know him well. Reckon he fits the common bill of too good for VFL/WAFL, not quite good enough for AFL.
 
Agreed, can have the occasional good game, but never truly “cracked it”. Probably due to the combination of his work ethic and physical limitations.
I struggle to see where he fits with us, we don’t need a slow, one-dimensional mid, we already have Bytel.

Connor played juniors at a club in the South West near me and was in carnivals with my bro so I know him well. Reckon he fits the common bill of too good for VFL/WAFL, not quite good enough for AFL.
I don’t like the head on him, looks untrustworthy.
 
He wouldnt be the worst selection, we definitely need players who can kick goals.

I still think at some stage, we are going to need to find another tall key forward/ruckman.

I’m worried about Marshall’s ability to play out the whole year as no 1 ruck without injury.

Hopefully Max Heath comes on.
 
Last edited:
My main gripe with McKenna is that I don't think he'll last the distance, and I reckon we should be targeting players that have the potential to see out a contract and do the right thing by our club, rather than the right thing for a GAA club thousands of miles away. That call will always be there, and he's already done it once. Others see no issue with it, which is fine...it's just that I do...which is also fine.
What about Zak Jones to the HBF? Has pace, a bit of aggro, likes to take the game on (depending on his head space) and his kicking isn't as shocking as has been made out and he's more or less the same age as McKenna.
Agree , we have enough people who can run off the halfback line and not worry about there player they are meant to be defending.
This is why Sinclair is so good , he defends and attacks - Hill did ok there but was a worry if he had to defend.
It also has to be realized Coffield will be back and McKenzie could also be putting his hand up.
Jones mostly played as a halfback for the Swans and with the emergence of Owens , Windhager it may well force Ross , Clark to spend more time time back even if Sinclair is thrown into the midfield and you still have Highmore and Connolly playing at Sandringham.

I would be not be looking at picking a halfback when you have a lot of options when it comes to halfback.

A interesting thing as well , people are thinking Cordy is a instant inclusion into our 22 and if that is the case with
Paton - Howard - Wilkie
Sinclair - Cordy - Coffield

Where is Battle playing - because I would be playing Battle before Cordy , I fully expect Webster to be playing as well because if he holds his current form which is more than exceptable.

Whatever happens this year it is going to be good to see Ross Lyons team selections - could he get more out of Billings , can he get Hill to get back to his best - time will tell.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.


He saved the best for last. Smart campaigner. This is the kind of defender we need. One that’s too tight to pay for an Uber from Windy Hill to Moorabbin. Chauffeured all the way to his new locker.
 
Agree , we have enough people who can run off the halfback line and not worry about there player they are meant to be defending.
This is why Sinclair is so good , he defends and attacks - Hill did ok there but was a worry if he had to defend.
It also has to be realized Coffield will be back and McKenzie could also be putting his hand up.
Jones mostly played as a halfback for the Swans and with the emergence of Owens , Windhager it may well force Ross , Clark to spend more time time back even if Sinclair is thrown into the midfield and you still have Highmore and Connolly playing at Sandringham.

I would be not be looking at picking a halfback when you have a lot of options when it comes to halfback.

A interesting thing as well , people are thinking Cordy is a instant inclusion into our 22 and if that is the case with
Paton - Howard - Wilkie
Sinclair - Cordy - Coffield

Where is Battle playing - because I would be playing Battle before Cordy , I fully expect Webster to be playing as well because if he holds his current form which is more than exceptable.

Whatever happens this year it is going to be good to see Ross Lyons team selections - could he get more out of Billings , can he get Hill to get back to his best - time will tell.
Thank you Premo. It looks like we may be dodging a bullet there anyway. I reckon McKenna wants to go to a club ready to challenge. He seems to want either the Kennelly deal where gets a premiership in both Ireland and Australia, or he gets to go to a big club. I'm not sure we would be of much value to him on either front.

I could be wrong, but it's the vibe man.
 
Agree , we have enough people who can run off the halfback line and not worry about there player they are meant to be defending.
This is why Sinclair is so good , he defends and attacks - Hill did ok there but was a worry if he had to defend.
It also has to be realized Coffield will be back and McKenzie could also be putting his hand up.
Jones mostly played as a halfback for the Swans and with the emergence of Owens , Windhager it may well force Ross , Clark to spend more time time back even if Sinclair is thrown into the midfield and you still have Highmore and Connolly playing at Sandringham.

I would be not be looking at picking a halfback when you have a lot of options when it comes to halfback.

A interesting thing as well , people are thinking Cordy is a instant inclusion into our 22 and if that is the case with
Paton - Howard - Wilkie
Sinclair - Cordy - Coffield

Where is Battle playing - because I would be playing Battle before Cordy , I fully expect Webster to be playing as well because if he holds his current form which is more than exceptable.

Whatever happens this year it is going to be good to see Ross Lyons team selections - could he get more out of Billings , can he get Hill to get back to his best - time will tell.
Quote - "Whatever happens this year it is going to be good to see Ross Lyons team selections - could he get more out of Billings , can he get Hill to get back to his best - time will tell."

Answer - I hope Ross can get a bit more out of you mate. Time will tell.
 
Agree , we have enough people who can run off the halfback line and not worry about there player they are meant to be defending.
This is why Sinclair is so good , he defends and attacks - Hill did ok there but was a worry if he had to defend.
It also has to be realized Coffield will be back and McKenzie could also be putting his hand up.
Jones mostly played as a halfback for the Swans and with the emergence of Owens , Windhager it may well force Ross , Clark to spend more time time back even if Sinclair is thrown into the midfield and you still have Highmore and Connolly playing at Sandringham.

I would be not be looking at picking a halfback when you have a lot of options when it comes to halfback.

A interesting thing as well , people are thinking Cordy is a instant inclusion into our 22 and if that is the case with
Paton - Howard - Wilkie
Sinclair - Cordy - Coffield

Where is Battle playing - because I would be playing Battle before Cordy , I fully expect Webster to be playing as well because if he holds his current form which is more than exceptable.

Whatever happens this year it is going to be good to see Ross Lyons team selections - could he get more out of Billings , can he get Hill to get back to his best - time will tell.

Wilkie - Cordy - Paton/Webster
Battle - Howard - Sinclair/Coffield/McKenna

I think only one of Paton and Webster play. Sinclair, Coffield, Hill and McKenna (if he signs) will all rotate hb/wing/on ball.

Cordy takes the deep tall forward. Howard plays up the ground to hoof the ball into attack. Wilkie gets to play on blokes more his size and Battle stays as the interceptor.
 
Think we should seriously consider Will Hayward next year tbh



 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2022 Trade Thread - Part III

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top